MLB Picks

Get free expert and computer MLB picks for every game on May 12, 2026. With over 25 years of betting experience, our analysts and predictive models help you find the best value.

Los Angeles Angels logo LAA @ Cleveland Guardians logo CLE Tue, May 12 • 6:10 PM ET
1 Expert Pick 8 Computer Picks
Game Prop
Los Angeles Angels logo Cleveland Guardians logo YRFI/NRFI (No: -110)
Best Odds
Pick made: 2 hours ago
Quinn Allen image
Quinn Allen
Betting Analyst

The Los Angeles Angels and Cleveland Guardians could be in for another quiet first inning after a scoreless opener on Monday. Walbert Urena hasn’t allowed a first-inning run all season, while Cleveland has failed to score in the opening frame in three straight games. Slade Cecconi also tossed a clean first last time out.

Total Hits
Vaughn Grissom logo
Vaughn Grissom u0.5 Total Hits (+195)
Projection 0.9
Best Odds
Pick made: 5 minutes ago
EV Model Rating
Star rating: 3 out of 5
According to the weather forecast, the temperature and humidity for this contest will be the 3rd-best for pitching of all games on the slate today.. Hitting from the same side that Slade Cecconi throws from, Vaughn Grissom will have a disadvantage in today's game.. Vaughn Grissom will be at a disadvantage playing on the road in today's matchup.
View 9 Picks
New York Yankees logo NYY @ Baltimore Orioles logo BAL Tue, May 12 • 6:35 PM ET
3 Expert Picks 10 Computer Picks
Total
New York Yankees logo Baltimore Orioles logo u8.5 (+102)
Best Odds
Pick made: 5 hours ago
Chris Hatfield image
Chris Hatfield
Betting Analyst

Rogers’ 83rd percentile hard-hit rate is a significant factor here and always against New York. Simply put, when you’re able to limit the power swings of the Yankees, then the offense is much more pedestrian. Even though I think they’ll score enough to win by multiple runs, Rogers should be able to keep their offense in check. On the other side, Warren’s elite strikeout rate should navigate the Baltimore lineup effectively as we’ve noted above. I’d play this down to 8 with a projected run total of 7.9.

Spread
New York Yankees logo NYY -1.5 (+100)
Best Odds
Pick made: 5 hours ago
Chris Hatfield image
Chris Hatfield
Betting Analyst

Warren’s profile against this Baltimore team gives the Yankees runline value, and I’d play to -115. His 91st percentile strikeout rate should play well against a team with the 7th highest whiff rate in the sport. He had one of his best performances of the season earlier this year against Baltimore, pitching 6+ innings and striking out 9 while allowing just one earned run. I see similar dominance today. 

View 13 Picks
Colorado Rockies logo COL @ Pittsburgh Pirates logo PIT Tue, May 12 • 6:40 PM ET
1 Expert Pick 10 Computer Picks
Strikeouts Thrown
Paul Skenes logo Paul Skenes o7.5 Strikeouts Thrown (+100)
Best Odds
Pick made: 13 hours ago
Quinn Allen image
Quinn Allen
Betting Analyst

Paul Skenes has electric stuff, and this matchup against the Colorado Rockies sets up perfectly for a dominant outing. The Pirates ace owns a 2.36 ERA with 46 strikeouts in 42 innings, and Colorado strikes out more than any team in baseball. The Rockies are averaging over 12 Ks across their last three games, giving Skenes strong value to clear this number.

