Name Your Top 5 Quarterbacks Now

 

That is some funny shit dude.    I'm not sure that they're all good points, but it is funny!

No we do not have to do that. 

Who would take Marino or Fouts  in the draft.......given what they already know about their careers. 

Please be the first one to step right in here and get trapped.     No one in there right mind would draft a guy if they knew he would not win. 

Dilfer should not have been traded, he was  the perfect QB for the Ravens........look @ the Ravens since.

   If you can not see that Mcnabb is old,fat and Done...I feel for ya.    ! decent year  in the next 3-4 maybe, but nothing that even comes close to a top 5 performance.

 

  MICHAEL VICK

 

     Thanks dude!  That's some of the funniest shit in this thread.  Great athlete.  Average at best quarterback.   I laughed my ass off when they let go of Schuab.  I knew they would rue the day.  He's better than Vick ever was.  And because Vick was such a celebrated ATHLETE, they kept in the starting lineup.  That dude said it best when he called Vick a "coach killer".  Yeah the dude could run like a gazelle, but he lacked so many other needed skills to be a winning qb.  I've already said it and I'll say it again:  No team with him at QB will ever win anything.   The only way he'll win a Super Bowl (if he can find employment later) is if his defense and running game are both far superior than anything in the league.  And I'll lay big money that that never happens.  The odds are it wont.  And even then the coach will have to be smart enough to limit his throws.  The dude just doesn't have the grey matter to achieve at that level. 

 

Were you serious about listing Vick?  C'mon dude...

Besides... him and his brother are simply a lower form of life.

 

    

 

Thanks for your input but I cant agree with Anderson and Campell.  Anderson needs to prove that he's not a fluke and that takes a few more games (more than 21), and Campbell's numbers are average at best after only having played 20 games. 

Whoops! This was supposed to go with this.....

 

I noticed that too.

      Something else to ponder.  Romo sat the bench for a while, but what if Bledsoe had done just enough to keep the job and hadn't got hurt.  Where would Brady be now?  There are many stories like that.  Just because Romo sat the bench doesn't mean he was terrible.  How does a Willie Parker never start in college at NC?  How does James Harrison sit the bench for four years and then make the Pro Bowl after his first year as a starter?  If you dont get the opportunity and the right breaks, you cant succeed.

Excellent point Steel...

And with that we could even start another list.....guys who were backups and flourished when given the opportunity. Some pretty big names would be on that list...

Favre, Brady, Romo, Delhomme, Bulger, Garrard...

And that's not to say that ALL of these guys have been GREAT, but they have all had their share of success.

ItsDubz.......I do not give two shits if they are in Canton.........that has nothing to do with this argument......stay on topic .......I bet you were the little ADD kid eating glue in school. 

  Let's restate the question for little Johnny....he was busy looking through his messy desk when the question was asked.

In the league, right now, who are your top five in no particular order?

  ^^^^^^^^ When you get Pwned do not change the topic!!!!!!!!!!!  This is not about Canton!

Mcnabb is still an over-rated over weight disaster waiting to happen.  Top 5........Not even close there are 10-12 that are better QB's   THIS YEAR.

 

If I was a coach, GM, owner, or whatever; these are the QB's I would take over McNabb to start the 2008 season...

Brady, P. Manning, Romo, Roethlisberger, Palmer, Brees, Anderson, Garrard, Rivers, Cutler, Hasselbeck, Bulger, V. Young, Favre, E. Manning...

That's 15...

So by your logic as long as a guy wins in the regular season he is great.

I would not pick Marino in a draft....he could not win the big game.   I would not draft Fouts either knowing what I know now.  If you can not win the big ones.....what good are you?   
Mcnabb is not even in the same league as those to QB's.....to mention the three of them in a sentence is foolish. 
Unless the sentence is   Donavan Mcnabb was jailed in Ohio earlier today for stealing yellow jackets from Dan Fouts and Dan Marino. Mcnabb was quoted as saying he just could not handle being passed on for the fifth straight time by the pro football Hall of Fame.

94

Mia

16

16

385

615

62.6

4453

7.24

64t

30

17

89.2

22

-6

-0.3

10

1

Marinos stats @ mcnabbs age  in adifferent era as well

1981*

30

SDG

QB

16

16

360

609

59.1

4802

33

5.4

17

2.8

67

7.9

7.2

13.3

300.1

90.6

19

134

7.4

6.7

3.0

Fouts @ same age

Let's see what Mcnabb does this year.....since you like to compare him to real QB's @ age 32.

LOFL   not a chance in hell!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!