who had the better career ? Eli or Rodgers or Peyton ?

@AJ86

 Eli Hands Down 

what did Peyton do ? 

BRAD

@AJ86

 simpkle answer the player with the best playoff stats the guy with 2-0 record , the guy with 8-4 records , the guy with more td than ints

So if you are undefeated in the superbowl that means you are elite correct?

Only being 117-117 in your career is disregarded....

lol lol 

I didn’t even skim this shit but Peyton Manning is the best football player of all time at any position. 

@AJ86

 there are alot of great Qbs with 500 records and we praise them , yes being undefeated in Superbowl's against the best of the era in winning fashion does make him elite

list of QBS under 60 %

Troy Aikman -55% 

Philip Rivers - 56% 

Kirk Kousin 

Jim Plunkett 

Kurt Warner 

joe Namath 

Mike Vick 

whats your point 

@AnthonyStarks

  the best doent throw 251 interceptions and take 9 years to reach super bowls

@Brooklyncapper

 They were all great! but I would give it to both Eli and Peyton as they were much better and smarter than Rodgers. They also both showed showed class even to this day which is a trait of only the Greatest of the Greatest!!

Regular season games Peyton if he isn't facing the Brady/Belichick Patriots and if we are talking Superbowl starts, I would go with Eli.

Eli was the Patriots kryptonite. Yes, Eli had a defense but so did the other two and so did Brady. 
Rodgers was a big game choker in the post season aside from the one Superbowl win. 

eli 2c sb wins  over the  tom brady pats peyton also t wo sb wins

Phillip Rivers

Eli is Peyton's special needs brother.

It's very interesting watching Eli & Peyton do their Monday night show.

You can get a sense of the psyche of someone when seeing reactions in real time and relatively unscripted.

Peyton gets very excited while Eli is almost subdued.

You see this with Tom Brady as well. I can imagine this is what they were like with 2 minutes remaining and you needed to score.

Of course Eli had the better career. He has 2 rings.   And a team that helped him out a lot.  

as an individual player then that’s a different story.  

So Eli had the better career because he had 2 rings? Were his 2 rings better than Peyton's 2 rings?

I need more details

This thread hurts my brain man

I think we are splitting hairs on the legendary and classy Manning family. We know one thing for sure based on the back end of Aaron Rodgers career. He is a distant third based on his Kobe Bryant like selfishness as a teammate. There's more to life than numbers. 

Given a choice I’d rather been a teammate with Eli ! He has always taken the high road! It’s amazing how that family has stayed normal with all the celebrity status of the father and fame + money of their own! There parents could have not done a better job!