MLB Player Props & Best Bets Today for September 16: Horton Hears a K

Cade Horton's strikeout ability highlights our MLB player prop picks for today's action on the diamond.

Neil Parker - Analyst at Covers.com
Neil Parker • Betting Analyst
Sep 16, 2025 • 11:27 ET • 4 min read
Chicago Cubs pitcher Cade Horton (22) pitches the ball against the Atlanta Braves during the first inning at Truist Park.
Photo By - Imagn Images. Chicago Cubs pitcher Cade Horton (22) pitches the ball against the Atlanta Braves during the first inning at Truist Park.

The divisional and Wild Card races are heating up on the diamond with just a handful of games remaining on the schedule.

It’s a loaded slate on the diamond Tuesday, September 16, and my top MLB player props are headlined by rolling Chicago Cubs righty Cade Horton.

Best MLB player props today

  • TEAM Horton o4.5 strikeouts (+105)
  • TEAM Chisholm Jr. o1.5 hits+runs+RBI (-110)
  • TEAM Blubaugh o3.5 strikeouts (-125)

Our 3 best MLB player props for Tuesday, September 16

Take a look at our best bets and expert analysis below.

Prop #1: Cade Horton Over 4.5 strikeouts

+105 at BetMGM

The Pittsburgh Pirates have the seventh-highest strikeout percentage against righties this season and also rank seventh-highest overall across the past 30 days. 

Chicago Cubs rookie Cade Horton’s strikeout numbers are also on the rise with an 8.92 K/9 and a 25.9 K% across his past seven starts compared to respective 6.48 and 17.3% to start the year.

  • Time: 6:40 p.m. ET
  • Where to watch: MARQ, SNP

Prop #2: Jazz Chisholm Jr. Over 1.5 hits+runs+RBI

-110 at BetMGM

New York Yankees infielder Jazz Chisholm Jr. lands in the perfect matchup to snap an 0-for-7 slump at the dish with Minnesota Twins starter Zebby Matthews serving up a healthy .362 wOBA and .844 OPS to left-handed hitters this season. 

Chisholm hits in the middle of the loaded New York lineup, and he’s been solid all year against righties with respective .367 and .862 marks to go along with a high-end .282 ISO.

  • Time: 7:40 p.m. ET
  • Where to watch: YES, MNNT

Prop #3: AJ Blubaugh Over 3.5 strikeouts

-125 at BetMGM

Houston Astros righty AJ Blubaugh has pitched eight scoreless innings while striking out nine batters across four September appearances, and I expect him to pitch deep enough into Tuesday’s contest to pile up four or more punchouts. 

Additionally, if the Texas Rangers didn’t have a middling 21 1/3 strikeout percentage against righties, I think this total would be 4.5 given Blubaugh’s solid 28.7% mark.

  • Time: 8:10 p.m. ET
  • Where to watch: RSN, SCHN

Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

Pages related to this topic

Neil Parker - Covers
Betting Analyst

Neil Parker is, first and foremost, a sports fan. A huge supporter of the Cowboys, Cubs, and Maple Leafs, he has managed to parlay his passion into writing gigs at some of the top websites in the industry.

Neil takes a numbers-based approach to his handicapping and complements his in-depth statistical analysis with a keen eye on the markets to provide the best available odds. He loves to lean on his rolodex of idioms to offset his inner nerd. When it comes to wagering, he throws down on anything that catches his eye at bet365, Betway and BetVictor. He also keeps a close eye on CoolBet because the polar bear brand often has outlier NHL and NFL moneyline prices.

Neil graduated with honors from St. Thomas University in 2007 before completing his BEd at Acadia University in 2010. After teaching a myriad of courses and subjects, he found a groove delivering fun lessons to exceptional learners in non-traditional classroom environments. If his decade-plus teaching run taught him anything about sports betting, it’s to stay the course and use the summer – or offseason – to refresh and prepare to be better in the year to come.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo