NFL First Touchdown Scorer Picks & Odds for Week 18

The end of the NFL regular season is upon us. Sam Farley lists three favorite first touchdown scorers, highlighted by Chiefs tight end Travis Kelce.

Sam Farley - Contributor at Covers.com
Sam Farley • Betting Analyst
Jan 3, 2026 • 10:03 ET • 4 min read
Travis Kelce of the Kansas City Chiefs NFL
Photo By - Imagn Images. Travis Kelce of the Kansas City Chiefs.

It’s the final week of the NFL regular season, and with so much to play for, we’re picking our top three selections to score first in their respective Week 18 NFL matchups.

Here are my best three NFL picks for Sunday, January 4.

Best Week 18 first TD scorer props

Player DraftKings
Jaguars Travis Etienne +290
Chiefs Travis Kelce +950
Browns Blake Whiteheart  +2200

Covers TD Bingo

Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account Add as a preferred source on Google

TD prop #1: Travis Etienne first TD scorer

+290 at DraftKings

At these odds, you’re not getting huge odds, but sometimes smaller odds can still offer reasonable value.

The Jacksonville Jaguars are big 13-point favorites against the Tennessee Titans and know they seal the division with a win, and potentially even the first-round bye, if other results go their way later in the day. The Titans have given up 18 touchdowns to opposing running backs this season and have been struggling against the run.

It's been a strong season for Travis Etienne, who has 13 touchdowns, of which seven were rushing, and six were in the passing game. He’s hit real form in the past month, too, with six touchdowns in that span. He’s scored the first touchdowns in three games this season, more than any other Jaguars player, and is a heavy favorite here.

TD prop #2: Travis Kelce first TD scorer

+950 at DraftKings

The Chris Oladokun experience continues for the Kansas City Chiefs this week, but the Las Vegas Raiders are a far easier proposition to face than either the Titans or last week's opponents, the Broncos. Not only that, but the Raiders actively want to lose this game, as seen with them shutting down Maxx Crosby. 

If anyone is going to score for the Chiefs on Sunday, then it’s Travis Kelce, in what could be his last game for the franchise. He’s scored five touchdowns this season but also leads the team in red zone targets since Oladokun has been under center. 

TD prop #3: Blake Whiteheart first TD scorer

+2200 at DraftKings

The Cleveland Browns are 7.5-point underdogs here against the Cincinnati Bengals, and everything points towards the Bengals getting the win, but there’s a huge value opportunity available. Both Harold Fannin Jr and David Njoku are out of the game, which gives Blake Whiteheart a chance to show off their talent.

The reason that a third-string tight end suddenly becomes an active consideration here is that the Bengals have given up 16 touchdowns to tight ends this season, the most of any team by a substantial margin. With both Fannin and Njoku out, we’re pivoting to Whiteheart to score first at huge odds.

Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

Pages related to this topic

Sam Farley
Betting Analyst

Sam is based in the United Kingdom, where he grew up living and breathing soccer, before discovering - and playing - a different kind of football at the University of Bristol. He’s worked in the media covering soccer and the NFL for the better part of a decade, and has been a regular on the Matchbook NFL Podcast. His work has also appeared in a wide range of publications including The Telegraph, The Independent, VICE, and MSN.

The search for great betting value is a daily one, and Sam always hunts out big prices with a particular focus on player props. Sam’s best advice for bettors is to track their bets on a spreadsheet, that way you can keep an eye on your P&L but also the types of bets and sports that you are most successful in. He also recommends using a variety of different sportsbooks, with bet365, Betfair and Paddy Power amongst his favorites.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo