Sometimes the market hands you a clean narrative, and the only mistake is trying to outsmart it. A rainy Thursday night script heavily favors the ground game, and the exchange has this offense priced to dictate terms.
Trading as 2.5-point favorites against the Washington Commanders at MetLife Stadium tonight (Thursday, Nov. 12), the New York Giants carry an implied total approaching 22 points, and the market expects a run-first red-zone approach. If you are positioning across Giants anytime touchdown scorer props, the math is overwhelmingly concentrated. Washington's defense hemorrhages points, allowing touchdowns on 75% of opponent red-zone trips.
Factor in Tyrone Tracy's absence, and the backfield workload suddenly funnels into a highly predictable vacuum. In a wet-weather script against a soft interior, back the contracts anchored to guaranteed downhill volume over speculative perimeter shots.
Top New York Giants anytime touchdown predictions
For help understanding Kalshi probabilities, please see our odds calculator.
| Player | Position |  Probability |
Index score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Devin Singletary | Running back | 26% | 71 |
| Cam Skattebo | Running back | 41% | 71 |
| Gregory Desrosiers | Running back | 3% | 63 |
| Theo Johnson | Tight end | 10% | 62 |
| Darnell Mooney | Wide receiver | 10% | 62 |
| Malik Nabers | Wide receiver | 37% | 62 |
| Malachi Fields | Wide receiver | 18% | 61 |
| Isaiah Likely | Tight end | 33% | 61 |
| J.J. McCarthy | QB | 16% | 60 |
| New York Giants D/ST | Defense/special teams | 14% | 48 |
Start trading with Kalshi today!
Sign up now using our exclusive Kalshi promo code 'MAX60' and trade $25 on any event contracts to get $60!
*Eligible U.S. locations only
Devin Singletary anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Singletary's season carry share is 17%, but it has risen to 35% over the last three weeks and 40% across the two-game comparison window. Tracy's absence creates further volume.
The matchup: Washington's interior has struggled to end red-zone drives, giving Singletary a route through duo and inside zone against the defensive tackles and Mike linebacker. His best chance comes when Skattebo rotates out after consecutive early-down carries.
The value: The submitted 26% market level is equivalent to approximately +285 American odds. The working fair range is 31% to 36% (midpoint 33.5%), creating a positive gap of 5 to 10 percentage points. The edge is credible if Singletary receives a true series share and at least one inside-the-10 carry. The price is attractive despite the committee.
Cam Skattebo anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Skattebo owns 42% of New York's season carries and remains the back most associated with the lead rushing role. His recent dip reflects missed or limited work rather than a fully displaced role.
The matchup: Washington's 75% red-zone touchdown rate allowed puts the linebackers under pressure against downhill concepts. Skattebo's clearest path is power or duo behind the interior line, especially in a wet-weather positive script.
The value: The submitted 41% market level is equivalent to approximately +144 American odds. The working fair range is 42% to 47% (midpoint 44.5%), creating a positive gap of 1 to 6 percentage points. The price is supported if his hamstring allows the expected goal-line workload and Singletary does not take the first red-zone series. The price is slightly attractive, though already expensive.
Gregory Desrosiers anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Desrosiers is a depth back whose opportunity expands only because Tracy is unavailable and the top two backs carry recent health or workload questions. His baseline role is too small for confidence.
The matchup: He would likely face Washington's reserve front in a late series or spell package. A draw from spread personnel or a fourth-quarter goal-line carry in a favorable script is the narrow scoring route.
The value: The submitted 3% market level is equivalent to approximately +3233 American odds. The working fair range is 5% to 8% (midpoint 6.5%), creating a positive gap of 2 to 5 percentage points. The market offers enough compensation only if he is active and clearly third in the backfield rotation. The price is appealing, but the role risk is severe.
Theo Johnson anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Johnson has only a 3% season target share and no target share over the last three weeks, so his case rests on specialized tight-end deployment rather than general volume.
The matchup: Washington's linebackers must fit the run against heavy personnel, creating a possible play-action leak for an attached tight end. Johnson can score on a delayed release, but he may also stay in to protect against the edge rush.
The value: The submitted 10% market level is equivalent to approximately +900 American odds. The working fair range is 13% to 17% (midpoint 15.0%), creating a positive gap of 3 to 7 percentage points. The value requires a goal-line route; ordinary snaps and blocking work are not enough. The price is attractive only at long odds.
Darnell Mooney anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Mooney has a 10% season target share and 9% recently, plus occasional rushing involvement. His role supplies speed and spacing but not a high target floor.
The matchup: Working from the slot or reduced splits lets Mooney cross behind linebackers occupied by play-action. His best scoring route is an over route or slot fade against Washington's nickel and post safety exchange.
The value: The submitted 10% market level is equivalent to approximately +900 American odds. The working fair range is 14% to 18% (midpoint 16.0%), creating a positive gap of 4 to 8 percentage points. The edge depends on at least one designed vertical or red-zone target, not raw route count. The price is attractive at a double-digit probability.
Malik Nabers anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Nabers commands 30% of New York targets and 33% over the last three weeks, the strongest receiving share in this game. The question is price, not role.
The matchup: McCarthy has attacked outside the numbers on 41.2% of throws, aligning with Nabers' boundary volume. Washington can roll safety help toward him, so a slant or back-shoulder throw from a condensed split is cleaner than a pure isolated fade.
The value: The submitted 37% market level is equivalent to approximately +170 American odds. The working fair range is 30% to 35% (midpoint 32.5%), creating a negative gap of 2 to 7 percentage points. His target dominance is real, but the price assumes an aggressive touchdown conversion rate. The price is too short despite elite volume.
Malachi Fields anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Fields has grown from a 13% season target share to 19% over the last three weeks. That expansion gives him a meaningful secondary route role opposite Nabers.
The matchup: Safety attention toward Nabers can isolate Fields against the other outside corner. A deep comeback-and-go or red-zone back-shoulder target is the primary route, although rain may reduce downfield efficiency.
The value: The submitted 18% market level is equivalent to approximately +456 American odds. The working fair range is 18% to 22% (midpoint 20.0%), creating a range spanning +0 to +4 percentage points versus market. The market is supportable if his 19% recent share persists and includes an end-zone look. The price is fair with modest upside.
Isaiah Likely anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Likely owns a substantial 27% season target share, though that has eased to 22% recently. He remains a featured receiver rather than a conventional secondary tight end.
The matchup: His detached alignments can force Washington safeties and linebackers into difficult exchanges, particularly off play-action. The best design is a seam or corner route behind linebackers stepping toward Skattebo.
The value: The submitted 33% market level is equivalent to approximately +203 American odds. The working fair range is 27% to 31% (midpoint 29.0%), creating a negative gap of 2 to 6 percentage points. The role is strong, but the market price already assumes he converts a large portion of New York's red-zone passing chances. The price is too short at 33%.
J.J. McCarthy anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: McCarthy accounts for 8% of recent team carries, creating some scramble equity without establishing a dedicated goal-line rushing role. His hip carried no final designation.
The matchup: Washington's edge pressure can either close the pocket or open an interior scramble lane if contain breaks down. His touchdown route is a red-zone scramble or sneak, not a high-volume designed-run package.
The value: The submitted 16% market level is equivalent to approximately +525 American odds. The working fair range is 15% to 19% (midpoint 17.0%), creating a range spanning -1 to +3 percentage points versus market. The range assumes full mobility and at least one short-yardage decision kept by the quarterback. The price is approximately fair.
New York Giants D/ST anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: New York's defense ranks among the league leaders in blitz frequency, giving it sack-fumble access but also exposing it to quick throws. Return touchdowns remain much rarer than pressures.
The matchup: Daniels' mobility makes clean sacks difficult, yet edge pressure can attack his ball security and force hurried throws. The best scoring route is a strip-sack recovered in space rather than a conventional interception return.
The value: The submitted 14% market level is equivalent to approximately +614 American odds. The working fair range is 7% to 9% (midpoint 8.0%), creating a negative gap of 5 to 7 percentage points. The price overstates how often a productive pressure game becomes an actual defensive touchdown. The price is too short.
Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account
Game script & market context
New York carries an implied total of approximately 21.75 points in a 41-point game. As a 2.5-point favorite, the likely script supports Skattebo and Singletary, although Washington scoring first would push more volume toward Nabers, Fields and Likely. Wet conditions modestly favor shorter throws and the run game. The principal distribution risk is a split backfield: Singletary's recent share has climbed, but Skattebo remains the stronger touchdown-specific runner.
For analysis across the full slate, see our NFL Week 10 anytime touchdown predictions.
Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.
