There might not be a lot of scoring today, but my home run props believe keeping the ball in the yard won’t be easy for some pitchers battling workload issues, poor second halves, and even unsustainable end-of-season runs.
Munetaka Murakami knows how to take Gavin Williams deep, and if I’m doubling up on homers in one game today, it’s indoors with Cam Schlittler coming off a 117-pitch outing and Freddy Peralta due for some regression.
These are my favorite MLB player props for Monday, Oct. 5.
- UPDATE: Added another HR pick + parlay.
MLB home run props for today
For help understanding Polymarket probabilities, see our odds calculator.
| Player to hit a HR | Probability |
|---|---|
| 18% | |
| 17% | |
| 21% | |
| 💲Today's HR parlay | 117x |

Home run prediction: Munetaka Murakami
I’m not getting off the Munetaka Murakami train today against Gavin Williams.
The White Sox-Guardians series is not going to be high-scoring, but the runs that do cross the plate are more than likely coming via the long ball. The Sox won Game 1 3-0, but two of those runs came on a Murakami home run. He's a buy for me today to 20%.
Williams is a great pitcher who slipped a little in the second half, but he also gives up homers at a higher rate than you might assume. Only five other pitchers this season allowed more home runs than the Cleveland starter’s 28 over 184 innings.
If I’m backing one bat in this outdoor game, it’s the Japanese slugger who might be becoming a lot of people’s favorite MLB player.
Read our full White Sox vs. Guardians predictions.
- Time: 5 p.m. ET
- Where to watch: TBS
Home run prediction: Luis Garcia
The Yankees got one hit in their series opener, but have a much better homer matchup in Game 2 vs. Freddy Peralta.
The Tampa starter was on a heater before the postseason, earning AL Pitcher of the Month for September. But before the hot run, he was a below-average pitcher who allowed 22 home runs over 135 innings. It's a tale of two Peraltas, and I'll trade against him being a sub-1.00 ERA pitcher.
Lefties have taken Peralta deep at a higher rate this year, and Luis Garcia is the target I'd trade to 18%. Garcia has seen Peralta the second-most of all Yankee starters and has already gone deep in the postseason.
I would prefer an indoor home run today, as the hitting conditions in Cleveland aren't ideal. I hope the rest has turned Peralta back into the pitcher he was for the first 75% of the season.
Read our full Yankees vs. Rays predictions.
- Time: 8 p.m. ET
- Where to watch: TBS
Home run prediction: Junior Caminero
Cam Schlittler is coming off a massive 117-pitch outing in his last start and isn’t working on any extra rest. I love targeting pitchers coming off season-high workloads, and I get that chance Monday night.
Junior Caminero has seen Schlittler the most of all Rays hitters and is one of just two Tampa bats to take him deep. He’s 21% to go deep, which is one of his longest prices of the year, and there is value today with Schlittler coming off that massive workload.
I’m pushing this to a fair probability of 23%. The indoor setting only helps.
- HR picks: 41-158 -19.3 units
Best home run combo for October 5
| Trade Now 117x |
|
Want more baseball parlays? Check out our MLB parlay picks page!
Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.






