Quote Originally Posted by VegasMaxx:
I'm pretty sure most cappers (and ratings sites like kenpom) had the ACC ranked the highest, I think ACC had a winning record vs Big East this year too.
UConn 76-63 Miami (neutral)
PItt (away) 56-48 FSU
Marquette (away) 68-65 NC St.
Cuse (home) 73-70 UVA
Prov (away) 76-81 BC
Prov (home) 66-78 Miami (NIT tourney)
ND (neutral) 87-102 UNC
Cinci (neutral) 47-58 FSU
GT (neutral) 75-48 Maryland
GT (away) 67-76 Duke
Seton Hall (neutral) 77-73 VT
St. Johns (away) 70-82 BC
St. Johns (home) 67-82 VT
St. Johns (home) 56-70 Miami
St. Johns (home) 69-76 Duke
S. Florida (away) 75-77 UVA
Rutgers (away) 75-97 UNC
Big East was 6-11 vs. ACC
Big East bottom 4 teams were 0-6 vs. the ACC
Big East top 4 teams were 2-0 vs. ACC
Big East middle 8 teams were 3-5 vs. ACC
ACC bottom 3 teams were 1-2 vs. Big East
ACC top 3 teams were 4-0 vs. Big East
ACC middle 6 teams were 6-4 vs. Big East
Big East top 4 vs. ACC top 3 (0-0)
Big East bottom 4 vs. ACC bottom 3 (0-1)
Big East middle 8 vs. ACC middle 6 (2-3)
Big East top 4 vs. ACC middle 6 (2-0)
Big East top 4 vs. ACC bottom 3 (1-0)
Big East middle 8 vs. ACC top 3 (0-2)
Big East middle 8 vs. ACC bottom 3 (1-0)
Big East bottom 4 vs. ACC top 3 (0-2)
Big East bottom 4 vs. ACC middle 6 (0-3)
Point being that even though the ACC did beat the Big East head to head the games played were between teams were not a true indicator of conference vs. conference. The ACC had 35% of their games vs. the Big East facing the bottome 25% teams compared to 17% of the time the Big East played a team in the bottom 25% of the ACC... St. John's was 0-4 vs. the ACC in games vs. Miami, Duke, Vatech, BC.
65% of the games the ACC played against a team from the bottom half of the league in the Big East (47% of the time the Big East played a team from the bottom half)
If you were to elimate games that included teams in the bottom 25% from each league the head to head would be 5-4 in the ACC favor.
Unless more fair matchups presented itself this season the record of ACC vs. Big East does not accurately demonstrate how much better one conference is from the other.