Taking a 47.5-point total across the Atlantic usually requires a leap of faith, but a crisp forecast at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium offers a remarkably clean track. Pair dry conditions with a vulnerable Washington secondary, and the scoring math gets much simpler.
If you're sorting through Indianapolis Colts anytime touchdown scorer picks, the foundation is an implied team total of approximately 25.5. Laying 3.5 points as an international favorite, Indianapolis is priced to cross the goal line at least three times.
The real betting edge could come from structural attrition. With deep threat Alec Pierce landing on injured reserve, the Colts' perimeter route tree condenses, potentially funneling more high-leverage opportunities toward the remaining slot receivers and tight ends in this week's NFL picks.
Top Colts anytime touchdown predictions
| Player | Position |  Probability |
Index Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jonathan Taylor | RB | 70% | 71 |
| Keenan Allen | WR | 25% | 63 |
| Seth McGowan | RB | 11% | 58 |
| Tyler Warren | TE | 36% | 56 |
| Daniel Jones | QB | 18% | 55 |
| Josh Downs | WR | 33% | 55 |
| Mo Alie-Cox | TE | 7% | 50 |
| Indianapolis D/ST | D/ST | 13% | 50 |
| Darius Slayton | WR | 14% | 46 |
| Laquon Treadwell | WR | 16% | 45 |
Market note: Kalshi Probability is the submitted probability or the implied probability calculated directly from the submitted market price. Index Score measures relative value, not the player's raw probability of scoring.
Start trading with Kalshi today!
Sign up now using our exclusive Kalshi promo code 'COVERS60' and trade $25 on any event contracts to get $60!
*Eligible U.S. locations only
Jonathan Taylor anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Taylor has 13 red-zone opportunities, including five close-range chances, giving him one of the Colts' most concentrated scoring roles. His biggest competition near the goal line comes from the other backs and any Daniel Jones keeper.
The matchup: Daron Payne, Tim Settle, and Javon Kinlaw anchor a Washington run defense that has been much stronger than its pass coverage. Taylor's clearest touchdown route is running duo behind Quenton Nelson into the Commanders' interior front.
The value: The Kalshi price implies a 70% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 55.3%, creating a negative gap of 14.7 percentage points. The price is too short unless Indianapolis creates more goal-line volume for Taylor than his current usage suggests. The Index Score of 71 measures relative value, not touchdown probability.
Keenan Allen anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Allen has logged three red-zone opportunities and three close-range chances, giving him a usable scoring role behind the offense's primary option. Route participation becomes particularly valuable when it produces an end-zone target or designed touch near the goal line.
The matchup: Mike Sainristil and Frankie Luvu are the primary stress points for option routes and inside releases. Allen's cleanest touchdown path is a choice route that isolates either a linebacker or nickel defender.
The value: The Kalshi price implies a 25% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 28.4%, creating a positive gap of 3.4 percentage points. The price is slightly attractive if Indianapolis can repeatedly isolate Allen inside. The Index Score of 63 measures relative value, not touchdown probability.
Seth McGowan anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: McGowan has only one red-zone opportunity and no close-range chances, so his touchdown case depends more on a specialized package than steady volume. His biggest competition comes from Taylor and any quarterback keeper around the goal line.
The matchup: Washington's linebackers move well laterally, but screens can punish Odafe Oweh and K'Lavon Chaisson for getting too far upfield. McGowan's cleanest path is a red-zone changeup screen after Taylor draws defenders into the box.
The value: The Kalshi price implies an 11% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 21.2%, creating a positive gap of 10.2 percentage points. The price is attractive if Indianapolis creates that changeup role for him. The Index Score of 58 measures relative value, not touchdown probability.
Tyler Warren anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Warren has logged three red-zone opportunities and two close-range chances, giving him a legitimate scoring role even if he still trails the offense's primary option. His route value must also be balanced against blocking assignments and the other tight ends in the package.
The matchup: Frankie Luvu, Sonny Styles, and Nick Cross divide seam and hook responsibilities, which can create leverage conflicts off play action. Warren's cleanest touchdown path is bending a seam between Luvu and Cross.
The value: The Kalshi price implies a 36% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 26.7%, creating a negative gap of 9.3 percentage points. The price is too short unless Warren's red-zone route volume increases. The Index Score of 56 measures relative value, not touchdown probability.
Daniel Jones anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Jones has logged two red-zone opportunities and no close-range chances. His scoring path therefore depends on designed keepers, sneaks, or pressure-created scrambles rather than passing volume.
The matchup: Oweh and Chaisson can widen while reacting to Taylor action, leaving a selective keeper available if Jones reads the edge correctly. His cleanest touchdown route is a read-option keeper when Washington's edge defender crashes on Taylor.
The value: The Kalshi price implies an 18% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 19.3%, creating a small positive gap of 1.3 percentage points. The price is slightly attractive if Indianapolis gives Jones a designed keeper near the goal line. The Index Score of 55 measures relative value, not touchdown probability.
Josh Downs anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Downs has logged four red-zone opportunities but no close-range chances. His route participation is useful, but it only translates into touchdown value if Indianapolis can create an end-zone target or designed touch.
The matchup: Sainristil and Luvu are again the stress points on option routes and inside releases. Downs' cleanest scoring path is a whip route that punishes an inside-leverage mistake.
The value: The Kalshi price implies a 33% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 25.4%, creating a negative gap of 7.6 percentage points. The price is too short unless Downs' red-zone role becomes more aggressive. The Index Score of 55 measures relative value, not touchdown probability.
Mo Alie-Cox anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Alie-Cox has not recorded a red-zone opportunity through Week 3, leaving little evidence of a repeatable touchdown package. His route value also has to be weighed against blocking assignments and the other tight ends on the field.
The matchup: Payne and Javon Kinlaw can demand blocking help, narrowing release volume for attached tight ends. Alie-Cox's cleanest touchdown route is a heavy play-action target toward the back pylon.
The value: The Kalshi price implies a 7% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 7.4%, creating a small positive gap of 0.4 percentage points. The market is essentially fair, with the scoring case dependent on Indianapolis dialing up that specific play-action look. The Index Score of 50 measures relative value, not touchdown probability.
Laquon Treadwell anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Treadwell has not recorded a red-zone opportunity through Week 3, meaning there is no current evidence of a repeatable scoring package. His touchdown case depends almost entirely on route deployment creating an isolated end-zone target.
The matchup: Amik Robertson and Mike Sainristil protect the outside with Nick Cross available as closing safety help. Treadwell's clearest touchdown route is an isolated fade after Washington compresses toward Taylor and the running game.
The value: The Kalshi price implies a 16% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 7.4%, creating a negative gap of 8.6 percentage points. The price is too short without evidence of a larger goal-line role. The Index Score of 45 measures relative value, not touchdown probability.
Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account
Game script & prediction context
Indianapolis carries an implied team total of approximately 25.5 in a 47.5-point environment. As a 3.5-point favorite, the likely script favors balanced production with favorable passing efficiency.
The Colts can lean on Jonathan Taylor if they control the game, but Washington's early profile has been stronger against the run than the pass. That split could funnel the more attractive touchdown opportunities toward Keenan Allen, Josh Downs, and Tyler Warren if the Commanders force Daniel Jones to beat them through the air rather than simply feeding the backfield.
International travel and Washington's quarterback uncertainty create wider-than-normal game-script variance, although the mild forecast should not restrict either offense.
For analysis across the full slate, see our NFL Week 4 anytime touchdown predictions.
Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.
