Red Sox vs Yankees Props Picks & Best Bets for Sunday Night Baseball

Expect Carlos Rodon to deliver in more ways than one, as we’re backing the New York southpaw to generate plenty of swings and misses tonight.

Chris Hatfield - Contributor at Covers.com
Chris Hatfield • Betting Analyst
Aug 24, 2025 • 14:15 ET • 4 min read
Carlos Rodon New York Yankees MLB
Photo By - Imagn Images. New York Yankees starting pitcher Carlos Rodon (55).

The Boston Red Sox and New York Yankees will finish off a series this evening in the Bronx as New York looks to salvage a win from the four-game set.

We are solely targeting Yankees for tonight, so join me as I break down my Sunday Night Baseball player props for August 24.

Make sure to also check out Neil Parker's Red Sox vs. Yankees predictions before first pitch!

Red Sox vs Yankees Sunday Night Baseball props

  • Yankees Rodon o6.5 strikeouts (-130)
  • Yankees McMahon to record a hit (-130)
  • Yankees Chisholm Jr. to record a hit (-141)

Double your winnings for 10 separate bets at Caesars

Sign up for a Caesars account — using our exclusive promo code BASEBALLDYW — and get 10x profit boost tokens worth 100% each!

Caesars Sportsbook

Register now to collect your Double your winning tokens, or learn more with our comprehensive Caesars Sportsbook review.

Prop #1: Carlos Rodon Over 6.5 strikeouts

-130 at Caesars

In desperate need of a lift to break out of the recent dominance by their rival, the New York Yankees will turn to the arm that has been pitching like the ace of the staff for the last month. 

My personal projection and The Bat X were aligned at 7.0 on Carlos Rodon's strikeout prop, but that number could be low given the expected length I could see him providing.

While the Boston Red Sox offense has shown up in this series, the strikeouts have picked up over the last month. This holds particularly true against southpaws, as the K% has risen roughly 5% in that period.

Given all the situational elements at play here, along with the Bat X projection, I feel comfortable backing this number.

Prop #2: Ryan McMahon to record a hit

-130 at Caesars

I don’t usually back Ryan McMahon to do something offensively, but few starting pitchers throw the sweeper as much as Dustin May does.

And wouldn't you know it, this is one of the rare pitches that the newly acquired Yankee shines against offensively.

May will enter this game throwing the sweeper 40% of the time, and it’s a pitch that McMahon leads all Yankees in for key metrics such as slugging, hard-hit rate, and expected batting average.

Prop #3: Jazz Chisholm Jr. to record a hit

-141 at Caesars

Unlike McMahon, Jazz Chisholm Jr. has no head-to-head history against Dustin May in his career. But like McMahon, Chisholm is well-positioned to take advantage of the pitch mix he’ll see.

The Yanks' second baseman also fares strongly against the sweeper, with most hitting metrics coming in directly behind McMahon.

In addition, Chisholm has had a great season against the sinker, which is May's secondary pitch. He enters tonight with a batting average and expected batting average against the pitch that places him in the 90th percentile of baseball.

Chisholm’s underrated power often gets overlooked, but he’s well capable of attacking May’s hard-hit rate, which sits in the bottom 15 percent of the league. This is a pretty nice discount on a strong hitter to get a knock.

Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

Pages related to this topic

Chris Hatfield - Covers.com
Betting Analyst

Chris has always had a passion for three things: solving problems, sports, and writing. It’s no wonder then that he found himself attracted to the sports betting industry. You can find Chris betting every day. Whether it’s shot prop markets in Champions League Soccer qualifiers or NBA Summer League, he has no offseason. As an EV+ bettor, he especially values the insight gained through a data-driven approach.

His work has been featured on various websites such as SBNation, Rivals, Bleacher Report, and 247Sports. He has appeared on radio outlets such as ESPN 680 and The Sharp 600 podcast. You can listen to his own podcast, “What High School Did You Go To?” on Apple Podcast and Soundcloud.

Chris has carved out a niche as a college basketball originator with massive profitability success in that sport and stresses one piece of advice to sports bettors: exploit edges as broadly as possible and take advantage of them while they last. His preferred sportsbook is bet365 because of the range of markets you can find.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo