After a run of good polls, James Talarico has retaken the lead in Texas Senate odds at prediction market apps. Republican Ken Paxton is trying to keep the seat in red hands, while Talarico is trying to be the first Democrat to win statewide in Texas since 1994. A crucial state for 2026 Senate odds, Texas could decide who controls the Senate for the next two years.
The math behind the Texas odds shift
Talarico has just overtaken Paxton in odds, showing a 51% to 49% advantage at Kalshi as of Sunday morning, but it’s been a tight race overall for months. When Paxton was endorsed by Donald Trump, odds flipped then, before a run of decent polling for the Republicans moved the race. However, six straight polls showing Talarico ahead, and the Democrats’ significant fundraising advantage, have swung the market.
Democrats are trying to overcome a 14% margin in the state from 2024 this year. While the state is not as red as it used to be, it still voted 12% to the right of the nation as a whole. While the national environment is going to be bluer this year, currently the national generic ballot average is 6.4%, per Nate Silver’s average. Even accounting for the fact that Texas is more Hispanic than the country, and that Hispanics have swung back to Democrats since 2024 more than average, a 6.4% national lead is nowhere close to enough to flip Texas on its own.
Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account
Why the GOP gamble on Paxton could cost them
Ken Paxton primaried John Cornyn, who was a solid electoral performer whose last Senate race ended with him outrunning Donald Trump by 4% in 2020. The fact that Republicans primaried a proven winner hurts their odds; the fact they did it for someone with the laundry list of scandals Paxton has hurts them even more.
Paxton was indicted in 2015 on securities fraud, was impeached by the Texas House in 2023 for trying to use public funds to cover a settlement with whistleblowers, and was subsequently accused of committing numerous felonies in office, including misconduct in office to protect friends and donors and obstruction of justice on his securities fraud indictment.
While he was acquitted in the Texas Senate, the lengthy and public feud weakened Paxton, who already wasn’t a great electoral performer. In 2018, when Republican Governor Greg Abbott won the state by 13%, Paxton won by only 3% in his race for AG. The decision by Texas Republican primary voters to dump Cornyn for Paxton has moved Texas Senate odds, and made it harder for Republicans to win the state. With how close 2026 Senate odds are, this one seat could flip control of the chamber this November.
But it’s Texas, which means it’s bigger than just one Senate seat. Betting against Democrats’ hopes of blue Texas has been a reliable strategy in recent years, and the state’s partisan lean is a reliable argument it might happen again.
Beyond Beto: Is Talarico’s momentum real?
Picture this: Democrats are running a telegenic white liberal with a Hispanic-sounding name in a Trump midterm against a controversial, hard-line conservative Republican who has already won statewide in Texas. Polls show a tight race in Texas, and Democrats are riding high nationally, making Democrats hope that this could be the year it happens - even if the state did vote double digits right or the nation as a whole two years before.
Somehow this is not just describing Talarico.
There are many, many differences between Beto O’Rourke’s 2018 near miss and Talarico’s 2026 one. Beto only led in 2 polls all cycle, while Talarico has led in six in a row. Beto had to face an incumbent Senator whose controversies were hardline policies, not impeachment- and indictment-worthy accusations of misconduct. Cruz didn’t face a bruising primary where the incumbent Senator spent millions attacking him.
But Beto lost, and then two years later Joe Biden lost a much-hyped challenge to Texas’ red hue. Even in 2024, the effort to beat Cruz’s re-election outperformed Kamala Harris’ margin by nearly 6%, but still lost resoundingly.
Conclusion
As much as there is reason to believe Blue Texas is possible because of Paxton’s scandals and weaknesses, it’s also true that many (including myself!) have thought it would happen before now. It’s undeniable that Democrats have tried and failed to do this before.
It’s also undeniable that because it’s Texas, there is a whole mythology about this race that is unconnected from the math. Democrats (or Independents who caucus with Democrats) have won Senate seats in Alaska, Ohio, Iowa, Maine, and North Carolina - other than their core flip opportunities - since 2008. Democrats winning in those states has recent precedent. Their winning Texas doesn’t, which is why Democrats taking the lead in Texas Senate odds feels so totemic.
Democrats are favored to win their white whale, the state that has frustrated them, angered them, and baffled them for years. Republicans obviously still have a robust chance of winning the state, but Democratic hopes of winning the Senate got a big boost, deep in the heart of Texas.