Total Bases
Oneil Cruz logo
Oneil Cruz o1.5 Total Bases (+105)
Projection 2.05
Best Odds
Pick made: 8 hours ago
EV Model Rating
Star rating: 4 out of 5
Oneil Cruz projects as the 11th-best home run batter in the majors, per the leading projection system (THE BAT X).. Oneil Cruz is projected to hit 1st in the batting order in this matchup.. The #2 venue in the league for boosting BABIP to lefties, according to the leading projection system (THE BAT), is PNC Park.. Hitting from the opposite that Michael Lorenzen throws from, Oneil Cruz will have an edge in today's game.. Oneil Cruz may have an advantage against every reliever from start to finish, since the bullpen of the Colorado Rockies only has 1 same-handed RP.
View 11 Picks
Washington Nationals logo WAS @ Cincinnati Reds logo CIN Tue, May 12 • 6:40 PM ET
3 Expert Picks 10 Computer Picks
Game Prop
Washington Nationals logo Cincinnati Reds logo YRFI/NRFI (Yes: -130)
Best Odds
Pick made: 2 hours ago
Quinn Allen image
Quinn Allen
Betting Analyst

The Washington Nationals and Cincinnati Reds matchup has all the ingredients for an early run. Brady Singer has allowed a first-inning run in four straight starts and owns just a 3-5 NRFI/YRFI record this season. Washington is hitting .315 in the first inning and has scored early in two of its last three games, making this YRFI very appealing.

Hits
Elly De La Cruz logo Elly De La Cruz o1.5 Hits (+185)
Best Odds
Pick made: 13 hours ago
Quinn Allen image
Quinn Allen
Betting Analyst

Elly De La Cruz is red-hot at the plate, batting .367 over the last week while recording three straight multi-hit performances. The Reds star also crushed Houston for seven hits in the previous series. He now faces struggling veteran Miles Mikolas, who owns an ERA above seven. De La Cruz is batting .333 against Mikolas lifetime and thrives at home with a .346 average.

View 13 Picks
Philadelphia Phillies logo PHI @ Boston Red Sox logo BOS Tue, May 12 • 6:45 PM ET
3 Expert Picks 9 Computer Picks
Total
Philadelphia Phillies logo Boston Red Sox logo o8.5 (+101)
Best Odds
Pick made: 15 hours ago
Tom Oldfield image
Tom Oldfield
Betting Analyst

With the Phillies heating up at the plate, I’m taking the Over tonight. It’s 7-3 in the visitors’ past 10 outings, and they scored 22 runs in the weekend series against the Colorado Rockies. That included four homers from Kyle Schwarber, with Alec Bohm and Harper also joining the party.

Philadelphia has also finished with 9+ hits in five of its last six games, so watch for solid production here, with Boston expected to use an opener before turning things over to Brayan Bello. The Red Sox offense is the biggest cause for pause here, but the possible return of Willson Contreras here would give the lineup a boost.

Moneyline
Philadelphia Phillies logo PHI (-138)
Best Odds
Pick made: 15 hours ago
Tom Oldfield image
Tom Oldfield
Betting Analyst

The Phillies have won 10 of their last 13 contests, and I like Bryce Harper & Co. in this spot against the Red Sox.

It also helps that the Phillies are handing the ball to Zack Wheeler tonight. He’s posted a 3.18 ERA so far this year, and Philadelphia has won all three of his starts. After an eyebrow-raising sweep of the Detroit Tigers, the Red Sox came back to earth with a weekend series loss, and they’re just 7-12 at Fenway this season.

View 12 Picks
Tampa Bay Rays logo TB @ Toronto Blue Jays logo TOR Tue, May 12 • 7:07 PM ET
4 Expert Picks 10 Computer Picks
Game Prop
Tampa Bay Rays logo Toronto Blue Jays logo YRFI/NRFI (Yes: -113)
Best Odds
Pick made: 2 hours ago
Quinn Allen image
Quinn Allen
Betting Analyst

Tonight’s all-lefty battle between Shane McClanahan and Patrick Corbin should lead to a scoreless opening inning. McClanahan has surrendered just one first-inning run all season and enters on a streak of three straight clean firsts. Corbin has also tossed five consecutive scoreless opening frames, while both offenses are batting around .230 in the first inning this year.

Total Home Runs
George Springer logo George Springer o0.5 Total Home Runs (+450)
Best Odds
Pick made: 4 hours ago
Mike DiStefano image
Mike DiStefano
Betting Analyst

George Springer is starting to heat up, notching three hits over his last three games. He's also the only Blue Jays batter projected to be in the lineup who has taken Shane McClanahan deep.

View 14 Picks
Detroit Tigers logo DET @ New York Mets logo NYM Tue, May 12 • 7:10 PM ET
2 Expert Picks 10 Computer Picks
Total
Detroit Tigers logo New York Mets logo u7.5 (-108)
Best Odds
Pick made: 2 hours ago
Ed Scimia image
Ed Scimia
Betting Analyst

Any offensive outburst for the Mets is likely to come before the Tigers' bullpen enters the fray, which was given a much-needed rest day on Monday following a reliever-by-committee approach on Sunday Night Baseball in Kansas City. I have even less faith in the Tigers generating runs off of Peralta, who has held Detroit hitters to a lifetime OPS of .419, and both teams are also a combined 6–14 to the O/U in their last 10 games.

Moneyline
New York Mets logo NYM (-145)
Best Odds
Pick made: 2 hours ago
Ed Scimia image
Ed Scimia
Betting Analyst

Jack Flaherty has failed to go longer than five innings in any of his last four starts, and has a 7.71 ERA in that span. He has seemingly lost all control, allowing 6.9 walks per nine innings this season. The Mets should be able to take advantage of those free passes to do a little something on offense and get a win behind Freddy Peralta tonight.

View 12 Picks
Chicago Cubs logo CHC @ Atlanta Braves logo ATL Tue, May 12 • 7:15 PM ET
2 Expert Picks 10 Computer Picks
Total
Chicago Cubs logo Atlanta Braves logo u8.5 (+100)
Best Odds
Pick made: 34 minutes ago
Shawn Krest image
Shawn Krest
Betting Analyst

Neither offense has looked particularly impressive over the last week, Atlanta showcasing a .606 OPS and 82 OPS+, and Chicago with a .644 and 94.

Moneyline
Chicago Cubs logo CHC (+108)
Best Odds
Pick made: 36 minutes ago
Shawn Krest image
Shawn Krest
Betting Analyst

Pay no attention to the Cubs getting blanked in back-to-back outings. They face a tired Braves team returning from the West Coast and deploying Grant Holmes, who has struggled relative to Jacob deGrom, one of the hurlers who shut Chicago down.

View 12 Picks
Kansas City Royals logo KC @ Chicago White Sox logo CHW Tue, May 12 • 7:40 PM ET
1 Expert Pick 10 Computer Picks
Total Home Runs
Bobby Witt Jr. logo Bobby Witt Jr. o0.5 Total Home Runs (+400)
Best Odds
Pick made: 14 hours ago
Jon Metler image
Jon Metler
Betting Analyst

Bobby Witt Jr. at +400 to hit a home run with the wind blowing out to his pull side at Rate Field at 18 mph? Yeah, I’ll gladly hit the button on that number. Erick Fedde has allowed five home runs over his last two starts, and seven of the eight home runs he’s given up this season have come against right-handed hitters. Witt also has notable reverse splits when it comes to power. Twenty-two of the 23 home runs he hit last season came against right-handed pitching. On top of that, Witt has been swinging a hot bat lately, and at +400, this is simply too good of a price to pass up.

