March Madness Predictions: Our 3 Favorite Underdogs for the First Round

Jason Logan: Senior Betting Analyst at Covers
Jason Logan • Senior Betting Analyst 21+ years betting experience
Updated: Mar 16, 2026 , 12:23 PM ET • 4 min read

Jason Logan breaks down his favorite March Madness underdog bets for Round 1, featuring the TCU Horned Frogs.

TCU Horned Frogs NCAAM David Punch
Photo By - Reuters Connect. TCU Horned Frogs forward David Punch.

Upsets are how March Madness got its name. But for sports bettors, we don’t need a No. 15 seed to knock off a No. 2. We just need these March Madness underdogs to cover the spread.

This year, the tournament is top-heavy with 17 double-digit favorites on the odds board in the opening round. There’s plenty of points padding the underdogs, but finding a pup with pop could be tough.

Here are my favorite three underdog March Madness picks for the Round of 64.

Team Spread ML
Saint Louis Saint Louis (+2.5) -110 +125
VCU VCU
(+2.5)
-110 +115
TCU TCU
(+2.5)
-110 +115

No. 9 Saint Louis Bilikens vs No. 8 Georgia Bulldogs

Midwest Region, Thursday @ 9:45 p.m. ET, CBS

This one sizes up as a shootout, boasting the tallest total (170 O/U) for the entire Round of 64. In fact, there have been just five NCAA tournament games with a total north of 170 points since 1998.

The Georgia Bulldogs ran their way into the Big Dance, pushing insane pace and piling up the points. That’s just fine with the Saint Louis Billikens, who put the pedal to the metal as well.

Saint Louis has a few edges over UGA, starting with the fact that it actually plays defense. The Billikens also run deep, and are able to keep fresh capable scorers on the floor. Most importantly, SLU can light it up from long range.

Georgia’s 3-point shooting runs hot and cold while Saint Louis shoots better than 40% from beyond the arc and averages over 10 triples an outing.

Game models have this pairing as one of the closest contests of the Round of 64, with forecasts between one and two points for UGA. 

Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account Add as a preferred source on Google

No. 11 VCU Rams vs No. 6 North Carolina Tar Heels

South Region, Thursday @ 6:50 p.m. ET, TNT

The North Carolina Tar Heels are in trouble.

On top of losing star guard Caleb Wilson for the season, UNC got help from a home-friendly schedule in the back half of ACC play to pad its resume. They played six of their last 10 at home, and lost all four away games. 

The Tar Heels aren’t a great 3-point shooting team, and they leave far too many points at the foul line. I question UNC’s motivations with a talent-rich roster possibly weighing a transfer (and all that NIL money) if coach Hubert Davis gets the ax.

The VCU Rams have a completely different mentality in the Round of 64. The Rams have been fighting for their lives for the past two months after being a bubble team until the moment the horn sounded on their A-10 Championship win. 

Virginia Commonwealth attacks on every level: drawing fouls, crashing the glass, and playing tight defense. The Rams won’t be intimidated by UNC’s pedigree either, having played a tough non-conference slate.

No. 9 TCU Horned Frogs vs No. 8 Ohio State Buckeyes

East Region, Thursday @ 12:15 p.m. ET, CBS

I’m happy to see Ohio State Buckeyes stalwart Bruce Thornton finally get his time in the tournament, but it could be short-lived. 

The Buckeyes have a tough draw in the TCU Horned Frogs. Texas Christian enters the NCAA playing its best basketball of the season, with its only loss in the past month to Kansas in the Big 12 tournament (6-1 ATS).

The Horned Frogs can poke a soft spot for OSU, which coughs the ball up too much. TCU is terrific at flipping those mistakes into buckets, forcing almost 14 turnovers for 16 POTOV per game.

The Buckeyes are the better offensive team but see a significant dip away from Columbus, scoring 12 points less in foreign venues. Ohio State also has trouble cleaning the glass and the Frogs are opportunistic, snatching misses for second-chance putbacks.

Perhaps the biggest nod to TCU is its resume, which features wins over Florida, Texas Tech, Wisconsin, Iowa State, and a close loss to Michigan. The Buckeyes got fat beating up on the Big Ten’s so-so teams and are 3-10 SU in Quad 1 contests.

Covers March Tourney challenge
Join Covers' 25K March Tourney Challenge today!

Pages related to this topic

Jason Logan Senior Industry Analyst Covers.com
Senior Betting Analyst

In his 20 years with Covers, lead NFL betting analyst; has seen it all and bet it all. Through the wild west of early Internet gambling to lobbying for legalized sports betting to our brave new wagering world, Jason has been a consistent source of actionable info and entertainment for squares and sharps alike. Since joining the Covers team back in 2005, he honed his handicapping skills to provide audiences with the most thorough insights, blending traditional capping methods with advanced modelling and predictive analysis. Jason has studied the ins and outs of the sports betting business, learning from some of the most successful gamblers in the industry and the biggest sportsbook operators on the planet. He is under center for Covers during NFL season as our top NFL expert, taking the points in his infamous NFL Underdogs column and representing the Covers Community at the Super Bowl. While he lives for football season, Jason's first love is basketball and that shows in his in-depth NBA, NCAA, and WNBA betting breakdowns. On top of being a mainstay in media from coast to coast; WPIX, PHL17, Fox 5 San Diego, WGNO, TSN, SportsNet, ESPN Radio; he had his analysis featured in USA Today, MSNBC, ESPN, the Wall Street Journal, CBS, Bloomberg, the L.A. Times, the New York Times and other major publications. You can also find JLo stuffing all the top picks and predictions he can into 10 minutes as the host of Covers; flagship podcast, The Sharp 600.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo