Week 13 College Football Best Bets: Jake Butt's Top Picks for Nebraska vs Penn State & More

Want the angles that matter this weekend? Jake Butt sits down with Covers’ Joe Osborne to reveal his top Week 13 picks and insights.

Ryan Murphy - Managing Editor at Covers.com
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor
Nov 21, 2025 • 09:31 ET • 4 min read
Nebraska Cornhuskers running back Emmett Johnson (21) runs the ball against the Northwestern Wildcats.
Photo By - Imagn Images. Nebraska Cornhuskers running back Emmett Johnson (21) runs the ball against the Northwestern Wildcats.

With college football Week 13 bets taking center stage, the stretch run is delivering everything fans crave: chaos at the top, razor-thin margins that will decide who plays for trophies, and a betting board loaded with value... if you know where to look.

College football expert Jake Butt cuts through the noise, pairing sharp wagering angles with frank assessments of the playoff structure, coaching expectations, and the outsized role injuries will play as we sprint toward Selection Sunday. Check out his NCAAF picks and analysis below.

Nebraska Nebraska vs Penn State Penn State best bet

Pick: Emmett Johnson Over +22.5 receiving yards (-105 at FanDuel)

Nebraska is starting freshman QB TJ Lateef under center following an injury to starter Dylan Raiola. That - combined with Penn State's downhill, aggressive defense - is a recipe for a ton of targets for running back Emmett Johnson.

"I've called Nebraska games and they want to feed Emmett Johnson consistently," Jake says.

He believes the Cornhuskers' game plan is simple.

"They want to get the ball to Johnson, which is gonna include a heavy screen game," he explains. "All it takes is one perfect play call when Penn State is aggressive running the blitz dump down to Emmett Johnson. He could have 40 or 50 yards on one catch."

Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account Add as a preferred source on Google

College football playoff implications and rankings shakeup

Week 13 is functioning like a pivot point for the entire postseason picture. With the 12-team playoff framework hovering over the rankings conversation, the margins inside and just beyond the Top 10 feel tighter than ever. That squeeze is intensified by structural guarantees, especially the Group of Five berth, that simultaneously promote representation and, as Jake argues, complicate competitive fairness in a year where the bubble is crowded with quality.

"One of my biggest takeaways is, and I'm for representation, but guaranteeing a spot for a G5 team really hurts everybody this year," Jake says. "And don't take my word for it. Take Tulane's head coach's word for it, okay? They're the 12-seed. I don't know if you saw this quote. Jon Sumrall said, 'Hey, we're an average team.'"

The bracket math further tightens when you account for conference dynamics. The ACC is likely to produce a participant, while the G5 berth is locked, effectively shrinking available at-large spots for power-conference teams with comparable resumes. As Jake puts it, the current ladder rewards teams that banked quality wins early and punishes late climbers who might actually be better right now.

"If you're not inside the Top 10, you're kind of out right now because a G5 team has to get in and an ACC team most likely has to get in," Jake explains.

The net result is a rankings environment where every snap has postseason implications, especially for teams hovering between eight and 14, where a single win against a brand-name opponent or a convincing rivalry performance can swing seeding or even survival. This week's slate doesn't just seed teams; it filters them, and the line between No. 8 and No. 12 feels as consequential as the line between No. 1 and No. 2. In this climate, motivation, health, and matchups aren't just talking points; they're the determinants of who plays in December and who watches.

Impact of injuries and player health on championship contenders

Every playoff conversation this time of year passes through a medical tent. For Ohio State, the status of star receivers Jeremiah Smith and Carnell Tate is more than a depth chart note, it's the difference between a multidimensional passing attack and an offense that must win with defense and situational football. Smith's late exit last week put a spotlight on how quickly title odds can wobble when a singular talent is compromised.

"Ohio State doesn't go all the way if they're not healthy," Jake proclaims. "And they still might. But here's the concern is Jeremiah Smith left the game last week limping. It really is concerning and sad because that's the best player in college football."

Injury management also intersects with Heisman calculus. Voters are swayed by November moments and those opportunities materialize only if star players are available and trusted at full speed. That's why coaches often toggle between conservatism and calculated risk in Week 13: preserve key pieces for a conference title shot, but leave enough tape to win awards, matchups, and momentum heading into December.

