Yankees vs Orioles Prediction, Picks & Odds for Today's MLB Game
Get free expert and computer MLB picks for every game on May 12, 2026. With over 25 years of betting experience, our analysts and predictive models help you find the best value.
Rogers’ 83rd percentile hard-hit rate is a significant factor here and always against New York. Simply put, when you’re able to limit the power swings of the Yankees, then the offense is much more pedestrian. Even though I think they’ll score enough to win by multiple runs, Rogers should be able to keep their offense in check. On the other side, Warren’s elite strikeout rate should navigate the Baltimore lineup effectively as we’ve noted above. I’d play this down to 8 with a projected run total of 7.9.
Warren’s profile against this Baltimore team gives the Yankees runline value, and I’d play to -115. His 91st percentile strikeout rate should play well against a team with the 7th highest whiff rate in the sport. He had one of his best performances of the season earlier this year against Baltimore, pitching 6+ innings and striking out 9 while allowing just one earned run. I see similar dominance today.
Paul Skenes has electric stuff, and this matchup against the Colorado Rockies sets up perfectly for a dominant outing. The Pirates ace owns a 2.36 ERA with 46 strikeouts in 42 innings, and Colorado strikes out more than any team in baseball. The Rockies are averaging over 12 Ks across their last three games, giving Skenes strong value to clear this number.
Elly De La Cruz is red-hot at the plate, batting .367 over the last week while recording three straight multi-hit performances. The Reds star also crushed Houston for seven hits in the previous series. He now faces struggling veteran Miles Mikolas, who owns an ERA above seven. De La Cruz is batting .333 against Mikolas lifetime and thrives at home with a .346 average.
There's so many reasons, I don’t even know where to begin with why I like this prop and price so much for Elly De La Cruz. For starters, De La Cruz is swinging a hot bat right now, with seven hits over his last three games, so you’re not buying into a slump or trying to catch a struggling hitter at the right time. He’s also facing Miles Mikolas in Great American Ball Park, one of the most hitter-friendly parks in baseball. Mikolas has already allowed nine home runs this season in just 134 at-bats. Another thing I love about this spot is that Mikolas rarely pitches deep into games, meaning De La Cruz should also get multiple at-bats against the bullpen. Because he’s a switch hitter, you also don’t have to worry much about losing a platoon advantage once the relievers come in. Whether it’s against lefties or righties, De La Cruz has shown he can take anyone deep this season. I think this prop should be trading much closer to +210.
With the Phillies heating up at the plate, I’m taking the Over tonight. It’s 7-3 in the visitors’ past 10 outings, and they scored 22 runs in the weekend series against the Colorado Rockies. That included four homers from Kyle Schwarber, with Alec Bohm and Harper also joining the party.
Philadelphia has also finished with 9+ hits in five of its last six games, so watch for solid production here, with Boston expected to use an opener before turning things over to Brayan Bello. The Red Sox offense is the biggest cause for pause here, but the possible return of Willson Contreras here would give the lineup a boost.
The Phillies have won 10 of their last 13 contests, and I like Bryce Harper & Co. in this spot against the Red Sox.
It also helps that the Phillies are handing the ball to Zack Wheeler tonight. He’s posted a 3.18 ERA so far this year, and Philadelphia has won all three of his starts. After an eyebrow-raising sweep of the Detroit Tigers, the Red Sox came back to earth with a weekend series loss, and they’re just 7-12 at Fenway this season.
Bobby Witt Jr. at +400 to hit a home run with the wind blowing out to his pull side at Rate Field at 18 mph? Yeah, I’ll gladly hit the button on that number. Erick Fedde has allowed five home runs over his last two starts, and seven of the eight home runs he’s given up this season have come against right-handed hitters. Witt also has notable reverse splits when it comes to power. Twenty-two of the 23 home runs he hit last season came against right-handed pitching. On top of that, Witt has been swinging a hot bat lately, and at +400, this is simply too good of a price to pass up.
Andrew Vaughn has popped up on the projections at Covers for the first time, with a fair home run price around +480 today. American Family Field ranks as the sixth-best home run park for right-handed hitters, and Vaughn is into his sixth game since missing most of the season, so the rust appears gone. He’s already homered, owns a .880 OPS, and his 35.3% BlastContact rate over the last 14 days ranks second in all of baseball, thanks to an absurd 47.1% SqUpContact rate. The right-handed bat also gets to attack knuckleballs today with Matt Waldron on the mound. Waldron’s floater can disappear quickly, and after a strong outing last time out plus a road start here, a rough performance feels more likely than another good one for a pitcher carrying a 7.71 ERA.
