TRADE: ryan mathews vs shonn greene

i would get

shonn greene, reggie wayne, fred taylor

he would get

ryan mathews, ahmad bradshaw, tim hightower.

my runnung backs now are those 3 , jahvid best, cadillac

my wr are welker, calvin johnson, malcom floyd, marc clayton

i need to start 2 rbs 2 wr and 1flex

should i do this trade?

I would say definately not. I don't think Matthews will be out long.

I think you're in fine shape. For this week you can start: Best, Bradshaw, Megatron, Welker, & either floyd or Caddy.
When Matthews is back you can have Bradshaw as your flex. Floyd & Caddy will make for fine bye week plays.

LT now appears to be getting a few more touches a game than Greene. I'm not sure Wayne will hold up all year. His production could easily drop off the second half of the season. And I wouldn't want to be trading for Fragile Fred. That NE backfield is a mess. The Law Firm & Morris will also get carries. Plus I think there's another RB that might get a few touches.

time share running backs . matthews and bradshaw are far from time shares now it looks like. you dont want to be running out there every week best and greene. ya best has had 2 good weeks. what if he is not what he has been the 1st 2 weeks. every week you would be getting like 15 points from your 2 running backs.yikes. your wr are fine as they are. if you start wayne every week and leave floyd on your bench which you would have to he would what maybe outscore him by 4 or 5 on a week to week basis if that. not worth is cause bradshaw and matthews will outscore green every week no doubt. hope that makes sense. kind of rambling. greene will be one of the biggest 1st-2nd round busts ever by the looks of it. my point being there is not to much of a difference from floyd or welker to wayne and there is a huge difference from bradshaw and matthews to greene.

yea, thats what i was thinking, was to reject it. but the traded offer was fair and made me think about it. thanks for the respnses