For bettors, the takeaway is straightforward: injury information changes everything, from live totals to underdog value. If a team's top skill player is limited, opposing defenses will squeeze the middle of the field, force longer drives, and tilt outcomes toward Unders or underdogs with game-control profiles. Conversely, a clean bill of health for elite receivers can turn red-zone trips into touchdowns and push a total past the key numbers.

Coaching changes and program expectations

Coaching moves in November and December always carry a whiff of instant-fix urgency. James Franklin's move to Virginia Tech is intriguing precisely because it tests that narrative; the Hokies can benefit from a proven program builder, but in the transfer portal and NIL era, culture and alignment drive outcomes as much as playbook installation. Talent acquisition and retention — the lifeblood of consistency — will decide whether promising turns into perennial.

"It takes a team to win," Jake says. "It takes a village to win at the college level."

That village now includes donors, collectives, recruiting departments, analysts, and alignment across the athletic department. Buy the right coach, and you buy competence; fund the right infrastructure, and you buy staying power. For on-field results this season, coaching rumors can nudge locker rooms in either direction, galvanizing veteran rosters or distracting units that rely on precision. Savvy bettors watch the signals: portal whispers, staff retention, and how a team responds in a meaningful Week 13 spot.

Key matchups and game analysis for top teams

Missouri vs. Oklahoma is a rivalry freighted with history and nearly all of it slanted toward the Sooners. That context matters, but it collides with this week's quarterback uncertainty, the single variable that can erase trend lines in an instant. If the starter is limited or out, expect a conservative script early and an emphasis on field position. If he's full-go, Missouri's balance can stress an Oklahoma defense that thrives when it dictates tempo.

USC vs. Oregon offers a classic stylistic clash: the Trojans' playoff hopes hinge on an explosive passing attack landing early shots, while their defense must survive Oregon's bruising run game. If USC can generate chunk plays and force the Ducks into a track meet, the pressure flips; if Oregon controls the line of scrimmage and the clock, USC's margin for error disappears. In-game, watch third-and-medium as USC's defense lives or dies on those downs.

As for Rutgers vs. Ohio State, the betting question aligns with the Buckeyes' broader goals. With injuries to key receivers on the radar, a measured approach would surprise no one. That invites a lower-possession game in which a big number is inherently harder to cover. Rutgers' objective will be to compress the field, lean on special teams, and turn a few third quarters into coin flips. That script doesn't guarantee an upset, but it does keep 31.5 live deep into the second half.

The evolving landscape of college football with the 12-team playoff

The most striking part of this season's stretch run is how much it already feels like postseason play. With more berths at stake and the middle class empowered by access, November resembles a bracket as teams on the 8–12 line manage attrition while those around 15–20 hunt for an opening. That pressure radiates through every decision, from how long starters play to whether a coach leans on analytics or intuition in fourth-and-short.

"This is basically like an extension of the college football playoffs right now," Jake says. "It's the advantage again of the 12-team playoff because I mean 18, 19, 20, like you can make a case potentially for teams to get in. So, it's going to be chaos and drama, which, you know, we love about sports."

Conference championship scenarios now double as seeding wars. An ACC representative is almost certain, compressing at-large lanes, while the G5 auto-bid ensures an outsider makes the dance regardless of computer rankings or public perception. For teams hovering outside the Top 10, that means every style-point opportunity counts, but so does preserving health for the extra game that awaits. Playoff teams need to be built to win three or four times, not just once.

Actionable angles for this week: monitor tempo tells (App State's pace remains a catalyst for Overs), check injury reports up to kickoff (especially for Ohio State's receiving corps), and weigh motivation over model in late-season blowout spreads (Rutgers' number makes more sense when viewed through the Buckeyes' risk calculus). Pair those with coaching context like Virginia Tech's long-term arc under Franklin could start with stability plays in December rather than fireworks, and you have a roadmap for both Saturday and the weeks beyond.

Pages related to this topic

Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Managing Editor

Ryan Murphy began his love affair with sports journalism at the age of nine when he wrote his first article about his little league baseball team. He has since authored his own weekly column for Fox Sports and has been a trusted voice within the sports betting industry for the past eight years with stops at XL Media and Churchill Downs. He’s been proud to serve as Managing Editor at Covers since 2022.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo