If Peyton Wins, Where he rank among all-time QBs?

Seriously I respect the argument when it comes to Montana or maybe even Brady, although I think Peyton is better then Brady, but Favre?

The guy has 1 ring like Manning so all of those people can't say anything especially since Manning has a chance to win 1 or maybe even 2 more before it's all said and done.

Now if you look at the numbers Manning has a career QB rating of almost 10 points higher then Favre.  Manning's playoff QB rating is also higher.

Favre throws a td 5.0% of his attempts and interceptions 3.2% of his attempts

Manning throws a td 5.6% of his passes and interceptions only 2.7% of the time.

There are really no numbers that you can show me that would make me think Favre is on the same playing field as Manning.

No fault of his though.

Manning is the Jerry rice of his position. You can't out work him. Look at his WRs and RBs. No HOFs there. Best all time.

top 3

At the end of today, if he wins, Top 5 all time.  As he continues to put up numbers in record fashion, he will be the Greatest of All Time.  Still only Top 5 until he wins more SB's

Doesnt much matter now.

somewhere in a crowd that includes trent difer, donovan Mcnabb, brett favre and danny white.