Premier League Predictions: Moneyline Picks for Every Matchweek 5 Game

Chris Vasile - Betting Analyst at Covers.com
Chris Vasile • Betting Analyst 13+ years betting experience
Updated: Sep 18, 2026 , 09:00 AM ET • 4 min read

Chris Vasile's Premier League moneyline predictions for Matchweek 5 target value across all 10 matches, including a pair of underdog picks and two draws.

Chelsea's Morgan Rogers celebrates scoring their first goal.
Photo By - Reuters Connect. Chelsea's Morgan Rogers celebrates scoring their first goal.

Matchweek 5 offers plenty of opportunities to look beyond the obvious favorites, with several teams entering the weekend dealing with injuries, short rest, or misleading Premier League form.

My Premier League moneyline predictions cover all 10 matches, including a couple of draws and underdogs that could provide value in the three-way market.

Here are my moneyline picks for every Premier League match this weekend.

Premier League moneyline picks for Matchweek 5

Game Pick
Brentford Brentford
vs
Chelsea Chelsea
Chelsea
41%
Tottenham Tottenham
vs
Aston Villa Aston Villa
Aston Villa
27%
Brighton Brighton
vs
Arsenal Arsenal
Arsenal
59%
Everton Everton
vs
Ipswich Ipswich
Everton
55%
Newcastle Newcastle
vs
Iraq Hull
Draw
22%
Nottingham Forest Nottingham Forest
vs
Iraq Coventry
Nottingham Forest
61%
Bournemouth Bournemouth
vs
Liverpool Liverpool
Liverpool
45%
Leeds Leeds
vs
Crystal Palace Crystal Palace
Leeds
56%
Manchester City Manchester City
vs
Sunderland Sunderland
Manchester City
77%
Fulham Fulham
vs
Manchester United Manchester United
Draw
26%

Percentages courtesy of Kalshi, one of the best prediction market apps.

Start trading with Kalshi today!

Sign up now using our exclusive Kalshi promo code 'COVERS35' and trade $25 on any event contracts to get $35 — including EPL picks!

*Eligible U.S. locations only

Enjoying Covers content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account Add as a preferred source on Google

Expert Premier League moneyline picks for Matchweek 5

Brentford vs Chelsea pick: Chelsea

Kalshi win probability: 41%

Chelsea's defense makes them difficult to trust at a short price, but their attack gives them a significant advantage in this matchup. The Blues rank second in the Premier League with 10 goals through four matches and are averaging six shots on target per game.

Brentford have yet to lose in league play, but they have conceded in each of their last six matches across all competitions. I'm backing Chelsea's firepower to eventually separate them.

Tottenham vs Aston Villa pick: Aston Villa

Kalshi win probability: 27%

Villa's Premier League numbers don't tell the whole story. After struggling to score domestically, Unai Emery's side has produced seven goals across its last three matches in all competitions, including three at Club Brugge and three at Coventry.

Tottenham, meanwhile, have scored just once across their last four matches and enter off a 3-1 EFL Cup loss to Liverpool. With Villa's attack showing signs of life, I'll take the visitors at what should be an attractive probability.

Brighton vs Arsenal pick: Arsenal

Kalshi win probability: 59%

Brighton's underlying attacking numbers have been excellent, but their injury list makes this a difficult spot. Kaoru Mitoma, Yankuba Minteh, Evan Ferguson, Mats Wieffer, Jack Hinshelwood, Charalampos Kostoulas, and Yohanna are among those unavailable.

Arsenal also have the scheduling advantage after playing their midweek cup match one day earlier. Brighton can cause problems at full strength, but their depleted attack has to face one of England's best teams. Give me Arsenal.

Everton vs Ipswich pick: Everton

Kalshi win probability: 55%

Everton haven't been spectacular, but they've become extremely difficult to beat. The Toffees enter unbeaten in six matches across all competitions, including three consecutive Premier League draws before their midweek cup victory. More importantly, they've conceded just three goals through four league matches.

