NHL Player Props & Best Bets for Today, October 16: McDavid's Breakout

Connor McDavid has been somewhat quiet by his standards, but the hapless Islanders represent a great opportunity for Edmonton's superstar forward to stuff the stat sheet.

Quinn Allen - Betting Analyst at Covers.com
Quinn Allen • Betting Analyst
Oct 16, 2025 • 09:32 ET • 4 min read
Connor McDavid Edmonton Oilers NHL
Photo By - Imagn Images. Oilers F Connor McDavid (97) skates during a game vs. the Rangers.

It’s another busy evening in the National Hockey League, with 11 games on the slate.

My NHL player props will include Connor McDavid, Nathan MacKinnon, and Zach Werenski. Read more for my NHL picks for all the action. 

Best NHL player prop bets today

Player Bet99
Oilers Connor McDavid Over 1.5 points -120
Avalanche Nathan MacKinnon anytime goal +120
Blue Jackets Zach Werenski Over 3.5 shots on goal +125

Get a first bet encore up to $800 — no BET99 promo code neededGet a first bet encore up to $800 with BET99 bonus code COVERSNHL.
(not available in Ontario)

Our best NHL player props for Thursday, October 16

Take a look at our best bets and expert analysis below.

Prop #1: Connor McDavid Over 1.5 points

-120 at BET99

Connor McDavid is off to a bit of a slow start this season when it comes to actually putting the puck in the net. While he’s tallied four assists, the superstar hasn’t scored. That being said, it’s only a matter of time until he finds his best in all the ways offensively, and tonight is a perfect opportunity to have a big game. 

The Edmonton Oilers face the winless New York Islanders, who are one of the worst defensive teams in the NHL. McDavid also happened to light them up last season, registering five points in only two games. 

McDavid cashed the Over in points in the season opener with two helpers, and he’s put up a point apiece in his two other games so far.

  • Time: 7:30 p.m. ET
  • Where to watch: Sportsnet 360

Prop #2: Nathan MacKinnon anytime goal

+120 at BET99

Nathan MacKinnon is one of the best players in the league, coming out of the gates firing for the Colorado Avalanche, already scoring four goals and setting up another four in as many appearances. He cannot be contained. 

The former Hart Trophy winner has scored in each of his last three contests, netting twice in Monday’s victory over the Buffalo Sabres. The Avs face the Columbus Blue Jackets tonight, and while they’re only allowing three goals per contest, we’re talking about MacKinnon. It doesn’t matter who he’s playing against. 

MacKinnon will stay hot and pot another goal this evening.

  • Time: 7:00 p.m. ET
  • Where to watch: Altitude, FDSN Ohio

Prop #3: Zach Werenski Over 3.5 shots on goal

+125 at BET99

I know this is a high SOG total, but Zach Werenski has been lighting it up this season when it comes to creating opportunities. Although the 28-year-old defenseman has just three points, he’s leading the NHL with over six shots on goal per contest. He’s registered Over 3.5 shots on target in every game, totaling 19 already. 

Werenski has seven SOG in back-to-back games, and he also had five in the season opener. He’s getting a ton of pucks on net. It will be more difficult to do so tonight, as the Avalanche are allowing 27 on target, which is 12th in the league, but he’s consistently showing that he can generate chances.

  • Time: 7:00 p.m. ET
  • Where to watch: Altitude, FDSN Ohio

Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

Pages related to this topic

Quinn Allen - Covers
Betting Analyst

Quinn Allen is an experienced sports journalist from Vancouver, Canada who fell in love with sports by the time he could walk. He proceeded to play high-level baseball and soccer growing up and eventually played college baseball in the United States.

After his career ended, Quinn received his broadcast journalism degree from BCIT and has since written for many sports publications including ClutchPoints, Gino Hard, and RG, where he plies his trade as a writer and editor.

Quinn's favorite team is Chelsea FC and he'd like to watch a match at Stamford Bridge one day. He loves to bet on NBA player props and encourages others to bet responsibly and not chase losses.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo