Fantasy Baseball Question

I know there's a forum for this but it seems like no one looks at it...so here goes....

I've been offered Andrew Mccutchen for Andrew Bailey and Ricky Romero. We start 5 OF and it's probably my weakest position as I start Justin Upton, Colby Rasmus, Carlos Gonzalez, Garrett Jones, and Travis Snider (With Delmon Young, Cameron Maybin, and Mike Stanton on the bench. So I couldn't definitely use Mccutchen. We start 8 pitchers, it is your choice of how you want to assemble your staff, you can go 2 closers and 6 starters or 3 and 5 etc etc. My Rotation consists of Tommy Hanson, Clayton Kershaw, Francisco Liriano, Justin Verlander, Ricky Nolasco and 3 closers this week, Andrew Bailey, Neftali Feliz, and Carlos Marmol. So I'm pretty solid in most pitching aspects, and even though Romero strikes out a ton I have plenty of other high strikeout pitchers. As far as Bailey goes, I still would have Feliz and Marmol, and Matt Thornton is available in our league, who I think will soon be closing games for the White Sox.

So my question to you guys is, would you do this trade? Romero is a legitimate 15 W and 200K guy. While Bailey hasn't allowed an ER this season and looks like he could post 30-35 saves. Thanks in advance for the help.

Dont do it.  Its likely that they over paid for mccutchen and are trying to get some value from their pick.  There are other outfielders worth targeting that will help you out more.

Well he does help in all 6 categories. Which are HR, RBI, R, AVG, SB, and OPS by the way...

The guy who offered me the trade actually has no idea what he's doing, his first time doing fantasy baseball.

It should say "I COULD definitely use Mccutchen"

Romero is also a potential 4.5 ERA and 1.4 WHIP guy.  Unless that doesn't matter to you.

I agree Hutch, he shit the bed after a hot start to last season...the big piece in this deal for me is Bailey...I can afford to give up Romero's W's and K's with  the other pitchers I have listed

anyone else?

All I am saying is that if your looking for outfield help, I would find someone else to target.  I look at trading in fantasy baseball, kinda like poker.  I would rather be the one betting, than calling.  Meaning,  I would rather be the one offering trades, rather than accepting.  Obviously there are no brainer situations, where you are going to accept a trade, but I do not think this is one of those.  Just my humble opinion.  If you are looking for solid all around production, I would target under achievers this year like adam lind, jacoby ellsbury, and even jonny damon.  Maybe see if you could get Shin-soo Choo.

Any other opinions? Would be greatly appreciated...