Screw it I am going for it

Aaron ROdgers for Peyton Hillis

I have Vick and Rodgers and I just want to upgrade my team.........Am I crazy?

yes you're crazy. 

So just keep playing rodgers and just waste vick on the bench?

MY rb's are arian foster, then its a mess, beanie wells and deangelo williams.

Bet you $5 he wont do the trade, think he has roethlisberger

Make the trade, Hillis is the man there and Vick is close enough to rodgers, just hope he stays healthy

Will the guy take Vick instead?  Rodgers will be the more consistent play, but Vick will be solid if not spectacular each week as long as he's healthy.  I would do it.  You'll be rock solid at QB and RB.

YES Vick injury prone.. Rodgers is GREAT!

I think I am stuck with them both.

No one will give me a fair trade because I have a strong team already. I mean they reject every offer I amke and I have made over 10 offers. I dont know why but I cannot make a trade, I think I made one in 3 years on cbs

There is worst things than having Vick and Rodgers to choose from every week.

They will pay.

Do it

If you're firmly in first place, I dunno if I would risk having VIck and VIck alone as your QB. With the Kolb ready to step in at any moment, and Vick already getting hurt this year.

I think Vick has more upside, but Aaron Rodgers is a solid play every week.

If you really wanted an upgrade, you would trade a QB and a RB for 2 RBs. Hillis is the man, but he's a converted fullback. He has been a little banged up this year. With a rookie QB, I'm sure teams will be stacking the fucking box. Dunno who they have left, but they are in Pitts/Balty's division.

When Wells is healthy, I would start him. Deangelo is has a good schedule at the end of the year, but I dunno if he'lll make anything of it.

How are your WR's? I'd probably try to get an upgrade there as well.

trade him Vick instead of Rogers bro
for Hillis

Thanks guys but they a bunch of vaginas in this league they aint trading me. lol

If your team is really that good, and you plan on starting vick anyways, Aaron Rodgers is the best insurance you can have. 

Id say peyton hillis is close to a first round pick right now. He's a beast, he can catch too

Where do you think Peyton Hillis would go right now? Id say late 1st early 2nd

 

So you're going to trade the current #4 QB who is consistant in the league for a Guy who did great in week 9?

peyton hillis

 

you dont watch must football do you

 

Peyton hillis has 17 less fantasy points than adrian peterson.

One good week huh?

Vikings17, would you really dare start rodgers over vick this week? 

 

Not this guy

Yeah.. I don't watch much football...

When you make a trade, it is also important to look at the upcoming matchups for the people that you are willing pickup as opposed to those that those great ones that you are ready to dump off.

Rogers for Hillis is NOT a good trade.

I say it is a great trade given that you have a fantasy stud in Vick to start at QB. 

I just looked at some numbers according to the scoring system that my league uses.  This is a no-brainer trade (in fantasy terms).

- Vick is #7 for total points in my league with 201.9 total points.  This includes completely missing weeks 5,6,7 and missing almost all of week 4 against Washington.  So he he is at #7 despite only playing 6 complete games.   And this is not a fluke his average point per game is 32.9 and his lowest point total is 22.3 (pretty good for your worst game).

- Rogers is #2 in my league with 232.45 total points.  But he has played 10 complete games (4 more than Vick).  His point average is 23.25 (almost 10 points lower than Vick).

- Hillis on the other hand is #19 in total points with 179.15 which is good for the 3rd best running back in the league (only behind Foster and AP). 

-Wells and Williams are not even in the top 200 in my league with a total point production of 42.45 and 50.95 points respectively.

This trade proposal is a no brainer.  Technically starting Vick would be an improvement at QB (in terms of avg fantasy pts per game) and Hills is without a doubt a SIGNIFICANT UPGRADE at RB.

No Bro....I would do it.    Hills is the only offense the Browns have. he will make up any loss of Rogers' points. You know Vick can get you 45 if he's hot.

Rodgers  25-30  great day

Vick   20-25 good day  Hillis 20 every day

Looks like your gaining at least 10 pts a week with that trade. If Vick goes off....Bonus.

DO IT

 

I think it's more important to look at what defenses those 2 quarterbacks are going to be facing the rest of your Fantasy season. I would have to say that Rogers has the better matchups than Vick.

And if your fantasy "Superbowl" is on week 16 like most other guys, you will have Hillis at home against Baltimore and Vick at home against the Vikings.

If anything, I would trade Vick for Hillis.