Posted:
#376
warner
favre
collins
flacco
ryan
0
Name Your Top 5 Quarterbacks Now
Posted:
#377
You are all nuts, someone lock this thread, if i see one more kyle orton or marc bulger i might shoot myself, someone actually had nerve to say kyle orton just knows how to win, yeah if you call playing slightly above .500 cause of your defense winning thats cool... Its plain and simple despite injurys...
1. Brady (cant deny the rings or huge year last year)
2. Payton(controls game like no other qb in history + superbowl ring)
3.Big Ben ( gots himself a ring himself and career record is awesome)
4.Drew Breese (no one can deny the accuracy, incredible.)
5.Carson Palmer(hasnt won but is definately smart/talented qb for several years)
saw alot of tony romos... are you kidding nobody who turns the ball over that much is a good qb dont care if you throw 3-5 td''s a game.
Jay cutlers, hes definately on the rise can see him on this list in a few years.
one name i didnt see which i dont blame anyone was jake delhomme but seriously, atleast mention him before kyle orton, my god.
0
Posted:
#387
I still cannot beleive the overwhelming support for drew brees...
this guy has won ABSOLUTELY NOTHING
he's not a winner, period....could care less about his "great arm"...the true basis of a great QB is a guy that WINS in the CLUTCH, end of argument....he will NEVER WIN ANYTHING 
neither will Mcnabb, Palmer or Romo.....these guys are IMPOSTERS!!!!!!!
0
Posted:
#388
jeez robbie...harsh words. did drew fuck your girlfriend your senior year at purdue or something? 
IF ELI MANNING is really top 5 in football [which i dont believe he is], he should be able to do rather well with AMANI TOOMER AND HIXON AND BOSS AND STEVE SMITH in the passing game. If i remember correctly a top 5 QB such as Brady, did rather well with receivers such as Deion Branch, David Patten etc.........
Burress out cannot be an excuse.
0
Posted:
#389
It will interesting to hear what people say in this thread after the Super Bowl. The postseason says so much about how a QB can perform under pressure. When it's all on the line. The great ones rise to the top. Of course, the great ones that fail will always be back the next year. I think it may be a Pit-NY Super Bowl. That's my opinion as of now. Big Ben and Eli. That, I think, would be a killer game.
I think Romo's stock is falling. Until he does something in the postseason, I just don't know if he has the mettle. I'm worried about Peyton and the Colts. Nobody's talking about them, and they playing pretty good football. The thing is though, Harrison just isn't the ol' Marvin anymore. I believe that Rivers for San Diego has the unfortunate liability of having Norv Turner for a coach. The Chargers would be a better team without him. But look at his numbers! Wow! I do think Kurt Warner may have slipped into the top five. I'll plug his name in place of Brady's. Tom will be back next year though I'm sure...
Peyton
Big Ben
Warner
Brees
Romo
That's where I stand now. Eli is next. Pennington and Cutler are close, but I'd still take those five above first. I cant see Palmer in this list at all. Not this year.
0
Posted:
#390
Ryan Leaf
Andrew Walter
Kellen Clemens
Charlie Frye
Kyle Boller
I kid, I kid......Brady
P. Manning
Brees
Palmer
Mcnabb
Sorry guys, no big ben here. He's a turnover prone statue imho....
His stats over last 3 yrs, 44 games.....
65 td, 46 int, 24 fumbles, 134 sacks, avg qb rating 86.6 
I understand Ben is a winner and Pit is not the spot to pad stats. But to manage the game, trust your D, and come with the big 3rd down play when needed. There is no possible way to overlook these horrendous stats.....
Would any of these subpar qbs in the league have a job after this 3 yr stint???
0
Posted:
#393
Well, 1 of the years of the 3 mention you mention was the year after he got in his motorcycle accident. He then follows that year up with a 104 QB rating, the year before his accident he had a 98 QB rating and was a huge reason they won the Superbowl. This year he did hurt his shoulder correct? He has played against the Ravens(2), Colts, Skins, Dallas, NE, and Giants.
I'm surprised he is sacked that much, everytime I see the guy, he is getting away from pressure and making plays. Making big 3rd down plays are not that easy.
0
Posted:
#394
Quote Originally Posted by dak177:
Big Ben did not take the Steelers to the Superbowl it was his running game and great defense that took the team to the Superbowl. Don't get me wrong he is tops in the league, but don't make it sound like he alone took the Steelers to the Superbowl.
And to all the McNabb haters look at his numbers and throughout the years and then pull up Brady's numbers and compare. McNabb's winning percentage as a starter are among the very top of the league's and remember he did that for years in the very beginning throwing to uh Freddie Mitchell and James Thrash. So think about that when you are talking about top QB'S in this league.
Actually the year the Steelers won the Supwrbowl they used the pass to set up the run.
0
Posted:
#395
Quote Originally Posted by electricladylnd:
Well, 1 of the years of the 3 you mention was the year after he got in his motorcycle accident. He then follows that year up with a 104 QB rating. This year he did hurt his shoulder correct?
There is no doubt that they have run through death row this year w/schedule and stand at 11-3 currently. We can speak of his injuries. But the man has only missed 2 games in 3 years. But Ben is a "winner" right? They've been to 1 wildcard game since 05 sb run and lost to Jax.,,,,
Stats don't lie buddy.....
3 yrs, 44 games.....
65 td, 46 int, 24 fumbles, 134 sacks, avg qb rating 86.6
Would any of these subpar qbs in the league have a job after this 3 yr stint? Playin for a franchise where winning is expected.....
0
Posted:
#397
The top 5 quarterbacks when healthy.
1. Tom Brady- Track record doesn't lie, not the most physically gifted quarterback. Reminds me of Joe Montana. Maybe with a stronger arm. Just a competitor that makes winning look easy.
2. Peyton Manning- Enough said!
3. Carson Palmer- Most physically gifted quarterback in the NFL in my opinion. Could be number 1, this could be a little bit of homer coming in. He is terrific when he is healthy and has time to dissect defense's.
4. Ben Roethlisberger- How can he not be on this list. He makes plays, and just keeps on winning. Terrific quarterback, he has been sacked a ton this season. Any other quarterback would be hurt and the sacks would be doubled.
5. Drew Brees- This was a hard choice for me. He just keeps proving people wrong. Undersized not a big arm, just a great quarterback smart and savvy.
Just off the list:
1. Jay Cutler
2. Eli Manning
3. Tony Romo
1. Tom Brady- Track record doesn't lie, not the most physically gifted quarterback. Reminds me of Joe Montana. Maybe with a stronger arm. Just a competitor that makes winning look easy.
2. Peyton Manning- Enough said!
3. Carson Palmer- Most physically gifted quarterback in the NFL in my opinion. Could be number 1, this could be a little bit of homer coming in. He is terrific when he is healthy and has time to dissect defense's.
4. Ben Roethlisberger- How can he not be on this list. He makes plays, and just keeps on winning. Terrific quarterback, he has been sacked a ton this season. Any other quarterback would be hurt and the sacks would be doubled.
5. Drew Brees- This was a hard choice for me. He just keeps proving people wrong. Undersized not a big arm, just a great quarterback smart and savvy.
Just off the list:
1. Jay Cutler
2. Eli Manning
3. Tony Romo
0
Hot Forum Topics
