Royals vs Yankees Prediction, Picks & Odds for Tonight's MLB Game
Get free expert and computer MLB picks for every game on April 17, 2026. With over 25 years of betting experience, our analysts and predictive models help you find the best value.
This doesn't look like a pitcher's duel. Braves starter Martin Perez boasts a 3.14 ERA, 0.907 WHIP—but he's not fooling anyone, likely why he nearly lost his job.
Philly starter Taijuan Walker has posted a 7.36 ERA, 1.909 WHIP line, and opposing batters are hitting .333 with a .982 OPS against him. He's given up nine runs, 10 hits, and three homers in the first inning of his three starts this year.
Atlanta has the second-best run differential in baseball, behind only the Dodgers. They've also scored the second-most runs (5.6 per game) and allowed the second-fewest (3.3 per game) in MLB. Atlanta has won six of eight and has been even better in those games, scoring 6.9 runs per game.
Pittsburgh is hitting well, averaging five runs per game off a .734 OPS this year. Brandon Lowe has seven homers in his first 17 games, while Oneil Cruz and Ryan O’Hearn are also off to fast starts. Neither starter is likely to give their team much length tonight. There are soft spots that these lineups can take advantage of if it takes several arms to get through this game.
The Tampa Bay Rays are averaging 5.06 runs per game so far this season, and have put up at least five runs in every game of their current winning streak. They’ll have a great chance to keep that going tonight against Pittsburgh Pirates starter Bubba Chandler.
With both of tonight’s starters in a nice rhythm, I’m sticking with the trends that point to the Under, which is 7-2 in the last nine meetings between these teams – and 4-0 in the past four matchups at Yankee Stadium.
The Royals are giving their pitchers minimal run support. They’re averaging just 3.42 RPG, and all three of Wacha’s outings this season have fallen short of this 8.5 O/U mark. Meanwhile, for all the unquestionable offensive firepower that Aaron Judge and Co. bring to the party, the hosts have only posted a .214 batting average, the fourth-lowest in the majors.
With eight straight wins over the Royals, it’s fair to say the Yankees have their number. So I’m brushing aside the Bronx Bombers’ 3-7 mark across their past 10 contests, partly because Kansas City has the exact same record in that span.
As well as Michael Wacha has pitched this year, including a 0.43 ERA, the New York lineup has plenty of prior at-bats to lean on against the veteran righty. In contrast, none of the Royals’ hitters have faced Cam Schlittler before, and the Yankees phenom has racked up 7+ strikeouts in each of his four outings this season.
Ranger Suarez owns a 3.74 xFIP, which is well below his 5.02 ERA. That indicates he hasn’t pitched as poorly as the results suggest – and I’ve already highlighted the difficult competition he faced.
The Tigers are hitting .216 with a .083 ISO on the road and cold weather is expected, making this a good spot for Suarez to get back on track.
Casey Mize owns a solid 3.85 xFIP and has done a good job of neutralizing left-handed bets, setting him up for a quality start against Boston.
Both bullpens are also well rested so the managers will have plenty of options to help limit runs.
Ranger Suarez has had a difficult start to his Red Sox career but that coincides with very tough competition.
He has faced the Astros, Padres, and Cardinals. The Astros sit 4th in runs per game, the Padres sit 11th, and the Cardinals rank 7th in wRC+ against left-handed pitchers.
Suarez should get a little bit of relief against the Tigers. They have hit just .213 off lefties and rank 22nd in wRC+.
While most of the Red Sox top bats are lefties, they do have some good righties – most notably Willson Contreras and Ceddanne Rafaela – who could cause problems for Casey Mize.
Alvarez has come across the plate four times over the last three games. The Cuban also has four hits during that span, and he’s up against Kyle Leahy of the Cardinals tonight. Alvarez is 2-for-2 lifetime vs Leahy with two hits. The Astros are also batting .264 with RISP.
Jordan Walker has elite marks in swing speed and Blast Contact%, which have translated into a league-leading eight home runs. He gets a favorable matchup against Peter Lambert, who is making his debut and may only be in this spot due to injuries in the Houston Astros' rotation rather than performance. Lambert hasn’t pitched in the majors since 2024 and has allowed 25 home runs over his last 148+ innings in the MLB. He’s unlikely to go deep, which brings a vulnerable Houston bullpen into play — a unit that has already allowed the second-most home runs this season.
Pages has recorded a run in two of his last three games. He has five hits across his last five appearances as well. He’s putting himself in a great position to let his teammates do their thing and drive him in. The Dodgers are hitting .283 with RISP.
The Dodgers are a warranted heavy favorite given their advantages in starting pitching, relief pitching, and hitting. Tyler Glasnow has strong underlying metrics (2.60 xERA, 2.83 FIP) and a 107 Stuff+, whereas Tomoyuki Sugano has a worrisome 4.98 xERA and 5.39 FIP. Sugano’s 82 Stuff+ ranks 178th out of 184 pitchers who have started a game.
I started the week with a four-digit dinger, and I’m looking to bookend it with another. Vargas owns some of the best Blast Contact% marks on the Arizona Diamondbacks, which is enough at a +1200 price in a controlled environment. It gets better. Eric Lauer has been serving up meatballs, and Vargas has quietly posted a 1.068 OPS with plenty of extra-base hits. He hits lefties better, is moving up the lineup, and should also see favorable spots against a Toronto Blue Jays bullpen that can give up longballs.
Gimenez is 3-for-8 against Soroka with two of those hits leaving the yard. The Jays’ shortstop has shown some sneaky power this season, especially against the four-seamer, where he owns a .727 slug-rate against, which happens to be Soroka's most utilized pitch. He also has a .983 OPS against right-handed pitchers this season.
After a shaky start to 2026, Gilbert has calmed down, allowing just three earned across his previous two outings. deGrom has also given up just two earned runs in his last two starts. Texas and Seattle both boast solid bullpens, too. The Rangers have a 2.99 ERA, while the M’s own a 2.90 ERA. The Under cashed when these two pitchers met on April 6.
The Rangers hand deGrom the ball, who has a 2.87 ERA through three starts. The right-hander gave up only one earned run last time out to the powerful LA Dodgers. When it comes to facing this Mariners lineup, deGrom is utterly brilliant. Across 77 at-bats, he’s held them to a .182 average.
Covers’ has more than 25 years of experience making smart MLB picks from the season’s first pitch to the World Series.
We find the best MLB odds and share our picks and baseball best bets for all the significant games of the baseball season right here on this page.
Our picks are researched and analyzed by experienced sports bettors looking for an edge to get the best value from their MLB betting.
Making smart MLB picks means looking beyond the favorites. Our free expert baseball picks will include a wide variety of bet types and markets.
Every day our baseball analysts look for quality baseball picks to share. You can expect well-researched picks on the money, run line, totals, player props, and much more.
Run lines are what other sports like football and basketball refer to as point spreads. Run lines even the odds between two teams, offering bettors as close to an even matchup as possible. Our analysts research vital stats, pitching matchups, injuries, and more to give you the best possible edge before making your MLB run line bets.
Covers’ analysts make MLB Over/Under picks throughout the baseball season. Betting on MLB Over/Unders means choosing whether you think the combined total runs scored in a game will be Over or Under a specific run total set by oddsmakers.
Betting on the MLB moneyline means picking which team will win a game outright. While less common than picking the run line or even a prop, our analysts will always look for high-value baseball moneyline picks if they feel it’s the best bet.
There’s always value in MLB props. Our team scours through game, team, and player props to try and find opportunity and value. From strikeouts to home runs, expect well-researched MLB prop picks from Covers.
Covers’ consensus MLB picks show you the odds and predictions that our vibrant community of bettors and players are making. Try our picks on with our free MLB contests for a chance at prizes and more.
If you’re ready to bet on MLB picks, you first need to find the right sportsbook. The best MLB betting sites offer secure banking, best odds, bonuses, and reliable customer service.
Covers’ staff of sports betting fans also offers a wide array of free picks for the NFL, NBA, NHL, NCAA basketball, and NCAA football.
Covers’ MLB picks release on game day. Some significant matchups like playoff games release in the days leading up to the game.
Covers provides free MLB picks covering many markets, including run lines, totals, moneylines, player props, and more.