Total Hits
Munetaka Murakami logo
Munetaka Murakami u0.5 Total Hits (+170)
Projection 0.85
Best Odds
Pick made: an hour ago
EV Model Rating
Star rating: 3 out of 5
The Kansas City Royals infield defense profiles as the 2nd-strongest among all the teams on the slate today.. Despite posting a .383 wOBA this year, the leading projection system (THE BAT X) believes Munetaka Murakami has had some very good luck given the .031 discrepancy between that figure and his estimated true talent wOBA of .352.
View 11 Picks
San Diego Padres logo SD @ Milwaukee Brewers logo MIL Tue, May 12 • 7:40 PM ET
3 Expert Picks 10 Computer Picks
Total
San Diego Padres logo Milwaukee Brewers logo u8.5 (+100)
Best Odds
Pick made: an hour ago
Shawn Krest image
Shawn Krest
Betting Analyst

The San Diego Padres have had trouble at the plate, however. In their series split with St. Louis over the weekend, San Diego managed just 14 hits—a franchise record low for a four-game series. Like the Padres, the Milwaukee Brewers have been below league average at the plate all season and even worse lately. Milwaukee has a .625 OPS with 88 OPS+ over the last week. The Padres are .590 and 76 over the last seven days.

Moneyline
San Diego Padres logo SD (+116)
Best Odds
Pick made: an hour ago
Shawn Krest image
Shawn Krest
Betting Analyst

The San Diego Padres haven’t been hitting, but they should be able to get things going against starter Brandon Sproat, a rookie who is winless in MLB. Sproat walks 5.3 batters per nine and allows 2.1 homers. All of his pitches rank in baseball’s bottom quartile.

View 13 Picks
Miami Marlins logo MIA @ Minnesota Twins logo MIN Tue, May 12 • 7:40 PM ET
2 Expert Picks 10 Computer Picks
Total
Miami Marlins logo Minnesota Twins logo o9.0 (+100)
Best Odds
Pick made: 6 hours ago
Josh Inglis image
Josh Inglis
Betting Analyst

Mother Nature should help generate some runs in Minnesota today with 19-mph winds screaming out to center field. Eury Pérez has been giving up home runs on fly balls, while Bailey Ober owns a groundball rate that ranks in the bottom half of MLB starters. In fact, both pitchers carry groundball rates below 37%. Add in a Minnesota Twins bullpen sporting a 6.93 ERA over the last two weeks, and the runs could keep coming all game long. THE BAT is projecting 10.32 total runs.

Moneyline
Minnesota Twins logo MIN (-107)
Best Odds
Pick made: 14 hours ago
Jon Metler image
Jon Metler
Betting Analyst

Eury Pérez, when right, has elite stuff and flashes true ace potential. The issue right now is that he doesn’t look fully locked in, and when he struggles, things can unravel quickly. In his last start against the Baltimore Orioles, Pérez walked five batters, which is a strong indication that he’s fighting his command at the moment. That’s something the Minnesota Twins are well-positioned to exploit. Minnesota’s lineup is anchored by experienced hitters like Josh Bell and Byron Buxton, who should have the discipline to stay patient against Pérez, work counts, and wait for pitches they can drive—or simply take their walks. The Twins are trading around -107 on the moneyline, but I make them closer to -135 favorites in this matchup.

View 12 Picks
Arizona Diamondbacks logo AZ @ Texas Rangers logo TEX Tue, May 12 • 8:05 PM ET
1 Expert Pick 10 Computer Picks
Moneyline
Texas Rangers logo TEX (-134)
Best Odds
Pick made: 4 hours ago
Joe Osborne image
Joe Osborne
Senior Betting Analyst

Zac Gallen’s road struggles have been impossible to ignore, carrying a 7.13 ERA away from Arizona, while MacKenzie Gore has pitched much better at home. The D-backs lineup is also ice cold, scoring two runs or fewer in five of their last six games. On top of that, Texas enters with arguably the best bullpen in baseball over the past month, giving them a clear late-game edge.

