NFL Rookie of the Year Odds 2026: Mendoza is the New OROY Favorite

Sean Tomlinson - Betting Analyst at Covers.com
Sean Tomlinson • Betting Analyst 16+ years betting experience
Updated: Nov 11, 2026 , 11:54 AM ET • 4 min read

Fernando Mendoza, the 2026 first overall pick, is set to start, and he's the new favorite in the OROY odds. Arvell Reese is pulling away on the other side of the ball.

NFL Rookie of the Year Odds, Fernando Mendoza, Las Vegas Raiders, NFL
Photo By - Reuters Connect. Fernando Mendoza throws.

There's a new leader atop the NFL Rookie of the Year odds on the offensive side, and it's the 2026 first overall pick.

Fernando Mendoza will take over under center as the starter for the Las Vegas Raiders after they shipped off Kirk Cousins to the Minnesota Vikings just prior to the trade deadline.

His surge upward to become the favorite by the odds in part implies there's an expectation of immediate success from the rookie. But while his future is bright, Mendoza faces the Seattle Seahawks, Denver Broncos, and Cleveland Browns to begin. That's three daunting defenses, two of which rank among the top 10 in points allowed per game.

On the other side of the ball, Arvell Reese continues to sprint away, and he's now putting distance between himself and David Bailey in the NFL odds.

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year odds

 

Player Name Kalshi
Probability
Raiders Fernando Mendoza 22%
Broncos Jonah Coleman 17%
Browns Denzel Boston 16%
Titans Carnell Tate 13%
Browns KC Concepcion 10%
Cardinals Carson Beck 6%
Jets Omar Cooper Jr. 5%
Saints Jordyn Tyson 3%

Odds as of 11-11. Percentages courtesy of Kalshi.
Kalshi is a regulated financial exchange where you trade on real-world event outcomes. Instead of traditional odds, prices are listed as percentages (0-100%), representing the market’s estimated probability of an event occurring.

Start trading with Kalshi today!

Sign up now using our exclusive Kalshi promo code 'MAX60' and trade $25 on any event contracts to get $60!

*Eligible U.S. locations only

Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account Add as a preferred source on Google

How to approach Mendoza in OROY market

There's justifiably plenty of hype around the top pick from last spring and the Heisman winner. He's fresh off leading Indiana to a surprise national title run, and did it while throwing 41 regular-season touchdown passes with just six interceptions.

Enthusiasm and expectations alone will drive a highly touted passer to the top of this market, which is where Mendoza sat during the preseason before not getting the starting job right away. But it's best to be patient now. No one else is sprinting away at the top, so yes there is a runway for Mendoza to win Offensive Rookie of the Year even while playing for about just half a season. But his landing spot in the schedule couldn't be worse.

It starts with the Seattle Seahawks, who are tied for fourth while allowing just 18 points per game. Even worse for Mendoza, Seattle gives up the fewest passing yards per outing at 155.1.

He then gets daunting road matchups against the Denver Broncos and Cleveland Browns. Denver isn't far behind Seattle while giving up just 20.4 points per game, and the Browns' pass defense sits sixth at 201.0 yards permitted per matchup.

Mendoza will then enjoy the Raiders' Week 13 bye to regroup before the schedule gets significantly softer, with the Raiders playing the woeful Los Angeles Chargers, Tennessee Titans, and Arizona Cardinals to finish out the season.

It's likely his value decreases amid the difficult opening stretch to his NFL career. But then there will be an appealing opportunity to pounce on him during that bye week, especially if no one else has really taken hold of this market yet by then.

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year prediction

Although Carnell Tate spent the majority of his time in the shadow of both Jeremiah Smith and Emeka Egbuka at Ohio State, he’s an excellent route runner who brings little ego to a Tennessee Titans offense looking for a No. 1 WR.

Tate shot up quickly in this market after erupting for 145 yards on nine catches in Week 4. He was then silent in Week 5, and inconsistent play may be typical on an overall struggling Titans offense.

But Tate then bounced back swiftly in Week 6 with another productive performance while posting 70 yards on six catches, and his first career regular-season touchdown grab. He remained steady in Week 7, with a respectable 69 yards on five receptions. However, Tate suffered a shoulder injury and missed Week 8. He's now had Tennessee's Week 9 bye to recover.

