Johnson or Peterson for #1 Pick in Fantasy Football?

I got the #1 pick in my fantasy league this year...which of these two would you pick?  Will Johnson experince a significant drop-off making AP the more reliable choice?

Hel pe me "Covers Brothers"....Thanks!

CJ2K and it's not even close


Actually it's kind of close, but still you go CJ2K.  If its a PPR league, then you don't even debate it

Aaron Rodgers!

Please do....I'd be happy to take your money!

 Unless qb's get 20 points for td's i would like to be in you're league as well.

Ive won my league 3 years straight taking Peyton Manning in 2007 and 2008 and Brees in 2009....I have a good feeling about Rodgers blowin up this year.....

Granted if I had the 1st or 2nd pick, I'd take Johnson....AP is injury prone....

Any pick 3 or higher....I'm takin the best QB....

I have Pick #3 this year in my main League and am considering Brees over any running back.

I was shocked to see Randy Moss picked in the top 12 of many mock drafts as well as real ones. Is there something that I am missing here?

Chris Johnson sir!

Probably........He's averaged 81-1300-1 over his past 3 years.  He's in a contract year, Brady is back fully healthy after playing last year after a significant knee injury, and all the reports out of training camp have suggested that he's in the best shape he's ever been in, and he looks great and motivated.

*81-1300-16   

 

So it obvious you play in a league that is filled with women and people that ride the short bus while licking the windows.

 

 

Just for the record, if it's a PPR league, hands down CJ.  If it's just yardage based with td's, it's a flip of the coin.  But if I had the pick, I'd go with CJ or see if someone is in love with him, like at pick 3, then get an extra pick and at worst, get Ray Rice.

Suck it!

Standard re-draft league and not PPR I would definately go with AP.  Chris Johnson had a great year last year no doubt but AP has been having great years for the last three.  I like his consistency.  Also, whoever said that he is injury prone... WTF?  How so?  His rookie year was the only year he missed a game.  Finally, Chris Johnson had what 408 touches last year.  I cannot remember a time since I started playing fantasy football (1997) in which a running back with over 375 touches didn't have a SIGNIFICANT injury the following year.  I honestly would pass on Chris Johnson.  BOL!

"Well allow me to retorte"

By saying he is injury prone....I believe that he has a higher chance of being injured due to the style and way he runs....He is a bruiser and seeks out contact on every run....He wants to run over every defensive player in his path.....When you're purposely trying to run over 270 pound linebackers with every run, most likely you are going to run into some kind of injury....

That is all

I've got the first pick and I've been thinking about taking Rodgers. My next pick wouldnt be til #20 and I thought I could get Mathews there and then a receiver... but i did a mock draft today and wasnt even close to getting him

(we get 6pts for TD by QB btw)

So now im looking into Chris Johnson then Romo - though he went alot earlier than expected last year. 

I really think Rodgers is the top pick in my league and am even thinking I would rather have the 4th or 5th pick so I could start off with Rodgers, Mathews...

And I won back to back championships in 06 and 07 and finished 2nd in 08!

Though I finished last, last year hence the first pick this year

 

have the first pick in my league and it will be CJ2k, but i am in a league that give more points for longer tds, so its an absolute no brainer