Thursday Night Football has us wading in the murky waters of the AFC South sewer.
The Indianapolis Colts and Houston Texans clash in a crucial mid-week matchup, which might not be the sexiest sell... unless you’re following my Colts vs. Texans prop picks.
I unearth edges in the individual efforts, giving you my favorite NFL picks for TNF on Nov. 19.
Best Colts vs Texans props
For help understanding Kalshi probabilities, see our odds calculator.
| Pick | Probability |
|---|---|
| |
46% |
| |
52% |
| |
48% |
Percentages courtesy of Kalshi, one of the best prediction market apps.
Kalshi has also now launched Player Injury Protection for player props: Learn more here about how protected markets work, and which markets are eligible.
Start trading with Kalshi today!
Sign up now using our exclusive Kalshi promo code 'MAX60' and trade $25 on any event contracts to get $60!
*Eligible U.S. locations only

Prop pick #1: C.J. Stroud 22+ passing completions
The swelling spread for Thursday Night Football writes a run-positive game script for the Houston Texans. The only issue is you need running backs to run the ball.
Houston is thin in that department, with Woody Marks nursing a concussion and David Montgomery playing through a groin injury on the short week.
Quarterback C.J. Stroud is primed for a big performance, given Houston is back home at NRG Stadium in Week 11.
Stroud does his best work at the Texans’ venue and has completed at least 21 passes in three of four home starts this year while boasting a career 65% completion rate at NRG (vs. 61.9% on the road).
He faces an Indianapolis Colts secondary with massive gaps. Starting corners Sauce Gardner and Charvarius Ward are questionable after leaving Week 10 with injuries.
Stroud’s Week 11 projections range from 19.7 completions to 22.5. I’m siding with that ceiling, given the shape of the Texans’ rushing corps and the Colts' pass coverage.
Prop pick #2: Nico Collins 5+ receptions
Stroud targeted Nico Collins a season-high 16 times in last week’s loss at Cleveland.
The Texans WR1 grabbed nine passes for 94 yards against a Browns secondary running the highest rate of man coverage in the NFL.
Collins is Houston’s best receiving option against man-versus-man, which is something the Colts run at the eighth-highest rate. Indianapolis could also be missing its two top one-on-one defenders in Gardner and Ward, which means Collins feasts on lesser DBs.
Although Collins missed the first matchup with Indy in Week 3, he has lit up the AFC South rival in recent seasons. He’s snatched at least five receptions in each of his previous four meetings with the Colts, torching them for a collective 556 yards.
Thursday’s forecasts have Collins leaning toward five receptions, with my number north of five grabs and respecting a ceiling sitting just short of six catches.
Prop pick #3: Jonathan Taylor 20+ receiving yards
Colts running back Jonathan Taylor's carries have declined while his passing targets climbed over the previous three games.
While rookie RB Seth McGowan eats into JT’s snap share, Taylor is still the third-down back for Indy. And with the receiving corps depleted due to trades and injuries, he’s become a more prominent figure in the passing game.
Taylor has drawn 14 throws in the last three outings, catching 11 of those balls for receiving gains of 18, 20, and 25 yards. He averaged less than four targets and under 2.5 receptions in the first seven weeks, still posting 25.4 receiving yards per game.
He faces a Houston defense that has allowed the 10th most targets and receptions to rival running backs, with 6.4 passes thrown to the position per game.
Player models vary for Taylor’s receiving yards, with a couple sitting around 16 yards, but the majority are on the other side of 20 yards. My number comes out to 22+ yards, with the big road underdog likely playing in a pass-positive game script.
- Prop picks: 33-27, +3.28 units
Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.






