How often do u see the FB bat the ball back and the opp winger get the ball.
Very rarely happens. Normally the fullback gets the ball back or the supporting winger is back there to get it
you're argument is losing legs really rapidly.
There was ZERO luck in that try, rather SKILL, EFFORT and EXECUTION.
Ahhh, this is where you and Hirschfelder see the same thing.
If the probability of something happening is low, Hirshfelder says that it is not luck as there is a probability it could have happened.
I am agreeing with hi, he describes the event as the probability , i use a philosophical term to describe the low probability event happening, which the majority of people do.
If there is a 0.5% chance of me hitting a 1/2 court shot and i hit it. There was a chance of it happening and it did, but because the chances are so low, it was a lucky shot.
Luck is just used to describe a low probability event.
Ahhh, this is where you and Hirschfelder see the same thing.
If the probability of something happening is low, Hirshfelder says that it is not luck as there is a probability it could have happened.
I am agreeing with hi, he describes the event as the probability , i use a philosophical term to describe the low probability event happening, which the majority of people do.
If there is a 0.5% chance of me hitting a 1/2 court shot and i hit it. There was a chance of it happening and it did, but because the chances are so low, it was a lucky shot.
Luck is just used to describe a low probability event.
the kick was skill.
the chase was effort.
the try was a culmination of the two, blended with some execution.
to call that try 'lucky' is to be an ignorant fool 
the kick was skill.
the chase was effort.
the try was a culmination of the two, blended with some execution.
to call that try 'lucky' is to be an ignorant fool
So lets rely on the fullback batting the ball back to get possesion again?
If Barba had half a brain and saw he didnt have support, then should let it go........
So lets rely on the fullback batting the ball back to get possesion again?
If Barba had half a brain and saw he didnt have support, then should let it go........
that's not the point.
the fact that he didn't let the ball go doesn't mean the try is 'luck'.
Ask John Cartwright if he thought he was lucky to win against the Raiders a few months ago...
Oh thats right, you see players making knock ons from the scrum 5 metres out from there own line every week?
Hey, if it wasnt for the Raiders try i dont win my bet...I just acknowledge where i am lucky and unlucky
So lets rely on the fullback batting the ball back to get possesion again?
If Barba had half a brain and saw he didnt have support, then should let it go........
and the Robinson intercept try had fuck all to do with 'luck'.
Robinson showed skill by reading the play as it unfolded.
He then showed further skill in correctly anticipating where the ball would be thrown.
He then showed skill and executed that skill by successfully intercepting the pass and scoring.
how the fuck is his effort pure 'luck'?
and the Robinson intercept try had fuck all to do with 'luck'.
Robinson showed skill by reading the play as it unfolded.
He then showed further skill in correctly anticipating where the ball would be thrown.
He then showed skill and executed that skill by successfully intercepting the pass and scoring.
how the fuck is his effort pure 'luck'?
Established in 1995,
Deplorable rugby league side the Doggies
Rush Hour
A2M
Hot Forum Topics
