19:00 ET Oct 9

NYR +121 o5.5

WAS -134 u5.5

19:00 ET Oct 9

PIT +102 o6.5

CLB -113 u6.5

19:00 ET Oct 9

SEA +127 o6.0

DET -141 u6.0

20:00 ET Oct 9

ANA +110 o6.5

WIN -121 u6.5

Tampa Bay 2nd Atlantic3-1-0-0

New York 4th Metropolitan2-2-0-0

7:30PM ET 7:30PM ET · Oct 10, 2026

Lightning vs Islanders Picks & Props

TB vs NYI Picks

NHL Picks

There are no Expert or Computer Picks for this matchup at the moment.

Check out all hockey picks and predictions

Latest headlines Checkout latest headlinesRead more

NHL

10/09/2026 12:35 ET

NHL Milestone Tracker: DeBrincat, Connor Eye Goals in Game No. 700

Shooters, shoot. Read more

NHL

10/09/2026 11:26 ET

NHL Best Bets Oct. 9: Today's Top Moneyline, Total & Prop Picks

Expect some two-way scoring on Friday night. Read more

NHL

10/09/2026 11:01 ET

Rangers vs Capitals Prediction & Odds Tonight: NHL Picks

Perreault features in New York win.Read more

NHL

10/09/2026 08:42 ET

NHL Player Prop Picks & Goal Scorer Predictions: Friday, Oct. 9

Robertson's hot start continues.Read more

There are no Consensus Picks for this match up at the moment. Visit our Consensus to see all Consensus picks.

Consensus Picks

Recent Form Trends

Over is 4-0-1 in Islanders last 5 after allowing 2 goals or less in their previous game.
Under is 5-0 in Lightning last 5 when their opponent allows 2 goals or less in their previous game.
Under is 3-0-1 in Islanders last 4 home games.
Under is 4-0 in the last 4 meetings.
Under is 4-0 in the last 4 meetings in New York.
Under is 3-0-1 in Islanders last 4 games as a home underdog.
Over is 3-0-1 in Lightning last 4 games as an underdog.
Under is 6-1 in Lightning last 7 games as a road favorite.

ROI Trends

Tampa Bay Trends

The Tampa Bay Lightning have hit the Game Total Under in 15 of their last 20 games (+9.70 Units / 45% ROI)

Over

Under

Game Line - Total - FT

Compare odds

The Tampa Bay Lightning have hit the 3P Game Total Under in 9 of their last 12 games (+9.35 Units / 74% ROI)

Over

Under

Game Line - Total - 3Q

Compare odds

The Tampa Bay Lightning have hit the 2P Game Total Over in 13 of their last 25 away games (+5.95 Units / 21% ROI)

Over

Under

Game Line - Total - 2Q

Compare odds

The Tampa Bay Lightning have covered the 1P Puck Line in their last 3 games (+4.10 Units / 137% ROI)

TB

NYI

Game Line - Spread - 1Q

Compare odds

The Tampa Bay Lightning have hit the 1P Game Total Under in 8 of their last 13 away games (+4.00 Units / 30% ROI)

Over

Under

Game Line - Total - 1Q

Compare odds

The Tampa Bay Lightning have only hit the Game Total Over in 5 of their last 20 games (-12.00 Units / -53% ROI)

Over

Under

Game Line - Total - FT

Compare odds

The Tampa Bay Lightning have not hit the 3P Game Total Over in any of their last 12 games (-11.65 Units / -76% ROI)

Over

Under

Game Line - Total - 3Q

Compare odds

The Tampa Bay Lightning have only hit the 2P Game Total Under in 7 of their last 25 away games (-8.85 Units / -28% ROI)

Over

Under

Game Line - Total - 2Q

Compare odds

The Tampa Bay Lightning have only covered the 2P Puck Line in 1 of their last 9 away games (-7.00 Units / -71% ROI)

TB

NYI

Game Line - Spread - 2Q

Compare odds

The Tampa Bay Lightning have only hit the 1P Game Total Over in 6 of their last 15 away games (-6.85 Units / -32% ROI)

Over

Under

Game Line - Total - 1Q

Compare odds

NY Islanders Trends

The New York Islanders have covered the 2P Puck Line in 7 of their last 8 games (+6.60 Units / 56% ROI)

TB

NYI

Game Line - Spread - 2Q

Compare odds

The New York Islanders have hit the 1P Game Total Under in their last 5 games at home (+5.20 Units / 101% ROI)

Over

Under

Game Line - Total - 1Q

Compare odds

The New York Islanders have hit the Game Total Under in 9 of their last 14 games at home (+4.65 Units / 31% ROI)

Over

Under

Game Line - Total - FT

Compare odds

The New York Islanders have hit the 2P Game Total Over in 6 of their last 9 games at home (+4.15 Units / 38% ROI)

Over

Under

Game Line - Total - 2Q

Compare odds

The New York Islanders have hit the 2P Moneyline in their last 3 games at home (+3.05 Units / 73% ROI)

TB

NYI

Game Line - Moneyline - 2Q

Compare odds

The New York Islanders have only covered the 3P Puck Line in 6 of their last 20 games (-11.35 Units / -42% ROI)

TB

NYI

Game Line - Spread - 3Q

Compare odds

The New York Islanders have only hit the 1P Moneyline in 3 of their last 15 games (-7.35 Units / -37% ROI)

TB

NYI

Game Line - Moneyline - 1Q

Compare odds

The New York Islanders have only hit the 1P Game Total Over in 11 of their last 25 games (-6.90 Units / -21% ROI)

Over

Under

Game Line - Total - 1Q

Compare odds

The New York Islanders have only hit the Game Total Over in 4 of their last 14 games at home (-6.35 Units / -40% ROI)

Over

Under

Game Line - Total - FT

Compare odds

The New York Islanders have only hit the 2P Game Total Under in 7 of their last 20 games at home (-5.65 Units / -23% ROI)

Over

Under

Game Line - Total - 2Q

Compare odds

Total

'deerkiller' picks Tampa Bay vs NY Islanders to go Under (5.5)

deerkiller is #5 on picking games that NY Islanders are in with a record of (3-1-0) and +3000 units on the season.

Total

Over

Under

Total

Total

'lsbellmom' picks Tampa Bay vs NY Islanders to go Under (5.5)

lsbellmom is #8 on picking games that NY Islanders are in with a record of (3-1-0) and +2950 units on the season.

Total

Over

Under

Total

Pages Related to This Topic

//Trends script for picks tab