Newcastle vs Man City Predictions, Picks & Odds for Tuesday's EFL Carabao Cup Semifinal Match

Erling Haaland puts Man City on his back against Newcastle in the Carabao Cup.

Sam Farley - Contributor at Covers.com
Sam Farley • Betting Analyst
Jan 11, 2026 • 18:21 ET • 4 min read
Erling Haaland Man City Carabao Cup
Photo By - Reuters Connect. Erling Haaland of Man City.

The Carabao Cup returns this Tuesday for the first leg of the semifinal between Newcastle and Manchester City at St James’ Park.

Man City trail in the Premier League title race but should still have enough to win here, and my Newcastle vs Man City predictions expect Pep Guardiola to get past a Newcastle team who’ve only won around 50% of their games this season.

Read on for my betting picks for Tuesday, January 13, with kickoff at 3:00 p.m. ET on Paramount +.

Newcastle vs Man City picks and predictions

My Newcastle vs Man City best bet: Man City moneyline (+115 at Sports Interaction)

It’s a tough ask for Newcastle to beat Man City, who’ve won 18 trophies under Pep Guardiola, including four Carabao Cups. Despite not playing at their best, they’ve still only lost five times this season, and two of those were in August as they struggled to start their campaign.

They’ve dropped points recently, but still won nine of their past 12, with the other three being draws.

Newcastle have found some form, but they've still scored the third-fewest goals in the top half of the Premier League. They’ve also given up 15 goals at home this season, which is more than all but three other teams in the league, who all occupy spots in the bottom four.

You can’t afford to give up so many goal-scoring chances at home, and City, the league’s highest-scoring team, will punish them.

They managed 10 goals against Exeter in the FA Cup at the weekend, giving them a chance to rest some of their stars. 

City are packed with experience and should take advantage of a Newcastle team struggling at the back.

Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account Add as a preferred source on Google

Newcastle vs Man City same-game parlay (SGP)

Man City to win

Erling Haaland anytime goal

Joelinton to get booked

Erling Haaland has had an incredible season, with 26 goals already for Man City this season. He only played one half at the weekend, so he will be well rested.

Joelinton averaged 1.66 fouls per 90 minutes in the Premier League, and he’s been shown a card in a third of his starts this season. Against City's possession-based style, he’s likely to get booked.

Newcastle vs Man City odds

Newcastle vs Man City odds

Brighton & Hove Albion Newcastle Manchester United Man City
+210 Moneyline +115
+260 Draw +160
Over 2.5 (-170) Total Under 2.5 (+120)

Odds courtesy of Sports Interaction.

    How to watch Newcastle vs Man City

    Location St. James' Park, Newcastle-upon-TyneEngland
    Time 3:00 p.m. ET
    TV Paramount+
    Weather Light rain

    Newcastle vs Man City key injuries

    Newcastle: Dan Burn CB (Out), Emil Krafth DEF (Out), Fabian Schar DEF (Out).
    Man City: Mateo Kovacic CM (Out), Omar Marmoush STR (Out), John Stones CB (Out), Josko Gvardiol CB (Out), Ruben Dias CB (Out), Savinho CB (Out).

    Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
    Not intended for use in MA.
    Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

    Pages related to this topic

    Sam Farley
    Betting Analyst

    Sam is based in the United Kingdom, where he grew up living and breathing soccer, before discovering - and playing - a different kind of football at the University of Bristol. He’s worked in the media covering soccer and the NFL for the better part of a decade, and has been a regular on the Matchbook NFL Podcast. His work has also appeared in a wide range of publications including The Telegraph, The Independent, VICE, and MSN.

    The search for great betting value is a daily one, and Sam always hunts out big prices with a particular focus on player props. Sam’s best advice for bettors is to track their bets on a spreadsheet, that way you can keep an eye on your P&L but also the types of bets and sports that you are most successful in. He also recommends using a variety of different sportsbooks, with bet365, Betfair and Paddy Power amongst his favorites.

    Popular Content

    Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo