A trade proposed to me....

I don't think I'll accept but just in case I miss the boat, I'll ask.  This is a keeper league where we get to keep 5 players at year's end.  Right now my 5 are David Price, Stephen Strasburg (carrying him on my DL), Joey Votto, Josh Hamilton & Jacoby Ellsbury.

I would get:
C Alex Avila & OF Sam Fuld

I would give up:
C Russell Martin & OF Grady Sizemore

It should be noted that my starting catcher is actually Matt Weiters.

My bad, Ellsbury is no longer one of my five, I replaced him with Ryan Zimmerman.

Huh?

i would take a dump on that trade and light it on fire...avila and fuld are doing well now but face it if they start to slide they could end up not even being starters on their teams....since u have weiters i would try to trade one of ur catchers..most likley martin since he'd been tearin it up and could probably get back more in return...too early to tell on sizemore waht he is truly worth