OROY Pick: Carnell Tate (13% probability at Kalshi)


NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year odds

 

Player Name Kalshi
Probability
Giants Arvell Reese  55%
Jets David Bailey 31%
Dolphins Jacob Rodriguez 5%
Commanders Sonny Styles 6%
Patriots Gabe Jacas 2%
Cowboys Caleb Downs 1%
Packers Brandon Cisse 1%

Odds as of 11-11. Percentages courtesy of Kalshi.
Kalshi is a regulated financial exchange where you trade on real-world event outcomes. Instead of traditional odds, prices are listed as percentages (0-100%), representing the market’s estimated probability of an event occurring.

NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year prediction

The New York Jets snagged their edge rusher at No. 2 after selecting David Bailey, who’s fresh off a 14.5-sack season with Texas Tech.

Bailey has registered 7.5 sacks through eight games, doing his best to keep pace in this market with the soaring Arvell Reese.

Bailey did miss Week 8 due to a groin injury, which hurt him in this race. He then returned in a massive way during Week 9, logging two sacks and nine tackles (three for a loss).

DROY Pick: David Bailey (31% probability at Kalshi)


Popular NFL futures markets


NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year history

Here's a look at the recent award history (preseason favorite and winner odds courtesy of Sports Odds History):

Year Favorite Winner
2025 @ LV logo Ashton Jeanty  Panthers Tetairoa McMillan 
2024 Bears Caleb Williams  Commanders Jayden Daniels 
2023 Falcons Bijan Robinson  Texans C.J. Stroud
2022 Steelers George Pickens & Steelers Kenny Pickett  Jets Garrett Wilson
2021  Jaguars Trevor Lawrence  Bengals Ja'Marr Chase 
2020 Bengals Joe Burrow  Chargers Justin Herbert 
2019 Cardinals Kyler Murray  Cardinals Kyler Murray 
2018 Giants Saquon Barkley  Giants Saquon Barkley
2017 Jaguars Leonard Fournette  Saints Alvin Kamara 
2016 Cowboys Ezekiel Elliott  Cowboys Dak Prescott 

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year winners by position

Position OROY winners
Running back 40
Quarterback 12
Wide Receiver 2
Tight end 1

Bears legend Mike Ditka became the first — and so far only — tight end to win Offensive Rookie of the Year when he received the honor in 1961.

NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year history

Here's a look at the recent award history (preseason favorite and winner odds courtesy of Sports Odds History):

Year Favorite Winner
2025 Giants Abdul Carter  Browns Carson Schwesinger 
2024 Vikings Dallas Turner and Colts Laiatu Latu Rams Jared Verse
2023 Texans Will Anderson Jr.  Texans Will Anderson Jr. 
2022 Lions Aidan Hutchinson  Jets Ahmad "Sauce" Gardner 
2021  Cowboys Micah Parsons  Cowboys Micah Parsons 
2020 Commanders Chase Young  Commanders Chase Young 
2019 Steelers Devin Bush  49ers Nick Bosa 
2018 Broncos Bradley Chubb Colts Shaquille Leonard 
2017 49ers Reuben Foster  Saints Marshon Lattimore 

NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year winners by position

Position DROY winners
Linebacker 29
Defensive end 13
Cornerback 10
Defensive tackle 7
Safety 2

A safety hasn’t won NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year honors in over 20 years, dating back to when Mark Carrier (1990) and Erik McMillan (1988) won the award twice over a three-year span.

NFL Rookie of the Year FAQ

Pages related to this topic

Sean Tomlinson - Covers
Betting Analyst

Sean Tomlinson has been navigating the sports media landscape since 2009, officially joining Sportsbook Review in 2021. Over the years, his commentary has been cited by major outlets such as The New York Times and Forbes, and he has regularly discussed his NFL insight as a guest on TSN 1050 and The Fan 590. An active bettor who places wagers on a daily basis, Sean spreads his action across several platforms, consistently favoring FanDuel and bet365 for their user-friendly interfaces. His primary handicapping focus centers on the NFL, MLB, and Formula 1, with a heavy emphasis on locating high-value prop opportunities. Sean maintains a keen interest in political prediction markets too, closely monitoring candidate odds throughout primary runs and general election cycles. He views sports betting as an interactive lens for deeper analysis, applying that exact philosophy to his editorial work. He holds a degree in media studies from the University of Guelph-Humber—a background that previously led to editorial roles at Bleacher Report and theScore.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo