Had to comment on this. First off...Halladay may be considered a better pitcher then Wang, but Wang has the most wins of any pitcher over the last 2 seasons, and that is what matters overall. His 4 complete games this season means really nothing seeing that he lost 3 of them. Next, I don't belive that Marcum is better then Pettitte. Maybe Pettitte hasn't started off strong this season, but if it went down to a 1 game playoff to decide the final spot of the playoffs, are you teling me that you would take Marcum on the mound to outpitch Pettitte? I know I wouldn't. Burnett is better then Mussina, but Mussina is tied for 3rd in wins with 7. I have no idea why you mentioned McGowan over Hughes when Rasner is obviously going to get the job over Hughes the way he is pitching, and I believe that although Rasner may not be a better overall pitcher then McGowan, he sure is this season in the games he has pitched. Litsch is better then Kennedy, but Kennedy did have a great start his last outing and looks to be coming out of his slump. The Jays bullpen probably is better then the Yanks pen, but there really is no telling what is going to happen with bullpens until after the all-star break because once Joba moves to the rotation, they are going to bring up another pitcher who is supposed to be this season's Joba Chamberlain such as Alan Horne or Scott Patterson. And as of now, I believe that the Yanks jumped over a few teams since your post on the offensive side. It's the A-Rod affect. Since A-Rod has come back, Lefties are hitting .439, with Cano and Giambi busting out of their slumps. And maybe right now the Jays have better pitching, but Burnett hasn't shown much potential this season, and if Joba's move to the rotation works the way they hope it does, they have an awsome top 3 starters. The season is young, and the Yanks can easily come back and take the lead of the division. Hell...they already took 2 games from the Sox in 2 days. ![]()
Wins is not the most important stat for pitching. IT is actually one of the most OVERRATED stats for pitchers.
WHIP, BAA, K/BB, ERA and Innings are all better indicators of a better pitcher. You forget to mention that the Yankees have one of the most potent offenses in the game which gives their pitchers better chances of picking up victories when they do not pitch well.
Halladay- WHIP: 0.98; BAA: .231; K/BB: 6.2/1; ERA: 3.11; Innings pitched 81
Wang - WHIP: 1.17; BAA: .226; K/BB: 1.8/1; ERA: 3.51; Innings pitched 66.2
They are very close but Halladay is the better pitcher. He pitches deeper into games which rests your bullpen more and he allows less people on base while getting the strikeout at a much better rate. In addition he has almost and ERA of a half run better.







