Am I crazy for wanting to start Sanu over Roddy?

I would lean toward Roddy just because they are playing the Bears and should score a ton of points.  Roddy publicly guaranteed a TD last week and didn't come through so I think he should have a decent bounceback week.  Sanu should fill in at #1 with Green out so I think you have a solid option either way - tough call but I give a slight edge toward Roddy just because of the matchup

No you are not crazy. If it were me, I wouldn't even own Roddy, but that's a moot point.

I had Roddy 2 years ago, and it's now a given. Rarely will Roddy and Julio both have a good game. It's usually one guy gets 8-10 catches, 100 yards, and a TD. The other guy doesn't do too much, and that other guy is usually Roddy White.

How is it crazy to go with a guy that has been producing week after week, and going to be the main target today? If Roddy is "the guy" today, he will probably get more than Sanu, but I'd rather go with the safer play with slightly less upside.

I see Roddy having a ceiling of 16 pts in a non PPR, while Sanu is likely at least in the 7-10 range with not much chance of being a bust.