College Football Heisman Trophy Odds for 2025: Simpson a Slim Choice Over Mendoza, Sayin

Alabama's Ty Simpson has taken over as the tepid betting favorite in the Heisman Trophy odds over Fernando Mendoza and Julian Sayin. Here's how the Heisman odds look with eight weeks in the books.

Robert Criscola - Betting Analyst at Covers.com
Robert Criscola • Betting Analyst
Oct 20, 2025 • 17:35 ET • 4 min read
Heisman Trophy odds Alabama Crimson Tide Ty Simpson
Photo By - Imagn Images. Alabama Crimson Tide quarterback Ty Simpson.

The Heisman Trophy odds bettors have found a new Top 3 after Week 8.

Alabama's Ty Simpson has risen to the top following a big home win over Tennessee. Indiana's Fernando Mendoza remains in close pursuit after beating Oregon two weeks ago, and Ohio State's Julian Sayin is making progress as the Buckeyes remain undefeated.

Check out the latest college football odds to win the 2025 Heisman Trophy.

Heisman Trophy odds

Player Position FanDuel
Bama Ty Simpson QB +320
Indiana Fernando Mendoza QB +340
Ohio State Julian Sayin QB +400
Texas A&M Marcel Reed QB +750
Vanderbilt Diego Pavia QB +800
Georgia Gunner Stockton QB +1100
Oregon Dante Moore QB +1400
Notre Dame Jeremiyah Love QB +2000

Odds as of 10-20.

2025 Heisman Trophy opening odds

  • Garrett Nussmeier +900
  • Arch Manning +950
  • Cade Klubnik +1100
  • Drew Allar +1100 
  • Nico Iamaleava +1100
  • Jeremiah Smith +1700
  • Carson Beck +1800
  • Julian Sayin +1800
  • Dante Moore +2000
  • LaNorris Sellers +2000

Odds courtesy of FanDuel.

Heisman Trophy betting insights

Line Movement (opening to current)

  • Carson Beck +2000 to +350
  • Ty Simpson +5500 to +350
  • Fernando Mendoza +5500 to +550
  • Jeremiah Smith +1300 to +1400
  • Dante Moore +2000 to +1700
  • Joey Aguilar +5000 (Week 2) to +3000
  • John Mateer +2500 to +4000
  • Arch Manning +900 to +8000

Most Tickets

  • Arch Manning 8.3%
  • Jeremiah Smith 8.0%
  • John Mateer 6.4%
  • Garrett Nussmeier 6.3%
  • LaNorris Sellers 5.7%

Most Handle

  • Dante Moore 16.9%
  • Arch Manning 9.5%
  • Garrett Nussmeier 6.7%
  • John Mateer 6.7%
  • Jeremiah Smith 6.3%

Biggest Liabilities

  • Dante Moore
  • Arch Manning
  • Jeremiyah Love
  • John Mateer
  • Jeremiah Smith

Data courtesy of BetMGM as of 10-13.

Heisman Trophy winners by position

Position Heisman Trophy Awards
Running back 40
Quarterback 38
Wide receiver 4
Tight end 2
Fullback 2
Halfback 2
Cornerback 2

Running backs won the Heisman Trophy 11 straight times from 1973 to 1983.

Heisman Trophy betting trends

Here are a few trends to keep in mind before placing a bet on the biggest individual award of the college football season.

  • Quarterbacks have dominated this award over the last 23 years with 18 Heisman winners playing under center.

  • The Heisman trophy winner usually comes from a team with a shot at winning the national title, even though it is a regular season award. Since 2000, 14 Heisman trophy winners have played for teams that made it to the national championship game. If you're handicapping the Heisman, you might want to consider looking at which teams have the best chance of winning the title on the NCAA futures odds board.

  • Even though DeVonta Smith won the Heisman in 2020, he is one of only four seniors to win the Heisman in the last 17 years. Over that span, two freshmen, five sophomores, and six juniors have claimed the prize.

Heisman Trophy history

Year Winner (Position) School
2024 Travis Hunter (CB/WR) Colorado
2023 Jayden Daniels (QB) LSU
2022 Caleb Williams (QB) USC
2021 Bryce Young (QB) Alabama
2020 Devonta Smith (WR) Alabama
2019 Joe Burrow (QB) LSU
2018 Kyler Murray (QB) Oklahoma
2017 Baker Mayfield (QB) Oklahoma
2016 Lamar Jackson (QB) Louisville
2015 Derrick Henry (RB) Alabama

Heisman Trophy Odds FAQs

Pages related to this topic

Robert Criscola - Covers.com
Betting Analyst

Robert M. Criscola’s road to becoming a Covers publishing editor began with an internship at Metro New York, which eventually turned into a freelance job at MetroBet covering many sports from a wagering angle, including horse racing. He continued to focus on “The Sport of Kings” by writing for shapperdacapper.com, danonymousracing.com, and informer.fanxt.com before joining the team at the TwinSpires Edge in 2019 as a regular contributor and weekend editor. “Crisco” began writing game previews for Covers in 2022 and joined the editing team in 2023.

His best advice for sports bettors? Bet with your head, not over it.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo