Our Favorite MLB Props & Best Bets for Today: Sept. 16

Colby Marchio - Contributor at Covers.com
Colby Marchio • Betting Analyst 7+ years betting experience
Updated: Sep 16, 2026 , 12:56 PM ET • 4 min read

JR Ritchie owns a 23.3% walk rate over his last 30 left-handed hitters faced, making the over on his walks a strong look this evening against the Cubs.

JR Ritchie Atlanta Braves MLB
Photo By - Reuters Connect. Atlanta Braves pitcher JR Ritchie (60) throws against the New York Mets in the eighth inning at Truist Park.

Baseball all day long! We have so much to get into from the MLB player props market today. Let's dive in!

Join me as I break down three of my favorite MLB picks for Wednesday, Sept. 16, including why the Riley Greene is going to pop off against Max Scherzer.

Our best MLB player props for today

Player  Pick Odds
Yankees Luis Garcia Jr. Over 1.5 Total Base -104
Braves JR Ritchie Over 2.5 Walks Allowed +141
Tigers Riley Greene Over 1.5 Hits, Runs, RBI -115
Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account Add as a preferred source on Google

Luis Garcia Jr. Over 1.5 Total Bases (-104)

Run Luis Garcia Jr. BACK!

The New York Yankees first baseman did cash his hits, runs and RBI prop last night, but failed to go over 1.5 total bases. This afternoon against Minnesota Twins right-hander Zebby Matthews should get him back on track.

Garcia, over his last 10 games, has a .486 SLG, .550 xSLG, while generating just a 32% ground-ball rate, a hard-hit rate over 57% and a near-18% barrel rate.

Matthews has been struggling against left-handed hitters as of late. The last 30 he has faced are owning him, producing a 50% hard-hit rate, 13.6% barrel rate and 31.8% ground-ball rate. They also have a .304 xBA, .627 xSLG and .572 xwOBA.

If you like multiple Yankees, take their first-five team total. However, for this prop, do not take it below -105.

  • Time: 1:40 p.m. ET
  • Where to watch: YES, MNNT

JR Ritchie Over 2.5 Walks Allowed (+141)

We cashed Martin Perez over 1.5 walks allowed in the first inning last night, and now we are running it right back with another Atlanta Brave struggling to give up walks, that being right-hander JR Ritchie.

We are sweating out an extra walk, but Ritchie owns a 15.63% walk rate over his last five starts. Overall on the season, he is still at 14%. Against the last 30 left-handed hitters faced, Ritchie owns a 23.3% walk rate. The Chicago Cubs lineup will have five left-handed hitters this evening. Smirk

So far this season at home, the Cubs own the highest walk rate in baseball. Over their last 12 games, they have maintained an 11% walk rate, which ranks third-best.

Three is a lot of walks, but with how much Ritchie has been struggling to find the zone, this could be a fun sweat at +141.

Take this down to +120.

  • Time: 7:40 p.m. ET
  • Where to watch: BravesVsn, MARQ

Riley Greene Over 1.5 Hits, Runs, RBI (-115)

One of the most stressful teams to back for me personally is the Detroit Tigers, but Mr. Riley Greene is in a great spot against Toronto Blue Jays veteran Max Scherzer, who has been playing some great ball as of late.

However, the last 30 left-handed hitters he has faced do own a .333 xBA, .562 xSLG and .369 xwOBA, while generating a 46.2% hard-hit rate and 76.9% elevation rate.

Greene, across his last ten games, owns a .925 SLG, .907 xSLG and .450 ISO, while making 51.6% hard contact, 25.8% barrel rate and just a 19.4% ground-ball rate.

According to Batters-Box, through 77 elite ratings over the last three seasons, Greene has covered this prop 54.55% of the time.

Take it down to -120.

  • Time: 3:07p.m. ET
  • Where to watch: Sportsnet, DSN
Colby Marchio's 2026 Transparency Record
  • Prop picks: 513-992, +16.7 units

Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

Pages related to this topic

Colby Marchio
Betting Analyst

Colby Marchio is a two-time DePaul alum and former Division 1 (club) baseball player who has been sports betting since 2019. Since graduating in 2021, he has worked throughout the media circuit, hosting and appearing on various television and radio shows while making countless guest appearances discussing Major League Baseball, college basketball, college football, and the National Football League.

A self-proclaimed numbers nerd, Colby may enjoy digging through the data even more than winning itself. That passion is why his two favorite sports to cover are college basketball and Major League Baseball. 

As for his favorite sportsbook, it is whichever one has the best price, or whichever one is not taxing him as an Illinois resident. 

You can find all of his plays and more @ColbyMBets on Twitter/X.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo