Let's talk about what "most valuable" really means. The Bengals are paying nearly a quarter of their salary cap, by average salary, to two of the top wide receivers in the NFL. Ja'Marr Chase is elite, and 6'4" Tee Higgins is having a career year. He's second in the entire league in receiving yards. That's not a quarterback carrying a team. That's a quarterback with two Ferraris in the garage.
The MVP should go to the player a team can't win without. And the numbers back it up: when Tee Higgins is out, Burrow is just 5-7. Take away one of those receivers, and Burrow looks pretty ordinary.
Don't believe me? Ask Matthew Stafford how much a top receiver matters. Cooper Kupp won the receiving triple crown, and Stafford walked away with a Super Bowl ring.
To remove first post, remove entire topic.
Let's talk about what "most valuable" really means. The Bengals are paying nearly a quarter of their salary cap, by average salary, to two of the top wide receivers in the NFL. Ja'Marr Chase is elite, and 6'4" Tee Higgins is having a career year. He's second in the entire league in receiving yards. That's not a quarterback carrying a team. That's a quarterback with two Ferraris in the garage.
The MVP should go to the player a team can't win without. And the numbers back it up: when Tee Higgins is out, Burrow is just 5-7. Take away one of those receivers, and Burrow looks pretty ordinary.
Don't believe me? Ask Matthew Stafford how much a top receiver matters. Cooper Kupp won the receiving triple crown, and Stafford walked away with a Super Bowl ring.
Mvp has always been the QB with top tier stats and top tier record in the nfl..I don't think the voters ever really look at supporting cast or schedule unless it's a close race..
Mvp has always been the QB with top tier stats and top tier record in the nfl..I don't think the voters ever really look at supporting cast or schedule unless it's a close race..
Thank you for asking River...Across the that started at quarterback for the during the 2025 season, wide receiver recorded 27 receptions on 43 targets for 417 receiving yards and 5 touchdowns
Then there was three lifetime backups:
(2020–2021)
(2020)
(2023, 2025)
<
@River_fish
Thank you for asking River...Across the that started at quarterback for the during the 2025 season, wide receiver recorded 27 receptions on 43 targets for 417 receiving yards and 5 touchdowns
Fair point, everybody sees it a little differently. Stats are for fantasy football. I trust my eyes, and they've been watching this game for close to six decades. They need reading glasses now, but they still know a quarterback with two Ferraris in the garage when they see one.
@BigNutsCapper
Fair point, everybody sees it a little differently. Stats are for fantasy football. I trust my eyes, and they've been watching this game for close to six decades. They need reading glasses now, but they still know a quarterback with two Ferraris in the garage when they see one.
Hilarious that everybody's losing their minds about him coming back on the Tennessee Titans. they wouldn't have had to come back if he didn't throw three interceptions. and then Atlanta coaching = JETS and Washington. They keep forgetting that they have Bijon Robinson
@smellybunty
Hilarious that everybody's losing their minds about him coming back on the Tennessee Titans. they wouldn't have had to come back if he didn't throw three interceptions. and then Atlanta coaching = JETS and Washington. They keep forgetting that they have Bijon Robinson
Thanks for the question, @Raiders22, and thanks for the quarterback.
Josh Allen. There's only one Josh Allen. The other one had to change his name to Josh Hines-Allen just to get some peace. he does something freaky every week,.
Brock Purdy. Purdy has a better argument than Burrow, because he's been doing it with different pieces every week. That doesn't make him more valuable than Allen is to Buffalo, but he has the best story. The Niners defense can win games. Buffalo's defense can win against third-stringers, so far. And going from Mr. Irrelevant to MVP? Someday they'll make that movie. Working title: Mr. Relevant.
Jordan Love. Love is throwing the most accurate deep ball I can remember. Every game he launches bombs 40 to 50 yards downfield, and they land right in his receivers' laps. Sometimes they even stay there. No run game, plenty of drops, and you can still get him around +650.
Patrick Mahomes. He has to stay in the conversation. He's playing with broken pieces after a brutal injury last year, and he's clearly the emotional lift for that team. Even his odds look injured right now, which is why I like him.
Kirk Cousins. He hasn't played a down in his return to the Vikings yet, but I won't be surprised if he's in this race at the end of the year. He had 20 TD passes in Vegas, second most in the league. Raiders fans, you're welcome to cheer for him. Just quietly. I'm sure the odds are going down by the minute, so if you like him, could be the deal of the century for MVP odds. +4500?
Honorable mention: Kenneth Walker. I loved watching him break long runs at Michigan State, and I thought Seattle underused him. Seattle proved a running back can be MVP of the Super Bowl, just not MVP of the season after they stuffed him a couple weeks ago
@Raiders22
Thanks for the question, @Raiders22, and thanks for the quarterback.
Josh Allen. There's only one Josh Allen. The other one had to change his name to Josh Hines-Allen just to get some peace. he does something freaky every week,.
