The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a lower court's decision denying Kalshi an injunction against Maryland gaming regulators, allowing the state to continue pursuing enforcement of its sports wagering laws.
- The Fourth Circuit's 2-1 decision allows Maryland to continue pursuing enforcement of its sports wagering laws against Kalshi.
- The ruling adds to a series of appellate decisions supporting state authority over sports event contracts.
- Three federal appeals courts have now ruled against Kalshi's efforts to block state gambling enforcement, while the Third Circuit ruled in its favor.
The ruling strengthens Maryland's ability to join a growing number of states moving to restrict unlicensed sports event contracts.
The decision does not resolve Kalshi's underlying lawsuit, and Maryland has not said whether it will pursue further enforcement action. However, it removes a potential judicial barrier while litigation in Maryland and other jurisdictions continues, with a potential Supreme Court review ahead.
Court backs state regulatory authority
The Nov. 17 ruling affirmed an August 2025 federal district court ruling that rejected Kalshi's request to block Maryland's enforcement actions. State regulators had issued a cease-and-desist letter in April 2025, arguing Kalshi was illegally offering sports wagering without a Maryland license.
Kalshi argued its designation as a federally regulated exchange under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission gave it exclusive federal oversight under the federal Commodity Exchange Act, preempting state gambling regulations.
In a 2-1 decision, the Fourth Circuit rejected that argument at the preliminary injunction stage. Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker agreed Kalshi had not established grounds for blocking Maryland's enforcement, although they offered separate legal explanations.
Gregory concluded that Congress had not clearly removed states' longstanding authority to regulate gambling, even assuming sports event contracts qualify as federally regulated swaps.
"Congress knows how to displace traditional state police powers when it chooses to do so. Here, it has not done so with the clarity our precedents require,” Gregory wrote.
Thacker determined sports event contracts do not qualify as swaps under federal commodities law and therefore fall outside the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction.
Judge DeAndrea Benjamin dissented, arguing the contracts qualify as swaps and are consequently subject to exclusive federal regulation.
"The common criticism of Kalshi’s platform - that it walks like a casino, swims like a casino, and quacks like a casino, and thus should be regulated like a casino - appears logical. But that’s not what Congress said. Rather, 'exclusive jurisdiction' belongs to the CFTC."
Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account
More states could restrict prediction markets
Maryland's legal victory follows similar developments in several states seeking to prevent federally regulated exchanges from offering sports wagering without local approval.
Washington has already obtained a state court order requiring Kalshi to restrict sports and other event contracts, including implementing geolocation controls. Nevada has also received favorable federal appellate rulings allowing state gambling enforcement to proceed. Michigan has been able to prohibit Kalshi from offering sports wagering following court decisions, while a temporary ban is in effect in Louisiana. Courts have also sided with California tribes’ efforts to restrict sports event contracts within tribal lands.
Utah, which prohibits virtually all gambling, has pursued both civil and criminal enforcement against Kalshi, leading many leading prediction markets to exit the market. State authorities filed criminal charges against the company's cofounders in October, escalating the dispute beyond the civil proceedings underway elsewhere.
The Maryland decision could encourage other Fourth Circuit states to pursue similar restrictions. North Carolina, Virginia, and West Virginia already operate regulated sports betting markets, while South Carolina has not legalized sports wagering.
The Fourth Circuit's decision could strengthen regulators or attorneys general when challenging prediction market operators offering contracts without state licenses.
Supreme Court decision looms
The Fourth Circuit decision further strengthens the states' position in a widening federal appeals court dispute that could ultimately determine the future of nationwide sports prediction markets.
The Third Circuit ruled in Kalshi's favor in April, preventing New Jersey regulators from enforcing state gambling restrictions against the exchange. However, the Ninth Circuit subsequently sided with Nevada in August, followed by a Sixth Circuit ruling supporting Ohio and Tennessee in September.
With the Fourth Circuit decision, three federal appeals courts have now ruled against Kalshi's efforts to avoid state gambling regulations, compared with one that has supported the company's position.
The conflicting rulings may increase pressure on the Supreme Court to settle the dispute. New Jersey regulators have already petitioned the justices to review the Third Circuit's decision, while prediction market companies have sought review of unfavorable appellate rulings.
The Supreme Court has not yet agreed to hear the underlying dispute.
Legal experts believe the divided circuits increase the likelihood of Supreme Court action, but a timeline is uncertain. The Supreme Court has only a few months left to decide to take the case in the current term; without action, a decision may not come down until summer 2028.
Until the justices intervene, the Fourth Circuit's decision leaves Maryland closer to enforcing its gambling restrictions against Kalshi and adds another major legal obstacle to prediction markets' ambitions of offering sports contracts nationwide.






