my investing blog, can i get some feedback?
Some interesting stuff, but I disagree with your asset location rant. First of all, the capital gains rate will most likely not stay at 15% especially if a democrat is elected, and I'd recommend maxing out first in a ROTH Ira as since it is for retirement, youll not be paying anything on the earnings as opposed to what the capital gains rate will be in the future.
well said, I agree about the capital gains tax rate being increased, most likely,,,
Was your comment regarding the Roth IRA contributions stating that you think you should contribute to a Roth before contributing to a work 401k? (I'd like to understand your contention before I answer)
If that is what you were saying then I would obviously disagree b/c most work 401k plans will match and when you leave the job, as I am sure you know, you can roll it into a tax deferred rollover IRA.
If that is not what you are saying let me know and tell me which post it was included in. Thanks for th input Stuckey
![]()
Some interesting stuff, but I disagree with your asset location rant. First of all, the capital gains rate will most likely not stay at 15% especially if a democrat is elected, and I'd recommend maxing out first in a ROTH Ira as since it is for retirement, youll not be paying anything on the earnings as opposed to what the capital gains rate will be in the future.
well said, I agree about the capital gains tax rate being increased, most likely,,,
Was your comment regarding the Roth IRA contributions stating that you think you should contribute to a Roth before contributing to a work 401k? (I'd like to understand your contention before I answer)
If that is what you were saying then I would obviously disagree b/c most work 401k plans will match and when you leave the job, as I am sure you know, you can roll it into a tax deferred rollover IRA.
If that is not what you are saying let me know and tell me which post it was included in. Thanks for th input Stuckey
![]()
Some interesting stuff, but I disagree with your asset location rant. First of all, the capital gains rate will most likely not stay at 15% especially if a democrat is elected, and I'd recommend maxing out first in a ROTH Ira as since it is for retirement, youll not be paying anything on the earnings as opposed to what the capital gains rate will be in the future.
Can't really give a blanker recommendation on this. It depends on so many factors. First of all, if your 401K is being matched you gotta contribute at least up to the match for sure. Beyond that, and assuming you even qualify for a Roth, it depends largely on your current bracket. Not only that but some people are really in an even higher bracket because they may be in the middle of being phased our for certain deductions and credits (e.g. child tax credit, student loan interest) which can push effective marginal rate up over 35% easy. In that case, I say take the immediate upfront deduction and save more. Of course if it's a 401K you can still max that out and still contribute to a Roth if you qualify. I say do both. There is something to be said for tax account diversification. Have a traditional, a Roth and a regular brokerage. Adds more flexibility down the road.
Some interesting stuff, but I disagree with your asset location rant. First of all, the capital gains rate will most likely not stay at 15% especially if a democrat is elected, and I'd recommend maxing out first in a ROTH Ira as since it is for retirement, youll not be paying anything on the earnings as opposed to what the capital gains rate will be in the future.
Can't really give a blanker recommendation on this. It depends on so many factors. First of all, if your 401K is being matched you gotta contribute at least up to the match for sure. Beyond that, and assuming you even qualify for a Roth, it depends largely on your current bracket. Not only that but some people are really in an even higher bracket because they may be in the middle of being phased our for certain deductions and credits (e.g. child tax credit, student loan interest) which can push effective marginal rate up over 35% easy. In that case, I say take the immediate upfront deduction and save more. Of course if it's a 401K you can still max that out and still contribute to a Roth if you qualify. I say do both. There is something to be said for tax account diversification. Have a traditional, a Roth and a regular brokerage. Adds more flexibility down the road.
![]()
Can't really give a blanker recommendation on this. It depends on so many factors. First of all, if your 401K is being matched you gotta contribute at least up to the match for sure. Beyond that, and assuming you even qualify for a Roth, it depends largely on your current bracket. Not only that but some people are really in an even higher bracket because they may be in the middle of being phased our for certain deductions and credits (e.g. child tax credit, student loan interest) which can push effective marginal rate up over 35% easy. In that case, I say take the immediate upfront deduction and save more. Of course if it's a 401K you can still max that out and still contribute to a Roth if you qualify. I say do both. There is something to be said for tax account diversification. Have a traditional, a Roth and a regular brokerage. Adds more flexibility down the road.
well said depeche
exactly what i was trying to get across... i always say save as much as possible, hence why I mention maxing out a 401k and an IRA in my blog
![]()
Can't really give a blanker recommendation on this. It depends on so many factors. First of all, if your 401K is being matched you gotta contribute at least up to the match for sure. Beyond that, and assuming you even qualify for a Roth, it depends largely on your current bracket. Not only that but some people are really in an even higher bracket because they may be in the middle of being phased our for certain deductions and credits (e.g. child tax credit, student loan interest) which can push effective marginal rate up over 35% easy. In that case, I say take the immediate upfront deduction and save more. Of course if it's a 401K you can still max that out and still contribute to a Roth if you qualify. I say do both. There is something to be said for tax account diversification. Have a traditional, a Roth and a regular brokerage. Adds more flexibility down the road.
well said depeche
exactly what i was trying to get across... i always say save as much as possible, hence why I mention maxing out a 401k and an IRA in my blog
Another reason the Roth is so advantageous is 40 years from now (I'm 22 right now) who the fuck knows how high the tax brackets will be
Another reason the Roth is so advantageous is 40 years from now (I'm 22 right now) who the fuck knows how high the tax brackets will be
I have a 401k, a roth IRA, a traditional IRA, and a couple mutual funds. I put my company match into my 401k, then whenever I want to put money aside for the long run, I always stick in my roth. If it is for something in the next 5 years, Ill throw it in one of my taxable accounts.
Another reason the Roth is so advantageous is 40 years from now (I'm 22 right now) who the fuck knows how high the tax brackets will be
aint that the truth
I have a 401k, a roth IRA, a traditional IRA, and a couple mutual funds. I put my company match into my 401k, then whenever I want to put money aside for the long run, I always stick in my roth. If it is for something in the next 5 years, Ill throw it in one of my taxable accounts.
Another reason the Roth is so advantageous is 40 years from now (I'm 22 right now) who the fuck knows how high the tax brackets will be
aint that the truth
Whenever possible everyone should have a traditional IRS or 401K, a Roth IRA and a regular taxable account. Have all 3. Then direct certain investments and manage and mix between the accounts as best for tax purposes. Diversity with a purpose.
its not all about asset allocation, asset Location is just as important!!
Whenever possible everyone should have a traditional IRS or 401K, a Roth IRA and a regular taxable account. Have all 3. Then direct certain investments and manage and mix between the accounts as best for tax purposes. Diversity with a purpose.
its not all about asset allocation, asset Location is just as important!!
Hot Forum Topics
- Tuesday 11/10/2026 350
- BEAT Your book 127,557
- 🏈🏈🏈 Fubah2's risky CFB bets 300,732
- I'm embarrassed for Trump supporters 63,592
- $$ALL IN ( 2x5uNIT=1-O,5UnitUNDER=4-2,5Unit over=1-O,5Unit ATS=2-O,2Unit=4-o_ =+ 43 Units 5,695
- Florida Man Tuesday 4,288
- *EdgeHunter Ohio VS Miami Ohio - NEW WEEK, NEW MONEY!* 2,876
- Bags Tuesday LARGE **Michigan State vs Duke** 2,357
- Trump's legacy? 37,169
- Week 11 Money 2,817
Warning - External Link
Report User
This post is spam
Delete Post
Remove Thread
Scan Results
Login/Register
Accounts are free and easy to create.
Search