Total Hits
Corey Seager logo
Corey Seager u0.5 Total Hits (+200)
Projection 0.94
Best Odds
Pick made: 6 hours ago
EV Model Rating
Star rating: 3 out of 5
Globe Life Field ranks as the #30 ballpark in MLB for left-handed batting average, according to the leading projection system (THE BAT).. Globe Life Field has the 6th-deepest centerfield dimensions in the league.. Ranking in the 18th percentile, Corey Seager has notched a .201 batting average this year.
View 11 Picks
Seattle Mariners logo SEA @ Houston Astros logo HOU Tue, May 12 • 8:10 PM ET
2 Expert Picks 10 Computer Picks
Total
Seattle Mariners logo Houston Astros logo u8.5 (+100)
Best Odds
Pick made: 4 hours ago
Todd Cordell image
Todd Cordell
Betting Analyst

Houston has scored three runs or fewer in seven of eight. They're missing several key bats and it shows in their results. While Seattle is in better form, they sit 25th in runs per game and 26th in average. They're unlikely to score enough to push this game Over.

Moneyline
Seattle Mariners logo SEA (-150)
Best Odds
Pick made: 4 hours ago
Todd Cordell image
Todd Cordell
Betting Analyst

The injury-plagued Astros have scored three runs or fewer in seven of their last eight. That makes it difficult to win games, especially with one of the league's worst bullpens. Bryan Woo and the Mariners should find success Tuesday night.

View 12 Picks
St. Louis Cardinals logo STL @ Athletics Athletics logo ATH Tue, May 12 • 9:40 PM ET
10 Computer Picks
Total Bases
Brent Rooker logo
Brent Rooker o1.5 Total Bases (+120)
Projection 2.24
Best Odds
Pick made: 3 hours ago
EV Model Rating
Star rating: 4 out of 5
The leading projection system (THE BAT X) ranks Brent Rooker as the majors's 17th-best home run hitter.. Brent Rooker is penciled in 5th on the lineup card in this game.. The #2 ballpark in Major League Baseball for boosting offensive stats, per the leading projection system (THE BAT), is Sutter Health Park.. Sutter Health Park has the 4th-shortest fence height (on average) among all stadiums.. High temperatures are strongly correlated with more offense (and fewer Ks), and the weather report forecasts the hottest weather on the slate at 97°.
Total Bases
Jordan Walker logo
Jordan Walker o1.5 Total Bases (+115)
Projection 2.29
Best Odds
Pick made: 4 hours ago
EV Model Rating
Star rating: 4 out of 5
The leading projection system (THE BAT X) projects Jordan Walker in the 94th percentile when assessing his home run ability.. Jordan Walker is projected to bat 4th in the lineup in this matchup.. The #2 ballpark in Major League Baseball for boosting offensive stats, per the leading projection system (THE BAT), is Sutter Health Park.. Sutter Health Park has the 4th-shortest fence height (on average) among all stadiums.. High temperatures are strongly correlated with more offense (and fewer Ks), and the weather report forecasts the hottest weather on the slate at 97°.
View 10 Picks
San Francisco Giants logo SF @ Los Angeles Dodgers logo LAD Tue, May 12 • 10:10 PM ET
4 Expert Picks 10 Computer Picks
Total Home Runs
Andy Pages logo Andy Pages o0.5 Total Home Runs (+540)
Best Odds
Pick made: 2 hours ago
Josh Inglis image
Josh Inglis
Betting Analyst

Let’s head to Dodger Stadium on Tuesday night and grab a +540 Andy Pages dinger in one of the best matchups on the board. Adrian Houser is a bottom-10 starter in baseball right now. He owns the fifth-worst BlastContact% among MLB starters, as hitters are taking aggressive swings and squaring him up consistently. Twenty-one percent of his fly balls are leaving the yard, and his xFIP suggests the damage is sustainable. The setting also favors home runs with winds blowing out, and Pages has the third-fastest swing on the Los Angeles Dodgers over the last two weeks behind Shohei Ohtani (+235) and Max Muncy (+340). The Giants' bullpen is also one to target for runs. 

