As far as Monday Night Football matchups go, it doesn't get much more exciting than this — a high-octane matchup between two Super Bowl contenders.
Buffalo is a 3-point underdog in a 54.5-point game, producing a 25.75-point implied total. SoFi Stadium makes outside weather irrelevant.
Monday teams have not yet filed a complete injury report, so the central question is whether Buffalo's efficient rushing core can finish drives against a Rams defense allowing points on only one-third of opponent possessions.
A 54.5-point game total under the SoFi roof signals an explosive, high-tempo exchange environment where every offensive touch carries premium scoring weight.
Carrying an implied team total of 25.75 points as 3-point road underdogs, Buffalo will not have the luxury of taking its foot off the gas.
If you are allocating capital across Buffalo Bills anytime touchdown scorer picks, efficiency inside the 20-yard line is the core metric.
The opposing defense limits scoring drives effectively, but Buffalo's balanced ground attack thrives on condensed goal-line leverage. Target the contracts anchored to guaranteed red-zone touches.
Top Buffalo Bills anytime touchdown predictions
| Player | Position |  Probability |
Index Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| James Cook | RB | 54.5% | 90 |
| Josh Allen | QB | 54.5% | 80 |
| Khalil Shakir | WR | 28.2% | 70 |
| Keon Coleman | WR | 27.8% | 60 |
| Dalton Kincaid | TE | 32.3% | 55 |
| Dawson Knox | TE | 14.3% | 52 |
| Ty Johnson | RB | 16.7% | 51 |
| Joshua Palmer | WR | 17.4% | 50 |
| BUF Bills D/ST | DST | 15.4% | 49 |
| Ray Davis | RB | 5.3% | 49 |
| Jackson Hawes | TE | 9.1% | 47 |
Market note: Probability is calculated directly from the submitted market price. Index Score measures relative value, not the player's raw probability of scoring.
Start trading with Kalshi today!
Sign up now using our exclusive Kalshi promo code 'MAX60' and trade $25 on any event contracts to get $60!
*Eligible U.S. locations only
James Cook anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Cook has played 68% of snaps, handled 63.2% of carries, and accumulated 15 red-zone opportunities. His lead role is secure, although Allen owns 10 red-zone chances and remains the primary goal-line competitor.
The matchup: The Rams can meet interior runs with Kobie Turner, Poona Ford, and Nate Landman. Cook's cleaner route may be an outside-zone cut or screen that avoids the heaviest interior bodies.
The value: The submitted price of 54.5% implies a 54.5% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 62%, creating a positive gap of about seven percentage points. That assessment depends on whether Buffalo gives him the finishing carry instead of shifting to Allen near the stripe, so the price is attractive under the current assumptions.
Josh Allen anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Allen has accounted for 29.2% of Buffalo rushing attempts and 10 red-zone opportunities while playing every snap. Designed runs, scrambles, and sneaks create a touchdown role independent of his passing production.
The matchup: Los Angeles uses disciplined edges and interior size, but man coverage can still vacate scramble lanes. A sneak or power keeper after Buffalo reaches the two-yard line is more reliable than a long open-field run.
The value: The submitted price of 54.5% implies a 54.5% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 60%, creating a positive gap of about five percentage points. That assessment depends on whether Buffalo generates multiple goal-to-go snaps against a defense allowing points on one-third of drives, so the price is attractive under the current assumptions.
Khalil Shakir anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Shakir leads Buffalo with a 20.3% target share, has played 62.8% of the snaps, and has seen five red-zone opportunities. His volume is dependable, but the short-area role does not guarantee end-zone placement.
The matchup: Slot routes bring him toward Quentin Lake and the Rams' underneath zone defenders. A pivot route or crossing concept against pressure is the most realistic touchdown call.
The value: The submitted price of 28.2% implies a 28.2% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 32%, creating a positive gap of about four percentage points. That assessment depends on whether his target leadership extends into the red zone rather than shifting to larger receivers, so the price is a positive lean under the current assumptions.
Keon Coleman anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Coleman has played 62.5% of snaps, drawn 14% of targets, and recorded three red-zone opportunities. His scoring case relies on size and target quality more than raw volume.
The matchup: Outside routes should bring him toward the Rams' boundary corners with safety leverage behind them. A contested fade opposite Shakir's interior gravity is his clearest path.
The value: The submitted price of 27.8% implies a 27.8% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 30%, creating a positive gap of about two percentage points. That assessment depends on whether Allen gives him a deliberate end-zone target despite the difficult corner matchup, so the price is a positive lean under the current assumptions.
