A prediction market customer can take a position on who wins an NFL game with a few taps. In Congress, that same transaction has become a test of how much authority Congress handed a commodities regulator when it rewrote derivatives law after the financial crisis.
The answer could determine whether exchanges can keep offering sports event contracts nationwide or face the same patchwork of state restrictions that sportsbooks navigate.
- A CFTC proposal would generally preserve contracts on game outcomes while taking a harder line on markets tied to injuries, officiating decisions, and specific in-game actions.
- Federal appeals courts are divided over whether states can enforce gambling laws against prediction market operators.
- Democrats will control both chambers of Congress in 2027 and could pursue legislation restricting sports event contracts.
As senators move toward confirming two more members of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the agency has a chance to draw clearer lines around that business. But Tuesday’s Senate Agriculture Committee hearing offered a preview of the pressure the expanded CFTC could face in 2027.
If the CFTC continues allowing most sports event contracts while fighting state restrictions in court, the incoming Congress will have an opportunity to write limits of its own. Questions from senators and the incoming shift in congressional control suggest lawmakers could be more willing to pursue those restrictions in 2027.
The law behind the question
Congress has taken little legislative action on prediction markets, leaving the CFTC broad leeway to maintain its current permissive attitude toward sports event contracts.
Current CFTC chair Michael Selig has led the agency as its sole commissioner for nearly a year, aggressively protecting prediction markets operators’ rights to offer these contracts and legally challenging any group that seeks to prevent them. Adding a pair of new CFTC commissioners, one from each party, has boosted hopes for a potential position shift, but not all lawmakers are convinced it will lead to meaningful action.
In Tuesday’s nomination hearing, California Democratic Sen. Adam Schiff asked Nathan Anonick, a Republican-backed nominee, if a “bet” on a prediction market for this Thursday’s Colts-Texans NFL game would constitute a sports wager. Anonick said courts had interpreted that ruling in different ways.
Schiff put a version of the same question to Selig at his confirmation hearing a year earlier, with the nominee giving a similar answer. That potential shift was the point of Schiff’s line of questioning, as the former attorney highlighted how the commissioner can say the courts will have the final word while the agency takes an active role in shaping what the courts decide.
Confirming Anonick and Democratic nominee Matthew Rowland would give Selig two colleagues on a commission designed for five members. One early test for the expanded commission would be the agency’s current approach to sports contracts. It would generally preserve markets on game outcomes while taking a harder line on contracts tied to injuries or officiating.
Schiff’s NFL example falls into the category that the proposal would largely leave intact.
Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account
Legal arguments
The CFTC and prediction market industry's legal argument for offering sports contracts nationwide rests on the Commodity Exchange Act and changes Congress made through the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 following the 2008 financial crisis. The law expanded the CFTC's oversight of swaps.
The CEA's definition of a swap includes agreements tied to events with potential financial, economic, or commercial consequences. Kalshi argues sports outcomes meet that test and that the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction over swaps traded on designated contract markets bars states from enforcing their gambling laws against those contracts.
Dozens of states and Native American tribes have challenged that interpretation, arguing that the contracts are sports wagers subject to state and tribal gambling laws. Three federal appeals courts have now ruled against Kalshi’s efforts to block state enforcement, while one has sided with the exchange.
Multiple groups are asking the Supreme Court to offer a final decision, but the court has not yet accepted the case and there is no firm timeline for when it would do so.
Democrats can bring the debate to a vote
Senators acknowledged both nominees would be confirmed, and Tuesday’s hearing gave little certainty about how the expanded commission would regulate prediction markets. With CFTC and court action undetermined, the hearing indicated the incoming Congress would be more prepared to take action legislatively.
Democrats will take control of both chambers in 2027, giving them more say over bill hearings and votes. That includes proposed legislation, already introduced in the current Congress, that would ban these platforms.
Gaming and tribal groups have also urged senators to attach sports event contract restrictions to separate crypto legislation. Congress could also amend the CEA to restrict or ban sports event contracts and clarify when state and tribal gambling laws apply.
Even with Democratic majorities in both chambers, passing substantial legislation will be difficult, especially after Republicans have largely resisted any regulatory crackdowns. Still, Democratic control will give lawmakers who support restrictions more influence over committee agendas and which bills receive votes.
“These markets are operating in a Wild West desperately in need of regulation and guardrails,” Schiff said.