Mother Nature should help generate some runs in Minnesota today with 19-mph winds screaming out to center field. Eury Pérez has been giving up home runs on fly balls, while Bailey Ober owns a groundball rate that ranks in the bottom half of MLB starters. In fact, both pitchers carry groundball rates below 37%. Add in a Minnesota Twins bullpen sporting a 6.93 ERA over the last two weeks, and the runs could keep coming all game long. THE BAT is projecting 10.32 total runs.
Eury Pérez, when right, has elite stuff and flashes true ace potential. The issue right now is that he doesn’t look fully locked in, and when he struggles, things can unravel quickly. In his last start against the Baltimore Orioles, Pérez walked five batters, which is a strong indication that he’s fighting his command at the moment. That’s something the Minnesota Twins are well-positioned to exploit. Minnesota’s lineup is anchored by experienced hitters like Josh Bell and Byron Buxton, who should have the discipline to stay patient against Pérez, work counts, and wait for pitches they can drive—or simply take their walks. The Twins are trading around -107 on the moneyline, but I make them closer to -135 favorites in this matchup.
Zac Gallen’s road struggles have been impossible to ignore, carrying a 7.13 ERA away from Arizona, while MacKenzie Gore has pitched much better at home. The D-backs lineup is also ice cold, scoring two runs or fewer in five of their last six games. On top of that, Texas enters with arguably the best bullpen in baseball over the past month, giving them a clear late-game edge.
Houston has scored three runs or fewer in seven of eight. They're missing several key bats and it shows in their results. While Seattle is in better form, they sit 25th in runs per game and 26th in average. They're unlikely to score enough to push this game Over.
Yamamoto has dominated this lineup in the past, and he will probably do so again as the Giants have a lowly 87 wRC+ and .293 wOBA against right-handed pitching. LA’s star-studded lineup is in a cold stretch, posting a 91 wRC+ over the last 15 days and averaging 2.5 runs in its last four games
If Brandon Sproat can hold his own early, the Brewers will turn to an excellent bullpen that ranks fifth in xFIP and tied for third in homers allowed per nine innings.
Colder weather and Andre Pallante’s high ground-ball rate (50%) should allow the Cardinals to limit the long ball. That’ll make it difficult to score runs in bulk, helping keep this game Under the total.
Brandon Sproat’s xFIP and SIERA are two full runs less than his ERA, suggesting he hasn’t pitched as poorly as it appears on the surface.
Andre Pallante has posted some concerning numbers against lefties (47.2% hard-hit rate, 13.2% barrel rate), and the Brewers have plenty of good ones in their lineup. This mismatch favors the visitors, and we'll take the Brewers on the ML.
Covers’ has more than 25 years of experience making smart MLB picks from the season’s first pitch to the World Series.
We find the best MLB odds and share our picks and baseball best bets for all the significant games of the baseball season right here on this page.
Our picks are researched and analyzed by experienced sports bettors looking for an edge to get the best value from their MLB betting.
Making smart MLB picks means looking beyond the favorites. Our free expert baseball picks will include a wide variety of bet types and markets.
Every day our baseball analysts look for quality baseball picks to share. You can expect well-researched picks on the money, run line, totals, player props, and much more.
Run lines are what other sports like football and basketball refer to as point spreads. Run lines even the odds between two teams, offering bettors as close to an even matchup as possible. Our analysts research vital stats, pitching matchups, injuries, and more to give you the best possible edge before making your MLB run line bets.
Covers’ analysts make MLB Over/Under picks throughout the baseball season. Betting on MLB Over/Unders means choosing whether you think the combined total runs scored in a game will be Over or Under a specific run total set by oddsmakers.
Betting on the MLB moneyline means picking which team will win a game outright. While less common than picking the run line or even a prop, our analysts will always look for high-value baseball moneyline picks if they feel it’s the best bet.
There’s always value in MLB props. Our team scours through game, team, and player props to try and find opportunity and value. From strikeouts to home runs, expect well-researched MLB prop picks from Covers.
Covers’ consensus MLB picks show you the odds and predictions that our vibrant community of bettors and players are making. Try our picks on with our free MLB contests for a chance at prizes and more.
If you’re ready to bet on MLB picks, you first need to find the right sportsbook. The best MLB betting sites offer secure banking, best odds, bonuses, and reliable customer service.
Covers’ staff of sports betting fans also offers a wide array of free picks for the NFL, NBA, NHL, NCAA basketball, and NCAA football.
Covers’ MLB picks release on game day. Some significant matchups like playoff games release in the days leading up to the game.
Covers provides free MLB picks covering many markets, including run lines, totals, moneylines, player props, and more.