Fantasy Quarterback adviced needed for Week 15

Guys,

Badly need help! First week of the Playoffs. I lost Romo then Stafford and then Hill so I have at rotten luck at the QB position. Next week I have the choice between...

1) Josh Freeman (Tampa at home to Detroit)

2) David Garrard (Jags @ Colts)

3) Kerry Collins (Tennesse at home to Houston)

I have been back and forth between all 3. Freeman seems to score between 15-20 points each week. The other 2 seem hit or bust. Any feedback would be GREATLY appreciated...Cheers

Also McNabb @ Dallas

Definitely throw out Collins and probably McNabb too.  I would feel alright with Freeman or Garrard, but like you said Freeman is more consistent while Garrard has a higher upside.  Also look if Kitna is available, he has been pretty productive for Dallas.  

I'd go Garrard

Collins

Mack 05, Mcnabb's history against Dallas is appealling here. Dallas also has the possiblity of getting up big and McNabb will be throwing the ball against a shaky secondary. I'm 11-3 this year, and many previous successful and dollar making campaigns.

Jones=Drew has always ran well against the Colts on the turf.

Collins is garbage.

Freeman maybe the play here, but his track record leaves little to go by.

McNabb for me.

 

All this being said, Collins will probably rock, but I would never play him, draft him, or pick him up on the wire.

McNabb will play!!!!!!!!!!!!

McNabb will play

I was surprised by that move.

How did it turn out Mack?

I would have picked Garrard. Your choices were the best player from a pool of average guys. Tho they all did fairly well.