@Mskeets
G+........Texas +2.5
G+/G.....Ohio St. -2.5 (likely full G+ rating before end of reg, but premature now)
For me, this matchup depends on an accurate preseason assessment of team strength in all aspects. I am hopeful mine is...but ya never know!
My analysis has Texas (the preseason polls #1) RATED almost a half tier higher than OSU to begin the season - largely due to OSU not having a PROVEN starting QB (Texas does), losing 15 KEY starters to the draft
....and to top it off, losing their championship building DC to Penn St. PLUS the letdown factor does play a small part, as you noted, as well as Texas desiring bigtime to make an early statement and knock off the defending Champs in their own park! Too many ??? for OSU to start the season - although they should join my highest tier by mid-season!
Skeets, my top considerations for assessing teams preseason is: strength at QB, OL, DL (with defensive front 7 a close 4th)
OSU has a rookie QB (talented, but a virgin)....they lost 3 on the OL! (plus their 2 STUD RBs!!!!)....and lost all 4 off the DL!!!
And with only one returning starter at LB, the front 7 is very unlikely as good as last yr! OSU only returns 9 starters! Yes, there is transfers, talent and some experience ready to step up but it's not the same as 2 and 3 year carryovers.
TEXAS otoh, has a very talented dual-threat QB that is already under Heisman watch, and as you noted, from quite a pedigree with plenty of HQ advice and prep help from the entire fam damily!!! .....their OL is about the same shape as OSU, having lost plenty......their DL is also in similar shape to OSU losing plenty but good talent waiting to play. However the TEXAS LB corp is TOP NOTCH, which helps the defensive front 7 BIGLY and better overall than OSU
Special teams? Texas appears to have that edge too!
Assuming my ratings are very close to accurate, an almost HALF tier edge - on a neutral field - would suggest TEXAS a fav of roughly -3......But they lose that 3 point edge to OSU's homefield advantage. So, I figure the line should be -110 ML each team/ a pick'em on the spread.
I LEAN to Texas (dog). If I bet I'll very likely insist on a little more cushion with an alt-line... or just wait for a LIVE bet opportunity.
Hope this may help a little. BoL whatever you decide.