Peyton Manning is very good....but he's OVER RATED and here's why....

you dont even have your facts straight

Brady came in during game 2 and started his first game in week 3 - Brady got injured in the AFC title game & Bledsoe played a half, thats it

peyton is average, just like a Jim Kelly, Neil Odonnel, Dilfer, all the same---

Peyton cannot win the big one--


That is an insult to BRADY to compare Manning to a LEGEND like BRADY, Manning is NOT CLUTCH, brady IS SUPER AMAZING AND CLUTCH-

Looks like we've hit the jackpot on the number of dummies in a single thread

The most important thing when evaluating a QB in post season is not whether their team won or lost....but did their LEVEL OF  PLAY increase during these games ?......(relative to regular season)....not too hard to determine.

I believe with Manning we can say with (some) certainty that he is a better regular season QB.... than post season QB......going back to his days at Tennessee....for whatever it's worth (haven't done the statistical breakdown)

he's still a GREAT QB and one of best ever no doubt....very few guys can channel that extra adrenaline into positive results.....Montana great example of someone who could.....Tiger is best and most obvious example.....as the added pressure makes him a better golfer seemingly every time...never was a big Aikman fan ....but he played much better it seemed when it counted most....

never been a Manning fan until recently ....always thought he was a choker in college.....and he loved to throw his teammates under the bus after a loss...."we had protection problems"...."we dropped passes"....notice after this game .....many would say " (I) should never have thrown that pass".....his immediate response was "(he) made a great play on the ball".......BS....> sure he did.......but the TRULY great players /LEADERS/ CHAMPIONS.... don't say that....

the dude though has carried that team on his back for years....is the only QB calls most of the plays.....and is a tremendous leader by all accounts...and will own every passing record by the time he is done...

Beat my Steelers at home on that day when they had the bags packed for a Super Bowl 

i dont care about hall of fame becuase not all great players will get in..i.e. eric allen, eric metcalf, preist holmes etc. but manning doesnt even make top 3 all time QB

Mike tyson = peyton manning--

beats average fighters lost to anyone good--

peyton is the same wins reg season and in playoffs loses to any good defense--