TRADE EVALUATION....PLEASE

I have:

RBs
Gore
Hightower
P.Thomas
C. Williams

WRs
R. Moss
Sims-Walker
Bowe
L. Moore

I was just offered a trade: 

I give up P. Thomas

I get B. Marshall and L. McCoy......

Any thoughts would be appreciated.

Do it now!

agreed

The thing that makes me nervous is the fact that Thomas' schedule is pretty favorable......the Saints will be playing against some patsies for the next 5 weeks.  ATL, CAR, STL TB (NE-tough), WASH, ATL....etc.....

accept!

if u do that ur rb's would be weak , but u'd have a serious receiving core  try and get greene from the jets

whats shonn greene really going to do but sit the bench, just like sproles.

I thought of picking p greene, but I went with jamal charles instead, he has bye week but, im just really sick of having 2nd string rbs and wondering when they will play.

sounds fair
do it I say

keep an eye on ahman green

That's a steal for Marshall. He's a beast.

marshall is a best.. go get him

I would do it.

thomas is not even getting the most carries and mike bell is getting the goal line looks so do the trade now

I hope you didn't....

 

I disagree with all of these other posters.....the dropoff from Thomas and Gore to the rest of your runnings backs is not worth it

you have good WRs already

Don't do it... The Saints have the most favorable schedule for RBs in the league going forward, and even with Bell around, Thomas should have a monster second half of the season. On the other hand, Denver has a very unfavorable schedule for WRs the rest of the way, and although Marshall is a beast and should be able to rack up very decent points, I still belive Thomas should have a much better second half. McCoy is ok, but the Eagles schedule is not favorable, and he won't be a big factor until Westie goes down for good, so I don't think you will be able to use him much over your core. Don't pull the trigger on this one...

Dont do it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Didn't do it....and PT wound up winning the game for me with his 2 TD outing last week......