Panthers vs Maple Leafs Anytime Goalscorer Picks for Tonight

Round 2 play is upon us, and Tony Sartori has found three NHL goalscoring props for this Game 1 matchup between the Maple Leafs and Panthers.

Tony Sartori - Contributor at Covers.com
Tony Sartori • Betting Analyst
May 5, 2025 • 09:00 ET • 4 min read
William Nylander Toronto Maple Leafs NHL
Photo By - Imagn Images.

Monday’s NHL playoff slate features just one game, with the Toronto Maple Leafs hosting the Florida Panthers in the opening matchup of Round 2.

My NHL picks focus on three scorers for this May 5 matchup, highlighted by two Leafs and a Panther.

Panthers vs Maple Leafs anytime goalscorer picks

  • Red Wings Nylander (+210)
  • Red Wings Tavares (+230)
  • Red Wings Barkov (+250)

Panthers vs Maple Leafs goal props for May 5

William Nylander (+210 at Sports Interaction)

William Nylander finally broke through with a two-goal performance in the closing game of the first round. Those tallies marked his first time scoring since Game 1, and he’ll look to carry that momentum into the opening game of this series.

He’s likely to do so against goaltender Sergei Bobrovsky, who showed some vulnerability in the opening round. Over the final three games of the first round, Bobrovsky posted an .871 SV% and a 3.01 GAA.

In last year’s playoffs, Nylander scored in the final two games against Florida before the Maple Leafs were eliminated.

John Tavares (+230 at Sports Interaction)

Nylander’s linemate, John Tavares, is also a strong candidate to find the back of the net in Game 1. Tavares played a solid opening series against the Ottawa Senators, scoring three goals across six games.

This success is likely to continue against the Panthers. Tavares has scored in the past three meetings between these two teams, with Bobrovsky in net for all three games.

Not only do Nylander and Tavares skate together on the second line, but they also work the first power-play unit. In the regular season, Florida ranked last in the league in penalty minutes taken per game.

Aleksander Barkov (+250 at Sports Interaction)

The Panthers will likely find the back of the net at some point, and few candidates are stronger than Aleksander Barkov. The captain is the heartbeat of Florida’s two-way play, but he can also score.

He increased his offensive volume at the end of Round 1, averaging 3.3 shots on goal per game over the final three contests. Barkov broke through with a goal in the final game of that series and could keep rolling against Toronto and goaltender Anthony Stolarz.

Stolarz has played well this postseason, but he hasn’t been flawless. The Maple Leafs’ netminder has allowed two or more goals in all six games.

Sports Interaction: Canada’s home for NHL

Looking to bet on some NHL Playoffs action? Join Sports Interaction, the best in Canada for new bettors, and get a 125% bonus on your first deposit (up to $250)!

*Not available in Ontario. 19+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

Pages related to this topic

Tony Sartori - Covers.com
Betting Analyst

Tony Sartori has written over 1,000 pieces of sports betting content across multiple different media outlets. He covers the NHL, UFC, PGA, NFL and MLB. Tony started part-time while attending the University of Wisconsin-Madison, where he went on to receive a B.A. in Economics and a certificate in Entrepreneurship in 2022. He continues to work full-time in the sports betting landscape.

Due to the variety of sports he covers, Tony is handicapping every day. If he had one piece of betting advice for a new sports bettor, it would be to strictly enforce bankroll management rules for yourself. If you set aside $10,000 for your betting bankroll, then you should generally only be betting between $100 - $500 per play.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo