Carpenter or Reyes?

Question

5 player keeper league. No round designation, just keep any 5. I've already penciled in: Miguel Cabrera, Joey Votto, Bryce Harper, and Adam Wainright.

I'm leaning to Carpenter for the last spot. Reyes is older, and an injury risk. Carp is solid, and will have 2B eligibility this season. I like "sure things" when it comes to the first few rounds. Reyes is more risk than reward going forward, IMO. Who you guys like?

Jose_Reyes · Answer

5 player keeper league. No round designation, just keep any 5. I've already penciled in: Miguel Cabrera, Joey Votto, Bryce Harper, and Adam Wainright.

I'm leaning to Carpenter for the last spot. Reyes is older, and an injury risk. Carp is solid, and will have 2B eligibility this season. I like "sure things" when it comes to the first few rounds. Reyes is more risk than reward going forward, IMO. Who you guys like?

BWS77 · Answer

Carpenter and it&#x27;s not even close.   You can get Reyes back at some point if you&#x27;re attached to him.  Too much injury risk

chillinmcm · Answer

Absolutely Carpenter no doubt about it.

Jose_Reyes · Answer

Thanks guys.  Reyes is my favorite player, but I&#x27;ve rarely had him on my fantasy teams.  Hate the injury risk players.  Appreciate the input.

timdogs17 · Answer

Carp

Carpenter or Reyes?

Hot Forum Topics