Brock Purdy. Purdy has a better argument than Burrow, because he's been doing it with different pieces every week. That doesn't make him more valuable than Allen is to Buffalo, but he has the best story. The Niners defense can win games. Buffalo's defense can win against third-stringers, so far. And going from Mr. Irrelevant to MVP? Someday they'll make that movie. Working title: Mr. Relevant.
Jordan Love. Love is throwing the most accurate deep ball I can remember. Every game he launches bombs 40 to 50 yards downfield, and they land right in his receivers' laps. Sometimes they even stay there. No run game, plenty of drops, and you can still get him around +650.
Patrick Mahomes. He has to stay in the conversation. He's playing with broken pieces after a brutal injury last year, and he's clearly the emotional lift for that team. Even his odds look injured right now, which is why I like him.
Kirk Cousins. He hasn't played a down in his return to the Vikings yet, but I won't be surprised if he's in this race at the end of the year. He had 20 TD passes in Vegas, second most in the league. Raiders fans, you're welcome to cheer for him. Just quietly. I'm sure the odds are going down by the minute, so if you like him, could be the deal of the century for MVP odds. +4500?
Honorable mention: Kenneth Walker. I loved watching him break long runs at Michigan State, and I thought Seattle underused him. Seattle proved a running back can be MVP of the Super Bowl, just not MVP of the season after they stuffed him a couple weeks ago
It has to be considered that way I think because that sort of thing takes into account because it matters not just how important they are to their team but how well they have played overall.
Yes, Walker has been a huge benefit to KC.
I also think Cousins is interesting. For, example he now will have potentially an extra game to play this year because of the trade.
He is 5th in total yards and could easily leapfrog the other 4 in total yards with that extra game.
@bulubulu
Nice list.
I think you have to throw Williams and Lawrence in there as well. Even Maye might be considered if he has a few more good games.
But one you have to really look at is Prescott. It can very easily argued he means more to his team than anyone but Mahomes, Allen, and Burrow.
If you look at PE/Play for example: Williams, Burrow, Maye, Prescott are the leaders.
It has to be considered that way I think because that sort of thing takes into account because it matters not just how important they are to their team but how well they have played overall.
Yes, Walker has been a huge benefit to KC.
I also think Cousins is interesting. For, example he now will have potentially an extra game to play this year because of the trade.
He is 5th in total yards and could easily leapfrog the other 4 in total yards with that extra game.
To be honest it's too early to crown an MVP,it's nice to talk about though...it will probably won't be decided until the very end... nobody is running away
To be honest it's too early to crown an MVP,it's nice to talk about though...it will probably won't be decided until the very end... nobody is running away
Unfortunately mvp has always been more stats based than “how valuable a player is to his team based”. We know what a rb or wr would have to do to win this award.
Burrow is on a pace right now for close to or maybe over 5,000 passing yards and certainly over 40 and potentially towards 50 passing TDs. The only other player I see getting near those stats is Jordan Love. The question will then become how does the team perform and finish the season? The Bengals face a very favorable schedule. The Packers will go through the meat grinder in its own division. Cincy has only Pittsburgh to fend off for the division and it’s really hard to make a case for Pittsburgh having a better record at the end of the season.
So IF Burrow finishes around 5000 yards, over 40 TD passes, wins the division, and is potentially a 1 or 2 seed in the AFC, it’ll become impossible for voters to ignore.
My advice is to start building your position on Burrow MVP and Cincy over 12.5 wins before Sunday. With a win and a good game from Burrow those current odds will change. JA vs the jets could play a role. If he puts up a stinker vs the jets…boy oh boy. I haven’t done anything with MVP yet but I certainly will be invested in ov 12.5 wins for Cincy. Even if they lose to Pittsburgh it’s still in play and if they win I have to believe those odds go negative.
@bulubulu
@Raiders22
Unfortunately mvp has always been more stats based than “how valuable a player is to his team based”. We know what a rb or wr would have to do to win this award.
Burrow is on a pace right now for close to or maybe over 5,000 passing yards and certainly over 40 and potentially towards 50 passing TDs. The only other player I see getting near those stats is Jordan Love. The question will then become how does the team perform and finish the season? The Bengals face a very favorable schedule. The Packers will go through the meat grinder in its own division. Cincy has only Pittsburgh to fend off for the division and it’s really hard to make a case for Pittsburgh having a better record at the end of the season.
So IF Burrow finishes around 5000 yards, over 40 TD passes, wins the division, and is potentially a 1 or 2 seed in the AFC, it’ll become impossible for voters to ignore.
My advice is to start building your position on Burrow MVP and Cincy over 12.5 wins before Sunday. With a win and a good game from Burrow those current odds will change. JA vs the jets could play a role. If he puts up a stinker vs the jets…boy oh boy. I haven’t done anything with MVP yet but I certainly will be invested in ov 12.5 wins for Cincy. Even if they lose to Pittsburgh it’s still in play and if they win I have to believe those odds go negative.
Unfortunately mvp has always been more stats based than “how valuable a player is to his team based”.
Yes, because this comes down to too many opinions. How do you 'decide' that Mahomes and Burrow would do better or worse if they switched teams.
I think a small flyer could be started on Cousins. What if he comes in and starts finding Jefferson and with his extra game pads his stats. Then if MIN gets hot and he is seen as the reason.
But at this point it is Burrow's to lose.
@brn2loslive2win
Unfortunately mvp has always been more stats based than “how valuable a player is to his team based”.
Yes, because this comes down to too many opinions. How do you 'decide' that Mahomes and Burrow would do better or worse if they switched teams.
I think a small flyer could be started on Cousins. What if he comes in and starts finding Jefferson and with his extra game pads his stats. Then if MIN gets hot and he is seen as the reason.
With Caleb and Trevor, I think it's more about the coaching. Those are two very well coached, well balanced teams. Give the head coaches some MVP votes too. You are correct, though they both should be consideredat least as much as Burrow
Josh is my number one because of all the intangibles. I know a lot of people blame him for the playoff losses, but look closer. In his six playoff losses since 2020, his defense gave up an average of 33 points.
Start with "13 Seconds." Josh threw his fourth TD to Gabe Davis to take a 36-33 lead with 13 seconds left in Kansas City. The defense still couldn't hold it, and the Bills lost 42-36 in overtime. That should have been the year Sean McDermott lost his job. Instead it took four more years.
The last three losses were all by 3 points. Two seasons ago, his final throw in the AFC title game hit #86 Dalton Kincaid right in the hands and fell to the turf. Before that, Dion Dawkins got shoved right back into him mid-throw on what would've been the game-winner to Khalil Shakir. Hard to win when your own left tackle is part of the pass rush.
I'll own the Denver game. Four turnovers in a playoff game is inexcusable, and Josh said so himself. But even then, it was a one-score game right to the final whistle.
And that's the eye test. Value isn't just a stat line. It's what we get for watching. Some of the most exciting games I've ever seen had Josh Allen at quarterback, almost every one decided on the last drive. We viewers got our money's worth. My blood pressure did not.
@Raiders22
With Caleb and Trevor, I think it's more about the coaching. Those are two very well coached, well balanced teams. Give the head coaches some MVP votes too. You are correct, though they both should be consideredat least as much as Burrow
Josh is my number one because of all the intangibles. I know a lot of people blame him for the playoff losses, but look closer. In his six playoff losses since 2020, his defense gave up an average of 33 points.
Start with "13 Seconds." Josh threw his fourth TD to Gabe Davis to take a 36-33 lead with 13 seconds left in Kansas City. The defense still couldn't hold it, and the Bills lost 42-36 in overtime. That should have been the year Sean McDermott lost his job. Instead it took four more years.
The last three losses were all by 3 points. Two seasons ago, his final throw in the AFC title game hit #86 Dalton Kincaid right in the hands and fell to the turf. Before that, Dion Dawkins got shoved right back into him mid-throw on what would've been the game-winner to Khalil Shakir. Hard to win when your own left tackle is part of the pass rush.
I'll own the Denver game. Four turnovers in a playoff game is inexcusable, and Josh said so himself. But even then, it was a one-score game right to the final whistle.
And that's the eye test. Value isn't just a stat line. It's what we get for watching. Some of the most exciting games I've ever seen had Josh Allen at quarterback, almost every one decided on the last drive. We viewers got our money's worth. My blood pressure did not.
I understand. I think he is exciting and fun to watch. That is enough to keep him in the conversation for sure. But excitement and cold stretches at crucial times is not enough to put him at the elite level to me. But the talent cannot be denied. There have been some great exciting QBs and he is one for sure.
@bulubulu
I understand. I think he is exciting and fun to watch. That is enough to keep him in the conversation for sure. But excitement and cold stretches at crucial times is not enough to put him at the elite level to me. But the talent cannot be denied. There have been some great exciting QBs and he is one for sure.
Drew Lock has a higher QBR LOL. So, the stats argument eliminates all intangibles and just says whoever ends up with the most passing TDs gets it right? Or is it most yardage? Or is it simply fantasy point? Big nuts is right and it's too early. Alls I'm saying is that certain QBs like Burrow and Dak have an unfair advantage with 2 Ferraris. If Addison stats pick up tremendously then it will be Cousins' race to lose unless Josh makes an all time prime time game winning play on Thanksgiving night in front of the world
@brn2loslive2win
Drew Lock has a higher QBR LOL. So, the stats argument eliminates all intangibles and just says whoever ends up with the most passing TDs gets it right? Or is it most yardage? Or is it simply fantasy point? Big nuts is right and it's too early. Alls I'm saying is that certain QBs like Burrow and Dak have an unfair advantage with 2 Ferraris. If Addison stats pick up tremendously then it will be Cousins' race to lose unless Josh makes an all time prime time game winning play on Thanksgiving night in front of the world