Sometimes less is more.
That’s certainly the case when it comes to NFL Week 11 spreads. The schedule has five teams laying double digits and an average line of -8, with several one-sided matchups to mull over.
As someone who writes a weekly NFL underdog picks column, taking the points with those lofty dogs often means counting on the suckiest of teams to suck just a little less — or more likely, the favorite to fall flat.
Larger underdogs can offer value in the first half of the schedule, as they did through the first eight weeks of 2026 (+7 or higher went 21-6-2 ATS) and over the same stretch in the previous four years (56% ATS).
But as we've seen over the last two weeks, big pups are big for a reason once the calendar flips to November. Those underdogs catching a touchdown or more are 0-7 ATS since Week 9 and have historically lost their bite in the back half of the season (51% ATS from Week 11 onward over the previous four years).
Rather than trusting some teams that are truly buns and a couple rookie QBs on the road, my featured NFL picks for Week 11 are three underdogs with at least a fighting chance.
And, as the old saying goes, it’s not the size of the dog in the fight... but the size of the fight in the dog.
Last week: 2-1 ATS
Season: 17-13 ATS
NFL Week 11 underdog picks
For help understanding Kalshi probabilities, see our odds calculator.
Percentages courtesy of Kalshi, one of the best prediction market apps.
Start trading with Kalshi today!
Sign up now using our exclusive Kalshi promo code 'MAX60' and trade $25 on any event contracts to get $60!
*Eligible U.S. locations only

Buccaneers +7.5 at Lions
This spread jumped from Tampa Bay Buccaneers +5.5 to +7.5 following news that Baker Mayfield might not suit up Sunday.
Mayfield is worth an adjustment on name alone, but considering how well and how often Tampa Bay has run the ball, the switch from Baker to tested backup Jalon Daniels shouldn't make much of a difference.
The Bucs have been relentless with their rushing attack in recent weeks and enter Week 11 refreshed and reloaded. Tampa is 3-2 SU and 4-1 ATS over its past five outings, riding a top-10 ground game that's helped shape the No. 1 defense in EPA allowed per play over that span.
The Detroit Lions also give up a notable rest advantage, with the Bucs coming off their bye while Detroit traveled to Germany and back last week.
Although the Lions offense finally looked good against an injury-plagued Patriots team, they had sputtered in recent weeks. Detroit struggled to score 20 points in the three games prior, slumping to 20th in EPA per play over that stretch.
Given Tampa Bay's ability to bottle up opposing passers, this could very well be a grinder decided on the ground. That suits the Bucs just fine.
Ravens +2.5 at Panthers
The “Jacoby Brissett experiment” got off to a rough start on Monday. The Baltimore Ravens quickly fell behind to the Bolts and were unable to dig themselves out, losing their fifth straight contest.
A big part of the problem was the Ravens’ offense finding themselves in long third downs in the opening half. Baltimore couldn’t get gains with RB Derrick Henry and Brissett was forced to pass in bad spots with only a week to learn the playbook after being traded from Arizona.
Week 11 will see an improvement, not only based on Brissett getting another week deeper in the offense but also by what the Carolina Panthers bring – or don’t bring - to the table.
The Panthers snapped a three-game skid with a sweaty win in New Orleans last weekend. The defense is a work in progress after firing their coordinator and switching in interim Todd Wash, who wants to run a 4-3 base with 3-4 personnel.
Carolina is second last in third down defense, allowing foes to move the chains at a near 47% clip. And while the Panthers have improved their run stop, they did so against Denver and NOLA, who rank 28th and 29th respectively in yards per carry.
Overall, Carolina has given up 124 rushing yards per game and faces a pissed-off Henry, who had only 10 yards on 10 carries (with two TDs) in the loss to L.A.
Head coach Jesse Minter stressed the importance of getting “The King” going whenever and however they can, which will help put Brissett in third-and-manageable spots.
Vikings +3.5 vs. 49ers
Speaking of old QBs in new places… kind of… Kirk Cousins’ return to the Minnesota Vikings makes for a spicy matchup in Mexico City on Sunday night.
The 30-point performance from the Vikes at Lambeau looks better than it really was but the Minnesota defense didn’t have to spend 40 minutes on the field. So that’s a plus.
In the three games prior, Brian Flores’ guys logged an average of 36:41 of field work, including an insane 42:32 versus Buffalo in Week 9.
“Kirk Thuggins” eased the offense into a warm bubble bath last Sunday. A slow burn of 34.5 seconds per play clock ranked fifth lowest in tempo and a 9-for-17 success rate on third/fourth downs gave the stop unit more than 35 minutes of down time.
As far as how the San Francisco 49ers navigate that Minnesota defense, the last time Kyle Shanahan tried to solve Flores, Brock Purdy got sacked six times and turned the ball over twice in 2024. The 2026 version of this Vikings defense is far greater and more versatile.
Purdy has plenty of tools in his bag, but it doesn’t matter to Minnesota:
• He’s among the leaders in both air yards and yards after the catch per completion. The Vikings don’t give up either.
• Purdy has elite pressure releases in TE George Kittle and RB Christian McCaffrey. Flores shuts those alternative receiving options down.
• Deebo Samuel is a quick-hitting bulldozer picking up bonus yards after contact. The Vikes don’t miss many tackles.
Yards will be hard to come by inside Estadio Banorte, especially with a splash of rain in the forecast Sunday night. That half-point hook is muy importante.
Week 11 underdog combo
Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.






