Should I Keep Vick?

I already started a thread on this but not I'm getting nervous and don't want to make the wrong decision ... 3 keepers allowed and here are my options:

Vick
Steven jackson
Ahmad Bradshaw
Gates
Larry Fitz
Miles Austin
Reggie wayne
Peyton hillis

I'm afraid Vick may have a big year and don't want to make the mistake of not keeping him and I should give it a go one more year with him ... never know with guys in my pool they may draft him in the first round if they have a hunch.  Help

I'd say you'd have to keep Vick solely because he is a top 5 QB when healthy. You'll find that most of your "elite" QBs will be taken so if you don't keep Vick, you'll end up with a Tier II QB, which is not so good...Even if he plays half a season his production could be the difference between a W or L that week. Personally, I can't see McCoy getting 17 TDs this season too.

Yah... of that group Fitzgerald is the only for sure keeper.

I'm tossing around a bunch of ideas ... but can't seem to really figure it out ... damnit.  Thanks for the input.

I may have to roll the dice with Vick one more time. 

And then keep Jackson as my third keeper.