Would Kobe or Jordan have been able to win with LBJ's supporting cast?

What do you think?

 

Jordan yes

Kobe no

Jordan absolutely

Kobe maybe...

Kobe is a better pure scorer than LeBron.  I thought LeBron needed to score 40+ last night for them to win and he just doesn't get that.  Kobe would have.  Jordan for sure.  He would have scored 50 last night.

Jordan yes. Kobe maybe, but not as many times as he has...

Kobe had a squad with Smush Parker, Kwame Brown and Luke Walton one rebound away from upsetting the Suns in 2006.  Kobe would get to the Finals every year in the East with Bron's teams..

Keep in mind with jordan he lost 3 straight years in the late 80s to the pistons so he struggled to win for awhile. I believe pippen was there for some of those

88-89 Bulls had Cartwright, Horace Grant, Scottie Pippen and MJ of course.  The year prior of course was the year they drafted both Pippen and Grant.    In the 89-90 season they drafted BJ Armstrong and pushed the Pistons to a 7 game series in the Eastern Conference finals.  Whom ended up winning the title.   Then of course the next year they won the NBA title...3 in a row.  As a matter of a fact I believe the Bulls lost to the Pistons in the East Finals and they ended up winning the title both years. 

i dont think kobe would of won... he was struggling with his team before gasol got there, and they had a decent team..

First round exit.

Kobe and Jordan have a reliable jumpshot. James does not.

Jordan ofcourse who did he have that was that much better then what LeBron had to work with. Kobe I dont see why not his only other big time play maker is Pao.

What kind of players does LeBron need to actually win, the amount of money they invested in him its not as though they were flushed for FA cash to buy up top FA players their should be no complaints from Lebron about his supporting cast.

i do not think there is an NBA player who has ever played the game who could be inserted into LBJ's spot on the Cleveland Cavaliers and win a championship... not in a year when there are Orlando Magic, Boston Celtics and LA Lakers...

 

Jordan, or Kobe, or even Lebron could have won a championship with this team during a really shitty period of basketball... on a down year...

but even Wilt himself couldn't have helped them in a year where there were other quality teams...

failure!  this entire write-up is off target...

 

one player makes all the difference... when was the last time an NBA team won the NBA championship with just 1 superstar surrounded by role players?  think about it, guys... we're not talking rocket science here... why does everyone always get this shit wrong?

the answer to this thread is NO... and it is not really even debatable...

 

name 1 team in the last 20 years that won an NBA title with just one star on the team, surrounded by nothing but role players... that is what these Cleveland Cavaliers are... 1 star surrounded by no all-star caliber players... that is not and will not ever be an NBA championship team...

people are so stupid, acting like this is a surprise... it is not Lebron's fault that the media force fed this pretender of a team down your throat... it is no Lebron's fault that in 8 years Cleveland Cavaliers management didn't land ONE SINGLE All-Star to compliment him...

 

this may be a hypothetical question... but the question that is NOT hypothetical is this:

 

DID Jordan or Kobe ever win a title with a surrounding cast that is comparable to Lebron's... and the answer to that is...

 

are you high?  FUCK NO!  Kobe and Jordan won every single title surrounded by AT LEAST 1 All Star... Jordan had 2 perennial All Stars for almost every one of his titles, and Kobe had Shaq for all but one, and Pau for the other one (not to mention Bynum and Odom, giving them one of the best front lines of the last 20 years)...

how can anyone suggest Kobe or Jordan would have a title, when all evidence tells you they would not?  there is not a single thing that has happened over the last 25-30 years of basketball that would support any suggestion that Kobe or Jordan would have won a title with this team...

oh and let's not bother factoring coaching into the equation...

could Kobe or Jordan have ever won a title with Mike Brown as the coach?  or for that matter, could either one of them have ever won a title with anyone other than the guy who is considered the greatest coach of all time?

 

simple-mindedness gets you nowhere, and these forums are INFESTED with simple-minded fucks!

 

would Joe Montana have any Super Bowl Rings if he had been a Miami Dolphin and Dan Marino had been a SF 49er?  NO!

teams win championships... not players... there is a reason all of you suckers didn't realize before game 1 that Boston is a far better team than Cleveland... because you are simple-minded and think NBA titles (and Super Bowl Rings, etc...) are won by individuals instead of teams...

i know... that's far too complicated for my wittew bwain...

 

WEAK!

  Well said  

Lebroom I can help you....Kobe learned this from Jordan

a lot of people are forgetting that jordan won all his titles with a guy that was named to the top 50 nba players of all time, funny how everyone forgets about Pippen. The guy was a defensive machine and prettty great all around player too....

Ice is right on - NO

Though obviously Jordan could come closer in a down year with no real high quality tms.

The only guy in the last 20 yrs that got rings without any great, all-star quality players was Olajuwon but they were 2 sub-par quality NBA yrs when Jordan wasn't playing & Hakeem did it all as a center (O, D, boards, blocks, steals) & they had a great inside/outside game with good 3pt shooters.

I don't get why people say LeBron's suporting cast is bad. He made it to the Finals in 2007 with a MUCH worse squad. The Cavs finished the season with the best record in basketball...the team must have has some talent aside from LeBron to do that.

Jordan ripped his teammates new assholes in practice and in games...have never seen LeBron really get in anyone's face.Not mean enough, nowhere near as mean as Jordan.

Shaq, williams, and jamison all have been all stars.  Shaq now is better than any big man Jordan had.(longely, cartwright, purdue,etc)  Pippen is so over rated, how'd he do without jordan? 

Jordan would have a legit chance to win with this team,  YOu can be assured he wouldn't have quit or let his team quit in a loss.

Nope, No, Not a chance in hell.

Why do people act like MJ played with bums? Pippen was a stud, and Rodman was a monster on the boards/defense.

If anything, people now know how overrated Jamison is. People fell in love with him numbers. Is Moe Williams even close to being a top 20 pg?

Kobe? Come on, thats ridiculous. His head would have exploded playing with the guys LJ had.

So no.