Ipswich have already allowed 10, and that defensive gap should eventually show at Hill Dickinson Stadium. Ipswich have shown enough attacking ability to make this uncomfortable, but Everton are the more trustworthy side at home.

Newcastle vs Hull pick: Draw

Kalshi draw probability: 22%

Hull's results deserve more respect than their promoted status will get them. They've already beaten Manchester United, held Aston Villa scoreless, and earned a 2-2 draw at Chelsea.

Newcastle now return home after getting hammered 4-1 by Leeds, with Anthony Elanga, Nico Gonzalez, and Jacob Ramsey all picking up injury concerns. St James' Park keeps me away from Hull outright, but their recent performances suggest they're capable of frustrating another heavyweight. 

Nottingham Forest vs Coventry pick: Nottingham Forest

Kalshi win probability: 61%

Coventry's return to the Premier League has been brutal. They've lost all four league matches without scoring, and they've now dropped five of their last six across all competitions after Wednesday's 3-1 loss to Aston Villa.

Forest's defensive injuries are worth monitoring, but Coventry are hardly positioned to exploit them with Haji Wright injured and Taiwo Awoniyi suspended. Forest just won at Aston Villa and previously earned a point at Liverpool. This is a home favorite I'm comfortable backing.

Bournemouth vs Liverpool pick: Liverpool

Kalshi win probability: 45%

Bournemouth's winless league record is slightly misleading, with the Cherries taking points from Newcastle and Brentford while remaining competitive throughout their opening four matches. That makes this more dangerous than it looks.

Liverpool, however, remain unbeaten and have followed a Champions League win over Atletico Madrid with a 3-1 cup victory over Tottenham. Injuries have reduced Liverpool's attacking depth, but Alexander Isak gives them the best finisher on the pitch. I'll trust the Reds in a tight one, especially with the Cherries playing their first-ever European game on Thursday. 

Leeds vs Crystal Palace pick: Leeds

Kalshi win probability: 56%

This might be my favorite non-Man City spot of the weekend. Leeds are unbeaten through four Premier League matches and enter after hammering Newcastle 4-1.

Palace have the opposite setup: a Thursday European match leaves them with a short turnaround before visiting Elland Road, while injuries have hit their attack hard. Jean-Philippe Mateta and Ismaila Sarr are out, with Eddie Nketiah also a doubt. Form, rest, venue, and availability all point toward Leeds.

Manchester City vs Sunderland pick: Manchester City

Kalshi win probability: 77%

There's no reason to manufacture a contrarian angle here. Manchester City have won five straight matches across all competitions, scoring 10 goals while conceding only two. That run includes victories over Manchester United, Porto, Crystal Palace, and Bournemouth.

Sunderland have been competitive since promotion, but they were beaten 2-0 at home by Arsenal last weekend and now face an even tougher assignment at the Etihad. The probability may be enormous, but City are still the clear pick.

Fulham vs Manchester United pick: Draw

Kalshi draw probability: 26%

Manchester United's ceiling is higher, but trusting them away from home remains difficult. Fulham just went to Anfield and held Liverpool scoreless before scoring three times against West Ham in the EFL Cup.

United have flashed offensively, scoring five against Ipswich and four against Sabah, but they've also drawn Everton and lost to both Manchester City and Hull recently. Fulham have enough defensive structure to make this ugly, while United remain too inconsistent for me to back outright.

Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

Pages related to this topic

Chris Vasile Covers.com
Betting Analyst

Chris Vasile is a betting analyst with over 13 years of experience breaking down soccer betting markets, with additional coverage across the WNBA and NFL. He focuses on finding numbers that are slow to adjust — whether it’s due to scheduling spots, player usage, or recent form — and explaining why a line is worth playing. His work has appeared across major betting and sports media platforms, including Covers, VSiN, BetMGM Network, and SportsGrid, where he’s delivered sharp analysis on both mainstream and niche markets. At Covers, he contributes to major tournament coverage and daily betting content, with a particular focus on soccer. He also runs the Game Day Wagers YouTube channel, where he shares daily picks and betting insights tailored for serious bettors.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo