Will the Madden NFL 27 cover star be the man capping off a generational year which included a Super Bowl Ring? Jaxon Smith-Njigba has won everything else: NFL Receiving Yards leader, NFL Offensive Player of the Year, Pro Bowler, First Team All-Pro and Super Bowl winner with the Seattle Seahawks. It sure makes sense, but can he beat 'it'?
'It', the only thing scarier than Penny Wise the Clown, is the 'Madden Curse'. The one eldritch force in professional sports more reliable than an early-season collapse by the New York Jets.
This intense interest and public debate are the primary reasons we've pulled data from the Kalshi prediction market for the Madden NFL '27 cover star to find out who leads the race so far.
With the Madden NFL 27 cover acting as the ultimate digital hall of fame, traders and industry analysts believe that EA Sports is looking for a fresh, younger face to lead the franchise into its next era.
Key Takeaways
- Matthew Stafford took a lead in this market post-Super Bowl but Jaxon Smith-Njigba now sits atop the prediction market once more
- Running backs are enjoying a rare resurgence in popularity, with Bijan Robinson and Jonathan Taylor nipping at the heels of the elite.
- Defensive stars and perennial NFL MVP odds favorites like Patrick Mahomes are currently languishing in the bargain bin of "unlikely" outcomes across prediction markets.
Madden NFL 27 cover prediction markets
Madden NFL 27 cover star analysis
BUY: Jaxon Smith-Njigba | WR | 'Yes' at 58¢
Seattle’s wideout capped off a historic campaign by running away with Offensive Player of the Year and a Super Bowl ring, and he’ll look to break the mold when it comes to the stigma surrounding wide receivers being prioritized by EA.
Madden 19 marked the last time a wide receiver appeared on the cover (Antonio Brown), and only four receivers have graced the cover dating back to 2010.
There's so much volatility in this market that there's value to be find in trading into a 'Yes' position on the favorite. Just be sure to keep tracking this market daily as while he's been the most consistent contender: this may move to a 'Sell' within days.
Start trading with Kalshi today!
Sign up now using our exclusive Kalshi promo code 'COVERS' and get a $10 trading bonus after you trade $10 on any other event contracts — including this game!
*Eligible U.S. locations only
SELL: Matthew Stafford | QB | 'Yes' at 54¢
The Los Angeles Rams gunslinger is fresh off an MVP season in which he led the NFL in passing yards and passing touchdowns.
Paired with star receivers Puka Nacua and Davante Adams, ‘Stat Padford’ and the Rams will be one of the most highly used teams in next year’s edition.
Reinforcing our advice of 72 hours ago to buy 'Yes' for Stafford at 16¢: his price has jumped overnight to 54¢. Will he take the Madden 27 Cover? Possibly. But could you sell your 'Yes' position right now for a near 250% ROI? Definitely.
HOLD: Drake Maye | QB | 'Yes' at 40¢
After finishing second in the NFL MVP voting behind Matthew Stafford, Drake Maye looks eerily like the specter of Brady in that Patriots jersey.
Could he end up being even better? That's a big projection, but Drake Maye, in his sophomore season as an NFL quarterback, has shown more athleticism than the future Hall of Famer.
Despite a disappointing loss to a dominant Seattle team in the Super Bowl, Maye has a bright future in football and will likely find himself as the face of the Madden franchise at some point in the future, even if his time isn't now.
AVOID: Bijan Robinson | RB | 'Yes' at 14¢
The great thing about Bijan Robinson is his dual-threat capabilities, resembling a Madden-style player like Michael Vick in ’04.
While most Madden users love to abandon the running attack, Robinson will be part of your game plan no matter what, as he’s one of the most elite receiving backs in football alongside Christian McCaffrey.
Madden NFL Cover Athlete Prediction Markets FAQs
While Jaxon Smith-Njigba is the current frontrunner at 55% on Kalshi, he is absolutely not a guaranteed lock for the Madden 27 cover. Prediction markets frequently fluctuate based on late-season performances, playoff narratives, and unexpected marketing decisions by EA Sports. You should remember that a 55% probability still leaves a massive 45% chance that another star player ultimately secures the highly coveted spot.
Caleb Williams is gaining massive traction because prediction markets heavily weigh a player's raw marketability and presence in major television markets like Chicago. EA Sports traditionally favors young, electrifying quarterbacks who can drive video game sales through their dynamic playstyle and immense cultural relevance. Consequently, bettors recognize that his rising star power makes him an incredibly attractive candidate regardless of traditional MVP voting outcomes.
Prediction markets sometimes exclude defensive superstars like Myles Garrett because EA Sports has historically shown a massive bias toward offensive players. Market makers deliberately curate their lists to feature quarterbacks and receivers who statistically have a much higher historical probability of being selected. Although breaking the sack record is legendary, platforms often limit options to ensure higher betting volume on the most realistic offensive candidates.
The prediction market inherently reflects the infamous Madden Curse, as superstitious fans sometimes wager against their own franchise players to protect them. However, market prices are ultimately driven by objective probability and sharp bettors rather than the emotional fears of a team's dedicated fanbase. While fan anxiety creates amusing social media narratives, the actual odds prioritize EA's predictable marketing patterns over purely superstitious fan sentiment.
If EA Sports selects two players for the standard cover, prediction platforms usually resolve both of those specific player contracts as winners. You must always read the fine print, as rules differ wildly between sites regarding special editions versus the primary retail copy. Generally, market makers explicitly define the 'source of truth' to ensure all featured standard cover athletes trigger a legitimate affirmative payout.