Total
San Francisco Giants logo Los Angeles Dodgers logo u8.5 (+100)
Best Odds
Pick made: 4 hours ago
JD Yonke image
JD Yonke
Betting Analyst

Yamamoto has dominated this lineup in the past, and he will probably do so again as the Giants have a lowly 87 wRC+ and .293 wOBA against right-handed pitching. LA’s star-studded lineup is in a cold stretch, posting a 91 wRC+ over the last 15 days and averaging 2.5 runs in its last four games

View 14 Picks
Milwaukee Brewers logo MIL @ St. Louis Cardinals logo STL Tue, Jul 7 • 2:15 PM ET
2 Expert Picks 2 Computer Picks
Total
Milwaukee Brewers logo St. Louis Cardinals logo u8.0 (-120)
Best Odds
Pick made: 7 days ago
Todd Cordell image
Todd Cordell
Betting Analyst

If Brandon Sproat can hold his own early, the Brewers will turn to an excellent bullpen that ranks fifth in xFIP and tied for third in homers allowed per nine innings.

Colder weather and Andre Pallante’s high ground-ball rate (50%) should allow the Cardinals to limit the long ball. That’ll make it difficult to score runs in bulk, helping keep this game Under the total.

Moneyline
Milwaukee Brewers logo MIL (-110)
Pick made: 7 days ago
Todd Cordell image
Todd Cordell
Betting Analyst

Brandon Sproat’s xFIP and SIERA are two full runs less than his ERA, suggesting he hasn’t pitched as poorly as it appears on the surface.

Andre Pallante has posted some concerning numbers against lefties (47.2% hard-hit rate, 13.2% barrel rate), and the Brewers have plenty of good ones in their lineup. This mismatch favors the visitors, and we'll take the Brewers on the ML.

View 4 Picks

What are Covers’ MLB Free picks and predictions?

Covers’ has more than 25 years of experience making smart MLB picks from the season’s first pitch to the World Series.

We find the best MLB odds and share our picks and baseball best bets for all the significant games of the baseball season right here on this page.

Our picks are researched and analyzed by experienced sports bettors looking for an edge to get the best value from their MLB betting.

Free MLB Expert Picks

Making smart MLB picks means looking beyond the favorites. Our free expert baseball picks will include a wide variety of bet types and markets.

Every day our baseball analysts look for quality baseball picks to share. You can expect well-researched picks on the money, run line, totals, player props, and much more.

Free MLB Run Line Picks

Run lines are what other sports like football and basketball refer to as point spreads. Run lines even the odds between two teams, offering bettors as close to an even matchup as possible. Our analysts research vital stats, pitching matchups, injuries, and more to give you the best possible edge before making your MLB run line bets.

Free MLB Totals Picks

Covers’ analysts make MLB Over/Under picks throughout the baseball season. Betting on MLB Over/Unders means choosing whether you think the combined total runs scored in a game will be Over or Under a specific run total set by oddsmakers.

Free MLB Moneyline Picks

Betting on the MLB moneyline means picking which team will win a game outright. While less common than picking the run line or even a prop, our analysts will always look for high-value baseball moneyline picks if they feel it’s the best bet.

Free MLB Prop Picks

There’s always value in MLB props. Our team scours through game, team, and player props to try and find opportunity and value. From strikeouts to home runs, expect well-researched MLB prop picks from Covers.

MLB Consensus Picks

Covers’ consensus MLB picks show you the odds and predictions that our vibrant community of bettors and players are making. Try our picks on with our free MLB contests for a chance at prizes and more.

Best Baseball Betting Sites

If you’re ready to bet on MLB picks, you first need to find the right sportsbook. The best MLB betting sites offer secure banking, best odds, bonuses, and reliable customer service.

More Free Picks

Covers’ staff of sports betting fans also offers a wide array of free picks for the NFL, NBA, NHL, NCAA basketball, and NCAA football.

MLB Free Picks FAQs

When do we release our MLB picks?

Covers’ MLB picks release on game day. Some significant matchups like playoff games release in the days leading up to the game.

What kinds of MLB picks do we make?

Covers provides free MLB picks covering many markets, including run lines, totals, moneylines, player props, and more.