Dalton Kincaid anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Kincaid has played 66% of the snaps and commands a 17.1% target share but has seen just one red-zone opportunity. His receiving efficiency has been stronger than his touchdown-specific deployment.
The matchup: The Rams' three-safety and heavy-personnel answers can bracket tight ends, while pass protection may occasionally keep him attached. A seam behind Landman is the best scoring route.
The value: The submitted price of 32.3% implies a 32.3% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 33%, creating a positive gap of about 0.9 percentage points. That assessment depends on whether Buffalo restores his route volume after consecutive low-usage games, so the price is close to fair under the current assumptions.
Dawson Knox anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Knox is the secondary tight end in an offense using substantial heavy personnel. His ordinary target share is thin, but those formations can place him on the field near the goal line.
The matchup: He can draw a linebacker or edge defender after chipping, particularly when Kincaid occupies deeper coverage. A delayed release into the flat is the narrow route.
The value: The submitted price of 14.3% implies a 14.3% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 15%, creating a positive gap of about 0.4 percentage points. That assessment depends on whether Buffalo calls a two-tight-end play-action pass rather than using both players to block, so the price is close to fair under the current assumptions.
Ty Johnson anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Johnson owns passing-down and change-of-pace work behind Cook, without a stable share of rushing touchdowns. His best opportunities arise through routes rather than conventional goal-line carries.
The matchup: The Rams' interior strength encourages Buffalo to use screens and option routes against linebackers. Johnson's plausible score is a checkdown that reaches the edge before pursuit closes.
The value: The submitted price of 16.7% implies a 16.7% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 17%, creating a positive gap of about 0.2 percentage points. That assessment depends on whether the game remains pass-heavy enough to expand his receiving snaps, so the price is close to fair under the current assumptions.
Joshua Palmer anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Palmer operates as a complementary receiver with a modest target share and limited touchdown-specific evidence. His route volume must rise for the market price to become comfortable.
The matchup: Aligning on the boundary could put him in a matchup against Watson, while Coleman draws the more physical coverage. A backside dig or scramble-drill target is the most realistic scoring route.
The value: The submitted price of 17.4% implies a 17.4% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 17%, creating a neutral gap of about 0.0 percentage points. That assessment depends on whether Buffalo consolidates routes around three receivers rather than rotating the depth chart, so the price is close to fair under the current assumptions.
BUF Bills D/ST anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Buffalo needs a return touchdown against a Rams offense that has protected Stafford through a timing-based passing game. The defense has blitzed at a league-average 32.9% rate.
The matchup: Greg Rousseau and the Rams' front must speed Stafford without exposing Nacua and Adams behind pressure. A tipped pass or strip-sack recovered near the sideline provides the necessary return route.
The value: The submitted price of 15.4% implies a 15.4% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 15%, creating a negative gap of about 0.2 percentage points. That assessment depends on whether pressure arrives before Stafford can distribute to his first read, so the price is close to fair under the current assumptions.
Ray Davis anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Davis sits behind Cook and Johnson, leaving him without dependable carries or red-zone ownership. His touchdown case depends on injury, an unusual rotation, or a lopsided game script.
The matchup: Los Angeles' interior is a difficult assignment for reserve carries. A draw against a light box in a passing situation is more plausible than a planned goal-line series.
The value: The submitted price of 5.3% implies a 5.3% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 5%, creating a negative gap of about 0.2 percentage points. That assessment depends on whether the backfield hierarchy changes materially before or during the game, so the price is close to fair under the current assumptions.
Jackson Hawes anytime TD odds & analysis
The metric: Hawes is a blocking-oriented depth tight end in Buffalo's heavy-personnel packages. His receiving and red-zone volume is too small to establish a repeatable touchdown role.
The matchup: The Rams could overlook him while focusing on Kincaid, Knox, and stopping the run. His clearest path to a touchdown is slipping into the end zone after selling a block near the goal line.
The value: The submitted price of 9.1% implies a 9.1% scoring probability. The working fair estimate is approximately 9%, creating a negative gap of about 0.5 percentage points. That assessment depends on whether he releases into a designed route from a three-tight-end formation, so the price is close to fair under the current assumptions.
Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account
Game Script & Betting Context
Buffalo carries an implied total of 25.75 points within a 54.5-point environment. As a 3-point underdog, the most likely script preserves Allen's passing and rushing volume while keeping Cook involved as long as the game remains close.
The Rams' strong early defensive results could force touchdowns toward improvised quarterback plays. SoFi conditions are controlled; late injury news is the largest unresolved variable.
For analysis across the full slate, see our NFL Week 5 anytime touchdown predictions.
Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.
