Help with my keepers appreciated

I gotta choose 4 from the following:

McCoy, AJ Green, Demarch Murray, David Wilson, Ryan Mathews, Pierre Garcon, Desean Jackson, Eli Manning.

I have the 3rd overall pick in a non-snaking draft.  I'm leaning McCoy, Green, Wilson, and Garcon- but that last spot could be anyone.  Any suggestions?

PPR or non? What's your starting lineup? (how many rb, wr, etc)

I think you have it right, but I would genuinely take Murray over Wilson. I just don't fully trust Wilson as Brown could steal touches and tds. My take is go with the clear #1 and that's Murray. To me, Wilson is the #1 but Brown isn't too far behind and should could be a vulture.

I wouldn't frown on you for dropping Murray for Wilson.

Mathews - he has health issues and to me it's rbbc
Djax - screw him. he's inconsistent and that means you have two from Philly (which unless it's a prime team, I usually avoid)
Eli - He's a 8th round pick, maybe later. QB is deep.

GL

thanks Frozen

non-ppr.  Standard scoring.  QB, 3 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE- no flex.

I'm going to bat this around for a bit.

Definitely Green and McCoy. Then I would lean Murray. And since your format has no flex, I would take Garcon over Wilson. But would have to seriously think about it.