Who's your NSW backline if you had to pick today?

Right on it there AB. I have been on the Pearce hate train since day 1! They have to go with Carney. 

chk, you have to get away from this line of thinking fed to you by fulton and daley, and the fulton worshippers at the Telegraph (rothfield, richie and kent) and hadley. They will sell you this bullshit to make it sound they made great decisions, but in reality they constantly failed.

Check the NSW record when they make these stupid decisions, and check out NSW record in the last 15 years without Johns or Fittler in the team.

What did einstein say about insanity? you pick the best player in each position. Simple

 

Mullen

Cronk is a better halfback than Thurston, but hopefully they pick JT and put Cronk on the bench again.

how many teams carry a team week to week? see post 27

nsw will get beaten up front, so 4 forwards on the bench is a must

Hirsh these are just my opinions. I havn't picked a paper up in 2weeks. I have no idea what b/s they talking there. Which is why i like to have my discussions in here.

4 forwards is a must I agree

what the selectors will do and should do are 2 completely different things.

What they will do is something totally fucking stupid.

stuart + fulton = one giant fuckup

don;t be suprised if the selectors put carney at half and bird at 5/8

I'm pretty much in agreeance, except fro the Pearce bit.

ok, want a mind fuck? pick the pack, including 4 on the bench

This is my NSW backline

Nathan Gardner

Nathan Merrit

Luke Capwell

Colin best

Kane Linnet

Reni Matua

Chris sandow

snowden

farah

mannah

bird

tll

lewis

 

houston

weyman

someone

someone

 

snowden ain;t all that good, He got picked last year due to a lack of options, so people assume he must be good

would like to see what tolman does oveer the next month. Like Mannah, but don;t think he is hard enough.

want a 50 tackle guy in the backrow, an 80 minute guy who will be in every play

can we ignore the rules like qld do? they pick nz players, png players, nsw players, so can we pick the worlds best foward? gareth ellis in the 2nd row

a) we have little options

b) Matt Hilder

This is my team - for real

Hayne

B Morris

J Morris

J Idris

A Uate

T Carney

M Pearce

G Bird

P Gallen

B Creagh

K Snowden

M Ennis

M Weyman

Bench

K Gidley

T Mannah

A Watmough

A Tolman

 

What about playing Mullen and Gidley together at 6,7?

Mullen has played 2 good games in 8 years,lets not get carried away

A Tolman


He is too small and weak,gets absolutely destroyed every time he hits it up,just because someone does a lot of work doesn't make them good.


A Tolman > Younger version of N Hindmarsh(Who is one of the worst players in the NRL)





Tolman hitting it up in origin

A Tolman

A Tolman is good for supercoach points and thats it

Gidley in 1 or he is on the couch

Mullen picked for origin because he had 2 good games in 30 years

Hayne
Morris
Idris
Morris
Uate
Carney
Pearce